4 ms·
You live in a country where medical people of any sort (doctors, medical suppliers, etc) can be sued without scientific evidence that they harmed anyone. They w
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
You live in a country where medical people of any sort (doctors, medical suppliers, etc) can be sued without scientific evidence that they harmed anyone. They will face trial with a jury having no ability to evaluate scientific evidence and who will make a decision based on who is more sympathetic. The plaintiff's lawyer may pretend to be a psychic and still be awarded millions of dollars rather than being laughed out of court (http://www.nytimes.com/2004/01/31/politics/campaign/31EDWA.html http://www.nytimes.com/2004/01/31/politics/campaign/31EDWA.h...).
Is it any surprise that everyone involved goes out of their way to avoid any hint of possible legal liability?
- sliverstorm 16y agoA million times yes. I am convinced many of the issues with systems everywhere in America could be fixed by less frivolous litigation.
- megamark16 16y agoMy best friend is in the middle of his residency and this is what I hear from him A LOT.
- jbooth 16y agoWell, it's not like he's going to say "I'm the problem". Check my link above about the size of tort costs in the USA compared to overall medical cost, and their respective inflations.
- jerf 16y agoThe worst thing about liability is not the first-order costs, but the second-order costs. I'd make up an example, but all you need to do is read the posted article. Even if we say for the sake of argument that every last penny of what he spent was because of lawsuits, just to simplify things, the lawsuit cost to him is still utterly dwarfed by the opportunity cost to him of jumping through all those hoops and having his life shredded by sleep apnea for several unnecessary weeks vs. the way it could have gone: "You know, it does sound like you have sleep apnea. Diagnosing it definitively is hard, but let's send you home with a test CPAP for a week and see how it goes. I'll get you one from the back and you can start tonight." Your tort statistics won't include anything about making this guy suffer, or the fact that going with serious sleep apnea for an unnecessary month may well be taking months off his life, or the extra income lost and just general worsening of quality of life, yet they are by far the larger factor here. People on HN are prone to treat every medical issue as if the doctor is choosing between two medicines where one will save you, one will kill you, no medicine will kill you, and only the amazing skill and training of the doctor can resolve the incredible conundrum of which to choose. But really, there's no need to treat every medical issue that way, only the ones that actually are that critical. Abstractly, there's very little reason that my scenario above shouldn't be the way it actually happens. CPAP machines won't kill you if it isn't sleep apnea. (A quick Google search on "cpap fatality" has a lot of links about dying because you didn't wear the mask, albeit hypotheticals.) You probably can't get into a sleep study this very night anyhow, so trying that out isn't that great a loss. Silly scenarios ending in death can be constructed but the probability of them is negligible, and that's a stupid base to build policy on... but here we are. Meanwhile, in the real world, he really is suffering.
- Sukotto 16y agoCertainly we want to reduce/eliminate frivolous lawsuits. The (really hard) problem is finding a good way to do so.
- mattmaroon 16y agoI don't think that's quite accurate. They could be improved, certainly, but tort reform would still leave our healthcare system woefully overpriced and underperforming. The amount of money it costs is trivial compared to lifestyle choices like being overweight.
- ErrantX 16y agoIt seems crazy that modifying the machine doesn't invalidate any legal claim if it goes wrong (aka a warranty)
- jbooth 16y agoMedical tort costs in 2007 were 30 billion and have been increasing at about 5% a year for the last 10 years (http://www.towersperrin.com/tp/getwebcachedoc?webc=USA/2008/200811/2008_tort_costs_trends.pdf http://www.towersperrin.com/tp/getwebcachedoc?webc=USA/2008/...) Meanwhile, medical costs are more on the order of 2 trillion and have been increasing by over 15 % a year for the last 10 years. I don't think liability is really the main cost driver here. I'd look at profits first. $2k to do a sleep study? How much work could that possibly be? And then they insist on another one? Not to mention the whole PCP -> specialist -> other specialist to get a frickin piece of plastic. Everyone got a piece there.
- orangecat 16y agoThe question is how much unnecessary expense is incurred trying to avoid legal liability.
- jbooth 16y agoThe laws haven't changed over the last few years, yet the cost of healthcare has increased way more than the total in tort settlements. Even though reimbursement of healthcare costs is a big part of those settlements. Given those figures, I'd guess that "avoiding liability" is a convienent excuse for running up the bill in many cases. If the laws aren't changing, and the amount of settlements awarded is actually decreasing relative to the cost of care, why is care going up so fast? Why spend more money avoiding liability this year than last year, if the odds of being sued have actually gone down? Of course, expenses incurred doing better medicine and not screwing up as opposed to reducing liability are probably a good idea.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI don't recall claiming torts were the cause of all medical inflation. I claimed torts were the cause of Daniel Markham being shuffled from sleep study to sleep study and of him not being allowed to hack his own medical device. Also, your argument is specious since it completely ignores the cost of unnecessary medicine performed in order to ward off lawsuits. For example, a lawsuit fearing doctor might order unnecessary tests and procedures with little medical benefit but, but which the doctor can point to in court and say "look, I did the best I could".