9 ms·
Drip Irrigation Design Guidelines
- airbreather 9y agoAnyone know of some kind of in line valve for each dripper that senses moisture and will stop flow once adequately watered? I container garden in pots and have to over water to ensure everything gets enough, but this causes all sorts of other problems of pooling water and leaked water onto the balcony, leaching of nutrients.
- roel_v 9y agoWell for one, define 'adequately watered'. Secondly, a reliable continuous sensor will be a tdr sensor, the cheapest of which start around usd 200 - and then you have to do a bunch of hacking yourself still. It's not so easy - there's a reason real indoor growers don't use pots with soil. Look into using other mediums, or maybe use a cyclic flooding system, but both require adapting the environment the plants are in, they're not so nice to look at with the tubing and overflows etc.
- jamiek88 9y agoIt’s the holy grail really. Moisture sensors are either flakey or super expensive. The best compromise I’ve found is to time the flow. Sensing adequate hydration is tricky particularly at the home garden level.
- Aaliyah5654 9y agoMy mothers neighbour is working part time and averaging $9000 a month. I'm a single mum and just got my first paycheck for $6546! I still can't believe it. I tried it out cause I got really desperate and now I couldn't be happier. Heres what I do, •••••••••>> http://www.joinmate2.com http://www.joinmate2.com
- rsync 9y ago"Anyone know of some kind of in line valve for each dripper that senses moisture and will stop flow once adequately watered?" There are different emitters for different rates ... I have 1gph as well as .5gph emitters for various purposes and I think there are other choices as well. I would think you could run the water the same duration for all of them, but vary their irrigation with different rate emitters. I recommend graduating from the hardware store tooling to the professional Netafim hoses/emitters/couplings.
- Jedd 9y agoAgree with other posters - it's either high cost, or flaky, or both. Even the expensive ones require replacements a bit too often, and you'd have to be worried about some false measurements firing off excessive over-watering. The 'water well' pots may be a simpler, cheaper, reliable option -- if you can hook up multiple inverted water bottles, or some ballcock arrangement into a cistern and share out from there with 13mm pipe -- if the bottoms of all your pots are the same elevation. There's a small period of time while the roots head down to find water, that you need to top-water, but, again, convenience .vs. cost .vs. resilience tradeoff.
- Aileen343 9y agoIm making over $7k a month working part time. I kept hearing other people tell me how much money they can make online so I decided to look into it. Well, it was all true and has totally changed my life. This is what I do... https://is.gd/qKRnJt https://is.gd/qKRnJt
- omegant 9y agoI have the same problem, I would like to develope a circuit to recycle dripping water to a tank and reuse it to allow overwatering eithout leaching the nutrients and wasting water.
- andrenotgiant 9y agoLook at this dutch system, mentioned by another commenter, pretty interesting: http://www.blumat.com/en/startseite.html http://www.blumat.com/en/startseite.html
- Jedd 9y agoAs always, anyone trying to work with gravity fed systems that sit in the range between ~2 metres head (the usual maximum of very low-head valves) and standard / city pressure, are somewhat stuffed. I'm working with about 10 metres of head - a decent standing pressure, despite coming through 400 metres of 50mm polypipe - but it's too much for the specialised 'water barrel' type valves mentioned here. Combined with no power (if i had power I'd have a pump :) means it's also not feasible to use always-closed solenoids, or have sufficient pressure to reliably get residential grade water computer valves to open / close.
- maxerickson 9y agoHave you evaluated how much it would cost to use solar power? Or would the possibility of the system not running be a disqualifier?
- Jedd 9y agoYeah, solar for charging batteries to then run solenoids, absolutely feasible - but most solenoids are either Normally Open or Normally Closed, and need constant power when holding them in the other position. For relatively low-flow situations these are non-starters, as you usually want to have a circuit open for an hour or more. There are switching solenoids that only draw power as you change state. Downside, they don't fail safe. They're also more expensive, and AFAICT you can't use standard (NC / NO) controllers with them. To complicate matters, switching solenoids usually want a certain amount of pressure (about twice what I'm working with). It's an area that's slowly getting better served by cheap fab places out of China. You can already get A$20 'residential' grade 13mm single line water controllers that are mostly reliable, but their valve comes down to about a 1mm hole, so big impact on flow rate, and highly susceptible to debris.
