5 ms·
Amazon possibly working on new stand-alone messaging app called Anytime
- seibelj 9y agoBut everyone I know just switched over to Google Allo! We all have to switch again? /s
- adamnemecek 9y agoAmazon should stick to what they are good at and stop releasing these also-ran products.
- gtCameron 9y agoWhat they are good at is trying a shit ton of ideas and then optimizing and doubling down on the winners. If they just "stuck to what they are good at" they would still be a small online bookstore.
- dman 9y agoThe issue is that they are slipping on things they used to be good at. They are a lousy bookstore now and even the general retail experience has seriously regressed.
- cptskippy 9y agoI'm not sure they were ever a good bookstore, just cheap and online. They became the incumbent and it's hard to supplant the incumbent unless they falter.
- iamdave 9y agoLegitimately curious, but what about them is objectively "lousy"? ANECDOTE ALERT: I love how easy it is to buy a book from them, my new James Baldwin novel went from "read a review on another site, found it on amazon, ordered" in about 3 minutes, and the book itself arrived a day and a half later.
- dman 9y agoCarmack has a good recent example so I will defer to him for an example - https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/886229891720630272 https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/886229891720630272 I would expect a store of Amazons scale to do a far better job of categorising and searching information than what they offer right now. Also discovery of new books is very suboptimal in my opinion.
- riffraff 9y agoWhat results do you get for that search? The first and most are actually about video codecs for me. Then you have the weird erotic fiction, but restricting the search to "video engineering" is 2 clicks away on my phone, 1 on desktop.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoAmazon should stick to what they are good Which is what? Cloud services? Logistics and Freight Routing? Physical inventory management?
- jklinger410 9y agoThe way I see it is Amazon literally is an "I also-ran faster 2 years later" company. Almost every product they have is a wildly successful variation on a mildly successful already existing product.
- Thriptic 9y agoI don't follow. AWS, fire TV stick, echo dot, Amazon fresh, audible; all of these are great products / product lines that have little to do with delivery of non perishable goods.
- cptskippy 9y agoIt annoys me that everyone wants you to play inside their walled garden. It's especially annoying with all of these smart speakers that function perfectly fine as Bluetooth speakerphones. I would much rather they augment my existing phone service.
- mc32 9y agoThere was a time aol, yahoo and msn were made to play nice and interop, will that soon be the case with these new messaging platforms?
- Jtsummers 9y agoAs I recall, that was a very brief period and then they all went their own ways again with an arms race to prevent people from connecting to their networks without the official clients. Google used XMPP initially with Google Talk, but then turned off federation (was it ever on? I recall it was, but that was a long time ago). We've had greater than a decade now of poor interop between messaging platforms. This is unlikely to change as long as these platforms are owned by people with a vested interest in controlling the experience (tying it to their hardware or other services or ad networks, primarily).
- dboreham 9y agoFederation did work. I had it configured on our server.
- nashashmi 9y agoAmazon echo is their attempt at a smart phone without a screen.
- cptskippy 9y agoThat's not how anyone should look at a smart speakers because it's fundamentally flawed. A smart phone is a very intimate and personal device. A smart speaker is the exact opposite of that. It needs to be easily multiuser out of the box. The Echo worked because it was user oblivious but the new communication features break that model and are decidedly user specific and functionally retarded.
- libeclipse 9y agoAnyone wanna take the bet that this will follow the same path their phone did?
- ice109 9y agowhy in the world is everyone so keen on entering the messaging app space? what the hell is the value for all of these companies? is conversation data that useful for training deep nets or something?
- oceanswave 9y agoIn my view, messaging is the best example of how bloat over time kills apps. Nobody actively wants to switch messaging apps, but with numerous apps that have come and gone throughout the years - from icq to msn messenger to yahoo messenger to Skype to WhatsApp to kik to Line, often enough it's that the app itself gets bloated to the point where the fundamental messaging capability becomes secondary and folks move away to something that just works - or is easier and takes advantage of a new paradigm in discoverability and that becomes where you find most of your community.
- btown 9y agoWeChat is the perfect counterexample here, and I think it speaks to why a company like Amazon would love to "own the bloat." For western markets, if Apple or Facebook is equivalent to WeChat with their pervasive messaging platforms, and Amazon is the equivalent of Alibaba, then the war between them alluded to in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WeChat#WeChat_Pay_payment_services https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WeChat#WeChat_Pay_payment_serv... tells you all you need to know about why this is a crucial battlefront. It's one thing when bloat is from attempts at software feature differentiation; that's what kills these apps. It's another thing entirely when you're interfacing with product and payment ecosystems, when your features make you the core way in which people live their lives. It'll be damn hard to stick the landing, but Amazon absolutely has to try.
