4 ms·
I was with you until you suddenly got racist for no reason. Why does economics immediately become a zero-sum game when immigrants are involved? What does China
by fastball 9y ago
I was with you until you suddenly got racist for no reason.
Why does economics immediately become a zero-sum game when immigrants are involved? What does China have to do with America's changing culture?
- fullshark 9y agoMy guess is that OP was referring to real estate being unaffordable due to China's upper classes making investments in US/Canadian real estate.
- DonbunEf7 9y agoAssuming you're complaining about the phrase "the rise of China," it's not racism, but economics and the wealth of nations. China's economy has boomed in several distinct dimensions over the past three decades. They are part of BRICS, the five nations in G20 who like to talk to each other about how fast their burgeoning markets are growing. And, due to the way trade works, China's rise has changed how folks in the USA value and purchase goods. I'm sorry if this feels racist to you, but I can't fix you.
- jorvi 9y agoDude.. [1] People have become waaaay to adept at pulling the victimhood card as soon as something either doesn't fit their narrative or disadvantages them. It needs to stop. [1]http://i.huffpost.com/gen/1564426/original.jpg http://i.huffpost.com/gen/1564426/original.jpg
- fastball 9y agoA. I was talking about the "immigration" bullet point, and when modern Americans talk about immigration, they don't mean "white Europeans coming to America", like they did back in the day with Irish and whoever. I have not seen an anti-immigration argument in decades that didn't have racist undertones. B. Not really sure what China's middle class has to do with America's middle class, but OK. C. I think the modern leftist victim complex is a load of hogwash and I don't think immigrants are always a good thing.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoIf you feel complaining about illegal immigration is racist, then you have no real understanding of what racism is. Racism is discrimination based on race, which is based on skin color, language, or culture. (Most) people aren't complaining about illegal immigration because of the color of their skin, but because of the economic impact of millions of lower-class laborers displacing skilled jobs for near minimum wage combined with the cultural dilution that occurs when millions of people from a single culture migrate to an area. An argument can be made that there are some who have racist undertones in the way they portray their worries, but you are doing a disservice by dismissing everyone who raises real economic concerns from illegal immigration because you perceive it as racism. Edit: to those downvoting me, can you please explain why? If I have a flaw in my statement, it would help me if I understand what it is.
- fastball 9y agoHe said "immigration", not "illegal immigration". Good try though.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoThat is a good point, I misread that. Thank you.
- concede_pluto 9y agoReal estate has been zero sum ever since we ran out of frontier. Employment is zero sum when immigrants (of any race) try to add a lot of labor supply and minimal demand to an economy that already had a severe job shortage.
- hobs 9y agoWe have gigantic amounts of real estate effectively unoccupied in the united states, we are 179th in terms of population density for countries (almost the very bottom.) Immigrants do not add "minimal demand", immigrants drive significant demand and expand communities, for example, bloomberg reporting that gas prices dropping may have a contributing factor that immigrants driving less this summer. Lastly, our use of technology means that nothing is a zero sum game, we have created industries and growth through the use of various pulses of migrants and they are one of the core pieces of american success.
- concede_pluto 9y agoWhen we had a frontier, we had a surplus of habitable land and resources and immigration was a quick way to make the most use of it. That's over now, and we're spreading the same wealth among more and more people. An migrant worker creates less demand than a native doing the same job, because they're trying to live austerely and remit as much of their income as they possibly can out of our economy and back to their family's. They aren't building out water and power homesteading our uninhabitable scrub, they're living ten to an apartment near the few jobs.
- LyndsySimon 9y ago> I was with you until you suddenly got racist for no reason. This is ridiculous. What exactly about GP's comment suggests that they believe that some people are inferior by virtue of their race?