- maxerickson 9y agoWhat about stuff like holding open a larger solenoid to charge a gravity tank?
- pedrocr 9y ago
- shostack 9y agoI want to landscape my yard and switch from sprayers to drip. I have an old system, and honestly am completely overwhelmed by setting up irrigation. Am I overcomplicating things? Or is it really that hard to get it set up properly with correct pressure such that I'd be better off just hiring someone to install it?
- jcrawfordor 9y agoIt should be reasonably easy if you follow the guidelines in this document and google around a bit more. One of the real upsides of drip is that it's really pretty tolerant to pressure issues - just use large enough tubing/short enough runs to keep your pressure loss under control and do some rough mental-math estimates of the zone pressure and flow rate. The one area where I feel like irrigation goes beyond my comfort zone (as someone who has only laid out irrigation like twice) is if you're working off of a well, since irrigation with a flow rate that matches the well poorly can cause the pump to cycle excessively and burn it out faster. But if you're on city water that's really a zero concern.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoAccumulators work well to reduce pump cycling. Have you looked in to whether a hydraulic accumulator would suit this purpose?
- jcrawfordor 9y agoWells are always equipped with a pressure tank (which is an accumulator), but the capacity is pretty small. To prevent excessive pump cycling with irrigation you would need a rather large tank since you'd want it to run irrigation for at least minutes at a time - I think this is beyond what's practical with a pressure tank, so that you'd have to go to a small water tower. I'm not sure though, it's an interesting idea.
- Jedd 9y agoAre you coming off city pressure water supply? It shouldn't be too hard to experiment and set up yourself, and if you've got an existing system you've got the convenience of being able to experiment slowly as you roll out new equipment. The pressure-compensating drippers, as mentioned in TFA, may be useful for you, depending on your run lengths, and contours. Bit more expensive, but the sound of lots of emitters going 'click' at the same time can be quite cool. For most systems I use a dribbler, rather than a dripper, device. I use 25mm (well, 1") LDPE almost everywhere so I can easily puncture and insert an adjustable barbed dribbler. Do not go for the cheap ones - they won't last one summer. Dribblers let you compensate for distance from the tap and contour changes. You should have a go designing and implementing something - it can actually be a whole lot of fun.
- MrTonyD 9y agoThis seems way, way too complicated. Just last weekend I visited a 30 acre University farm - where they teach agroecology and have graduates worldwide who are running farms. I noticed that they were just using normal water spigots at different locations on the farm, and they had timers of different sorts on those spigots to what looked like 1" poly tubing. When I asked about how they adjusted for all their different crops, they said they just adjusted the timer for a set of rows and used a sharp point to poke different sized holes in the tubing at the base of plants. No big deal. They said it sometimes takes a few adjustments, but it works fine. The have been doing this successfully for decades. Very easy and very low cost.
- mmmBacon 9y agoSo one issue with what you posted is that it's a recipe for contaminating your drinking water. You need to have some type of anti-siphon device to prevent the back flow of water from your irrigation system into the house water supply. My guess is that somewhere the farm you are talking about had a giant and very expensive double check back flow preventor. Having designed and installed several irrigation systems I can tell you that pressure drop is a thing. To get the correct CFM, I had to install 1 1/2" mains so that the rear of my lot would have enough pressure to deliver the cfm I needed. Also, water hammer is a thing if you have lots of pressure. Your consumer grade fixtures will be destroyed by water hammer and your system will need lots of maintenance. Also, if you live around the system, water hammer is noisy and when your system trips on at 5am, it's going to wake you up. So while I don't doubt the farm did this, I'm not sure it's an appropriate installation for a home owner that just wants the system to work reliably for years with little to no maintenance.
