5 ms·

Cool, I'm always sceptical of whoever they choose for the next Doctor but they usually make a good choice. For me, the actor is the least concern, what the ser

by nicky0 9y ago

Cool, I'm always sceptical of whoever they choose for the next Doctor but they usually make a good choice. For me, the actor is the least concern, what the series really needs is some better writing.

pan69 9y ago
> what the series really needs is some better writing And production value. I love science fiction and I love the "idea" of Doctor Who but every time I sit down and try to watch it I get really annoyed with the (in my opinion) juvenile/simplistic story lines and the poor production value, i.e. it looks very flat and VHS. However, having said that, maybe those two things are exactly what attract other science fiction lovers to the series and it's exactly supposed to be like that..
- krapp 9y ago
  >it looks very flat and VHS. Even compared to the old series? I'm pretty sure once I saw a monster that was literally just a gaffer dressed in bubble wrap.
- DanBC 9y ago
  > juvenile It's a young kids TV show, aimed at 12 year olds. Of course it's juvenile.
pasbesoin 9y ago
After the first year of the reboot, with that Eggles-can't-spell-it guy, I couldn't keep watching the reboot. Same formula over and over, each episode: Doctor to the rescue! Skin of the teeth! I enjoyed the first year of the reboot. The Doctor/Rose dynamic was something new and really well played. I'm no longer a regular watcher, but I guess I did note a few exceptions to the above. E.g. particularly the episode where... Tenant, I think, encounters a forward-thinking female member of the royalty. Good writing and chemistry in that one. Ok, and Donna was a good change-up at points, another different bent to the companion role. I guess I mostly wish the episode stories weren't so basically repetitive. For the most part. But then, there was the... um (sorry, not a remember the name of every detail kind of fan) "stone angel" episode, with a younger Carry Mulligan. Unique for being an entire episode with the Doctor at best making a cameo at one or both ends (just the end, IIRC). That was different. And, Mulligan did a great job. At that time, I thought she would make an excellent Doctor. Hoped, wished production might think of the same thing. Didn't happen. But now, here we finally have a woman in the role. I hope it adds some new aspects to characterization and the roles. I hope, too, that in might inject some new thinking and variations into the writing and story construction and focus. As for production values, Baker remains my favorite Doctor. Yeah, the sets were obviously sets, and some -- many -- of the aliens would have been at home in the Los Isoles (sorry, again, not the kind of fan who knows the spelling of that) bar back in the first Star Wars film, "A New Hope". But the characters were characters, and they showed more than a bit of heart. And, where I was, then, the syndicated broadcasts made for a great excuse to stay up too late on Sunday nights. Some more of that, please, Ms. Doctor.
- marblar 9y ago
  > Los Isoles This is the Mos Eiseley Cantina, in case anyone else is stumped.
  - pasbesoin 9y ago
    LOL -- sorry! I'm not sure I've seen it with a good sound system since back when it was in the theater during the original launch. Lots of times, on tinny TV speakers. "Excuse me, while I..." Sort of along those lines. Thanks!

by nicky0 9y ago

Cool, I'm always sceptical of whoever they choose for the next Doctor but they usually make a good choice. For me, the actor is the least concern, what the series really needs is some better writing.

pan69 9y ago

> what the series really needs is some better writing And production value. I love science fiction and I love the "idea" of Doctor Who but every time I sit down and try to watch it I get really annoyed with the (in my opinion) juvenile/simplistic story lines and the poor production value, i.e. it looks very flat and VHS. However, having said that, maybe those two things are exactly what attract other science fiction lovers to the series and it's exactly supposed to be like that..

krapp 9y ago
>it looks very flat and VHS. Even compared to the old series? I'm pretty sure once I saw a monster that was literally just a gaffer dressed in bubble wrap.
DanBC 9y ago
> juvenile It's a young kids TV show, aimed at 12 year olds. Of course it's juvenile.

pasbesoin 9y ago

After the first year of the reboot, with that Eggles-can't-spell-it guy, I couldn't keep watching the reboot. Same formula over and over, each episode: Doctor to the rescue! Skin of the teeth! I enjoyed the first year of the reboot. The Doctor/Rose dynamic was something new and really well played. I'm no longer a regular watcher, but I guess I did note a few exceptions to the above. E.g. particularly the episode where... Tenant, I think, encounters a forward-thinking female member of the royalty. Good writing and chemistry in that one. Ok, and Donna was a good change-up at points, another different bent to the companion role. I guess I mostly wish the episode stories weren't so basically repetitive. For the most part. But then, there was the... um (sorry, not a remember the name of every detail kind of fan) "stone angel" episode, with a younger Carry Mulligan. Unique for being an entire episode with the Doctor at best making a cameo at one or both ends (just the end, IIRC). That was different. And, Mulligan did a great job. At that time, I thought she would make an excellent Doctor. Hoped, wished production might think of the same thing. Didn't happen. But now, here we finally have a woman in the role. I hope it adds some new aspects to characterization and the roles. I hope, too, that in might inject some new thinking and variations into the writing and story construction and focus. As for production values, Baker remains my favorite Doctor. Yeah, the sets were obviously sets, and some -- many -- of the aliens would have been at home in the Los Isoles (sorry, again, not the kind of fan who knows the spelling of that) bar back in the first Star Wars film, "A New Hope". But the characters were characters, and they showed more than a bit of heart. And, where I was, then, the syndicated broadcasts made for a great excuse to stay up too late on Sunday nights. Some more of that, please, Ms. Doctor.

marblar 9y ago
> Los Isoles This is the Mos Eiseley Cantina, in case anyone else is stumped.
- pasbesoin 9y ago
  LOL -- sorry! I'm not sure I've seen it with a good sound system since back when it was in the theater during the original launch. Lots of times, on tinny TV speakers. "Excuse me, while I..." Sort of along those lines. Thanks!