3 ms·
One hypothesis is that a given planet will have one dominant line that will squash the competition, so it's hard to witness multiple lines even if they existed
by jerf 9y ago
One hypothesis is that a given planet will have one dominant line that will squash the competition, so it's hard to witness multiple lines even if they existed at one point. There are possible "winner take all" elements; for instance, if a planet has two lines of life that each prefer the opposite handedness, it is likely that over time one of them will "win", as the (say) left-handed biosphere generates more left-handed proteins, which are poison to the right-hand biosphere, resulting in eventually there being one dominant biochemistry even if you seed it from the beginning with multiple.
It is also possible that life is, say, "medium" possible, and over the course of the Milky Way's life could be expected to arise a few dozen times and spread via panspermia, but in any given area only one of these may seed us, meaning that while there is variation in life, we can't witness it without traveling a long way.
Another possibility has been proposed that as our detection tools tend to assume DNA, and we look for DNA when "detecting life", that if there was some extremophile bacteria a couple of miles deep in the crust that truly was from another line of succession that didn't use DNA, or used it in a way unrecognizable to our equipment, that we could indeed even have run samples of such life through our labs and simply not know it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]