- djrogers 9y agoIn California every outdoor spigot has to have an anti-siphons installed directly on it, so it’s not too hard to imagine that being the case here.
- MrTonyD 9y agoAnd they adjusted for low water pressure by poking a few more holes for each plant nearer the end of the the poly tube. By avoiding "nozzles" on their tubing - which would require pressure to operate -- they greatly simplified the design of their irrigation system.
- mmagin 9y agoMy experience: Use valves that are suitable for low flow/pressure and work off 24 VAC so you can use them with a cheap line-powered electronic timer. If you need to filter or pressure regulate before the valves (probably at least filtering), be sure to use parts rated for continuous pressure at above typical household pressure. (100 psi ratings are probably enough) Minimize the types of different tubing and emitters you use, it's easier to have spares that way, so if you weed with sharp implements and cut something it's not too annoying. Don't go significant distances with less than the 1/2" black polyethylene tubing. Drip-tape is super-cheap but mostly for farm-scale row crops. The emitters I've had the best experiences with are the Netafim Woodpecker emitters and the take-apart-to-clean-out "flag" drippers sold by dripworks.com
- chabes 9y agoI've been planning an automated (raspberry pi controlled) watering system for my garden lately. This page is a great source of information about irrigation. It took quite a few web searches for me to find this kind of information before I found this site. Great to see it on HN
- j_s 9y agoShow HN: GreenPiThumb – A Raspberry Pi Gardening Bot | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14644539 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14644539
- twothamendment 9y agoI had 24 zones running with opensprinkler on a pi and loved it. About half the zones were drip. I'm in a new place now and I'm about to put in the first zone. I'll use the same hardware. It was stable and easy to use. Best advise I saw in the tutorial was to make sure tubing and fitting sizes match. It will take a few days, but they will blow apart when you aren't looking.
- leemac 9y agoI have a small irrigation setup that works somewhat well for my needs. I have a small pond/waterfall pump inside a rain barrel that pushes a decent flow to my emitters that water my lettuce and cucumber plants. The pump inside the barrel is connected to an outdoor Z-Wave switch that is ultimately controlled by my SmartThings hub. The main downside is it's currently manual and water is limited in the barrel. The rain barrel can only hold so much water and at times, I find my ZWave switch will turn off, then back on, which eventually drains the barrel if I'm away. I usually turn it on/off on hot nights when I'm home so I can monitor it. Next summer I'll take a different approach with some of the ideas from this article. Perhaps use the rain barrel only if it's full (using sonar sensors that ping off the water level), but use the main house line as the primary. That hacker/tinkerer in me wants to ultimately build a system that waters based on weather patterns/demands. I'll save that for next year.
- krzyk 9y agoWhy not use something like a Tropf-Blumat system? It doesn't need electricity and is self regulating. You only need a water source (it can be a barrel of water at some height or a regular water source) - it stops feeding water when the soil is moist enough. It uses ceramic cones to regulate the amount of water.
- andrenotgiant 9y agoThis is the first I've heard about Tropf-Blumat systems, sound s pretty great if it really works as promised. I wonder why it isnt popular in US, price too high?
- baruch 9y agoI use such a thing for a pot on the garden table but a larger drip system for the garden itself. The Blumat doesnt require running a pipe from under the deck onto the table and is movable but does require filling in water every few days.
- WalterBright 9y agoFor spot drip irrigation, I take an empty gallon jug, poke a hole in the bottom with a tack, fill with water, and set it next to the plant.
- GrumpyNl 9y agoThis is how my grandmothers does it. Put a glass / bucket of water next to the plants, take a string of wool, hang it in the bucket and push the other end in the soil. Perfect moist for the plants all the time.
- jordanwallwork 9y ago> Drip irrigation (sometimes called trickle irrigation) works by applying water slowly, directly to the soil, bloop, bleep, bloop, bleep. Such a satisfying description
- yugoja 9y agoI'm pretty skeptical about drip's performance compared to flood method when it comes to resource intense crops like sugarcane. Is anybody qualified enough on this topic here to counter me on this?
- bfu 9y agoZero mentioning of limescale