4 ms·
This is what I posted as a comment there. I have no idea whether or not it will be approved, so I'm putting it here as well. ----- A key part of your opinion
by btilly 16y ago
This is what I posted as a comment there. I have no idea whether or not it will be approved, so I'm putting it here as well.
-----
A key part of your opinion seems to be that "Art seeks to lead you to an inevitable conclusion, not a smorgasbord of choices."
However the most famous piece of artwork in the world is the Mona Lisa. The most distinctive feature of that painting is that it can be experienced in two very different ways. In one she is is happy, but not in the other. This is exactly the opposite of an "inevitable conclusion."
So this characterization of what art must do fails even when it comes to the most static of all possible media. The Mona Lisa has been sitting absolutely still for centuries. Yet only sometimes does she smile.
- shiro 16y agoHis view seems aligned to the mainstream way of storytelling form of art, which has long history of development (Alistotle said the plot structure was the essential.) But even in storytelling, there are other forms; e.g. Brechtian epic theatre deliberately avoids involving audience into the 'emotional journey', and also avoids presenting one conclusion.
- btilly 16y agoI'm also reminded of the mid-80s movie Agnes of God. The entire point of the movie was that you could figure out all of the events from either a scientific or religious point of view, both were consistent, yet they disagree on the interpretation of every single fact.
- po 16y agoHis view of "art" is very movie-centric.