3 ms·
I had interesting experiences with snake oil. I saw four acupuncturists. Two were useless, two changed my life. I'm talking about lasting, unambiguous, not-up-f
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
I had interesting experiences with snake oil. I saw four acupuncturists. Two were useless, two changed my life. I'm talking about lasting, unambiguous, not-up-for-debate physical changes that are still present more than fifteen years later.
I have no explanation, but I'm not going to deny my experience because of that. ("Placebo" doesn't do it. Not for this level of change.)
It's not as if mainstream medicine lacks snake oil. I recently researched anticoagulants after I was put on one and had an incredibly unpleasant, potentially fatal, reaction.
I looked at the original papers and the statistics quantifying side effects didn't make sense. There was no way to estimate the risks accurately, and when I talked to my doctor he said that they'd had quite a few problems - certainly more than you'd expect from the official numbers.
One manufacturer was caught flat-out lying about dosage and efficacy. The BMJ destroyed their claim that their product didn't need the same monitoring that warfarin does.
But the medication is still recommended - which I find rather strange.
And so on.
The problem with these debates is they become very tribal. It's easy for not very interesting people to assume an air of instant scientific authority and credibility by calling out "obvious" nonsense.
Unfortunately it's a very selective form of criticism, and IMO it's selective bullying directed exclusively at certain demographics.
The reality is that everyone believes utter nonsense, and every area of human experience is prone to it. We're not nearly as rational as we think we are.
Goop is an easy target, but there's plenty of snake oil in finance, econ, business, and politics. IMO it's far more dangerous and destructive there - and challenged far less often.
- skrebbel 9y ago> The problem with these debates is they become very tribal. Yes! This! This bothers me to no end. Somehow I can't let acupuncture fix me unless I'm also an antivaxxer. Thank you :)
- everyone 9y ago'"Placebo" doesn't do it. Not for this level of change.' Really, why do you say that? The placebo effect has been confirmed and measured many times, and can be very effective. Any clinical trials of new treatments must be designed account for it. Normally about one third of the control group being given sugar pills for instance will see improvements and some will be cured entirely. Theres even quite a bit of evidence suggesting the placebo effect can cause death. Read a bit about it, its very interesting. How is actually works is not understood afaik, but sugar pills, acupuncture, homeopathy, or just being told that something will happen by your local witch doctor can all cause the placebo effect. I think that salient fact here is that all the above fit into the same category.
- everyone 9y agops.. Looks like me and others are really browbeating you over this. Sorry! I guess stuff like this is frustrating for me because there has been loads of good research done into things like the placebo effect and acupuncture, yet people who are otherwise rational seem to completely ignore it. We have the very useful tool that is the scientific method, and great medical researchers, lets not simply cast them off.
- coldtea 9y ago>I had interesting experiences with snake oil. I saw four acupuncturists. Two were useless, two changed my life. I'm talking about lasting, unambiguous, not-up-for-debate physical changes that are still present more than fifteen years later. The "up-to-debate" part is not the changes, is that it was acupuncture that brought them up. You only know that (a) "you did acupuncture" and (b) "you had those changes". This is far from what's sufficient to establish a causal link. >I have no explanation, but I'm not going to deny my experience because of that. ("Placebo" doesn't do it. Not for this level of change.) You'd be surprised. If you'd have grown a new foot after the old one was severed, then yes, one might questioned the possibility of placebo. But for anything else, including e.g. a major growth disappearing etc, it can very much happen. Not only placebo can do huge levels of change, but even no-placebo-nothing-at-all, e.g. things like faith or optimism, can have similar effects. People have had recoveries caused by nothing we know in particular (verified as real recoveries by doctors with no known cause), that they have attributed to miracles, saints, etc.
- BoppreH 9y ago> I'm talking about lasting, unambiguous, not-up-for-debate physical changes that are still present more than fifteen years later. Was it back pain? I distinctly remember a study concluding that acupuncture was indeed effective at treating back pain (but not a host of other tested symptoms, and needle positioning didn't matter, which kinda discredits the philosophy behind it).
- literallycancer 9y ago>The problem with these debates is they become very tribal. It's easy for not very interesting people to assume an air of instant scientific authority and credibility by calling out "obvious" nonsense. Yeah, being "not very interesting" is the biggest issue in my life. How about not wanting relatives and friends who don't know any better to get scammed? >Unfortunately it's a very selective form of criticism, and IMO it's selective bullying directed exclusively at certain demographics. The reality is that everyone believes utter nonsense, and every area of human experience is prone to it. We're not nearly as rational as we think we are. Goop is an easy target, but there's plenty of snake oil in finance, econ, business, and politics. IMO it's far more dangerous and destructive there - and challenged far less often. There are scams in other industries, so it's OK to sell snake oil? Curious reasoning.