- otoburb 9y agoThis hits the nail on the head. Western companies have seen the massive ecosystem that WeChat provides via their highly effective messaging UI and belatedly realize through their corporate and fiduciary duty bound value systems that there is a whole 'nother level they must aspire to. When web-based giants successfully developed and implemented private clouds they served as an aspirational beacon for CIOs to transform their internal technology roadmaps. CxO teams are now greedily eyeing the WeChat experience and saying to themselves "we can do that too!" in a similar manner. By the way, this type of thinking isn't confined to corporate executives -- WeChat is so appallingly all-encompassing that even pure decentralized plays (e.g. Urbit) use WeChat as a concrete instantiation of the type of end-user-experience to strive for, albeit in more user- and freedom- friendly manners.
- zanny 9y ago"Everything you've wanted in a messaging app" Matrix support and total federation integration.
- eswat 9y agoWish we would get out of this red ocean of competing messaging platforms and head towards something more open, like XMPP (at least Slack works dandy with that) or even how email and the internet in general works. I have five messaging applications on my phone already and there is nothing critical on these platforms that couldn’t be handled by a single, polyglot client.
- _pmf_ 9y agoThat's what Matrix tried to solve. Yeah, it went exactly as everyone expected.
- satysin 9y agoI just want a widely used messaging platform that isn't owned by Facebook (Messenger and WhatsApp). Sadly Microsoft and Google seem incapable of doing it.
- hashkb 9y agoWhen will it be available? Anytime soon?
- hydandata 9y agoEvery sufficiently proficient programmer will eventually write their own text editor, Every sufficiently large enterprise will eventually write its own messaging app.
- skibob1027 9y agoI think viewing this a just another instant messaging walled garden is short sighted. This appears to be the digital portion of Amazon's attempt to displace and disrupt the US mail system. Messaging/voice/video provide a secure digital communications backbone to every Amazon account, much like iMessage does for Apple IDs. As Amazon operationalizes its own physical delivery network (planes, trucks, drones), the USPS is going to be demolished and postal rates will rise dramatically. Amazon accounts link every user one or more physical addresses. Anytime will also link those users to a secure digital "address" appropriate for delivery of sensitive information like financial and medical records. With this hub in place, Amazon can act as a clearinghouse to functionally displace the physical mail system in the US and throughout the world. Most of what arrives in your mailbox would be more efficiently and securely delivered electronically, but to date there has been no centralized platform to digitally mail items so every bank/medical practice/company has had to create its own internal secure messaging system or rely on email. Amazon Anywhere can act as the pre-scaled missing link to solve his problem while creating additional benefits to Amazon by functionally requiring anyone without an Amazon account to get one to receive secure communications in the future. It doesn't necessarily have to succeed as an IM or video call platform in order to fulfill this role.
- mxuribe 9y agoThis is annoying for all the reasons typically cited...but what if amazon (or someone big like amazon) actually dove full-head into leveraging/supporting the matrix protocol as the foundation of their messaging product/service? And before anyone replies with "but then amazon wouldn't get their intended walled garden/controlled silo"...i beg you to ponder the notion that amazon has AWS - basically servers/services for hire - but that didn't stop microsoft, google, etc. from starting competing (similar) services. Imagine a future where amazon creates "chat as a service" based on matrix. Sure some firms/individuals won't need more than their own self-hosted instance...but enterprises - already experienced with aws - can add on pro hosted chat (a la matrix protocol). Amazon could even contribute to the mattrix project, even if only to feel like they're helping to steer the software updates to benefit their company. Overall everyone wins: * Amazon doesn't need to develop a new chat system from scratch. * They can make plenty of money hosting matrix instance servers for private individuals and more importantly enterprises (read: cha-ching!). * By contributing to matrix project, amazon can "feel good" about to contributing to open source. * Amazon gets free on-boarding of potential new customers. Use-case: small business sets up their own matrix instance...eventually outgrows that, then turns to AWS, and voila, they migrate their instance to the official/supported AWS matrix instances. * If matrix - like email - were to eventually become a more widespread de facto messaging/chat protocl, AWS would be leagues ahead of other competitors. * There is also incentive for the competion (microsoft, google), if Amazon starts this, because like AWS, the others would compete with their own chat/messaging platforms, but enterprise customers would have an easier migration curve - because all chat/messaging would be based on matrix...not unlike email platform migrations today. Maybe my thoughts above are pipe dreaMS...but beyond the feel good aspects, i firmly believe there are possibilities for businesses to make good amounts of money in this space...and all due to a very good default protocol.