8 ms·
As opioid overdoses exact a higher price, communities ponder who should be saved
- tcj_phx 9y ago(this article can be read by searching for the title on http://twitter.com/ http://twitter.com/, then opening the link in a private window) > Two doses of an injectable form of naloxone, Evzio, cost $4,500, up from $690 in 2014. The price of other forms of the drug, including the nasally administered Narcan, typically range from $70 to $150 per dose, officials say. The cost of naloxone [1] is an insignificant part of the cost of reviving an addict. The rest of the costs mentioned in this article are pure profiteering. [1] http://www.sigmaaldrich.com/catalog/product/sigma/n7758?lang.. http://www.sigmaaldrich.com/catalog/product/sigma/n7758?lang.... If you buy 5 grams from Sigma Aldrich, a 2mg dose costs $0.588. Add a few more cents for salt, water and packaging brings the cost per dose to $2. An EMS supplier sells a single "kit" with an intranasal atomizer for <$48 [2]... Someone on Reddit sent me 4 vials of naloxone. I sent them <$20 to cover postage. [Edit: these vials have .4mg naloxone. Needles were also included. I think the standard intranasal dose is 2mg.) [2] http://www.dixieems.com/Economy-Naloxone-Kit.asp?pid=2086 http://www.dixieems.com/Economy-Naloxone-Kit.asp?pid=2086 Naltrexone is very similar to Naloxone. It is used to keep people from getting high on opiates. Big Pharma has found a way to jack the price of this generic drug too. 15 days ago I posted about the Naltrexone rip-off: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14672338 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14672338
- Clubber 9y agoI don't know how long this country can survive with this rampant corruption and profiteering. When do we hit a breaking point, and what does that look like? I mean I read your response and think, "wow, that's horrible." Then realize absolutely nothing is going to be done about it.
- joshlemer 9y agoI guess one way it could play out is that as the corruption becomes more and more obvious, together with increasing differences in political ideology between red and blue states, an appetite for seceding from the United States could develop in some states, and if that sentiment becomes common enough, it could become a reality?
- Melanie343 9y agoI get paid over $95 per hour working from home with 2 kids at home. I never thought I'd be able to do it but my best friend earns over 10k a month doing this and she convinced me to try. The potential with this is endless. Heres what I've been doing, •••••••••>>http://www.joinmate2.com http://www.joinmate2.com
- Aaliyah5654 9y agoMy mothers neighbour is working part time and averaging $9000 a month. I'm a single mum and just got my first paycheck for $6546! I still can't believe it. I tried it out cause I got really desperate and now I couldn't be happier. Heres what I do, •••••••••>> http://www.joinmate2.com http://www.joinmate2.com
- Retric 9y agoIt's IMO more likely than most people think. I really hope we don't see a civil war in our lifetime, but historically democracy's are highly unstable. This time it might be different, but then again it might not.
- Clubber 9y agoA Civil War today would look like Afghanistan or Iraq, not like the one we had before. It won't be pretty and will probably end in authoritarianism the likes we've never seen.
- maze-le 9y agoA civil war in a nuclear armed country could be considerable worse than that. Just consider what would happen if a faction of the army with control over nuclear weaponry took a non-neutral stance...
- dwelch 9y agoFurthermore, I'd imagine the cost of the naloxone alone is a small percentage of the total cost of the emergency responders + acute care given in life-threatening overdose. The article doesn't discuss a recurring theme in medicine: acute care is really, really expensive. It'd be far more cost-effective to reduce the need for acute care by providing access to addiction treatment before things get to this point. Easier said than done I suppose.
- tcj_phx 9y ago> It'd be far more cost-effective to reduce the need for acute care by providing access to addiction treatment before things get to this point. Easier said than done I suppose. Johann Hari has pointed out that it's very effective to just give heroin addicts pure heroin and a safe place to inject it. Switzerland has 'essentially' [edit] eliminated opiate deaths with this strategy: [edit: added 'essentially' in response to tptacek's comment below because the swiss probably haven't gotten rid of 100% of their opiate deaths] https://www.irishtimes.com/news/health/johann-hari-heroin-injection-centres-could-save-state-money-1.2216986 https://www.irishtimes.com/news/health/johann-hari-heroin-in...
- tptacek 9y agoIn reports about the Swiss strategy and in this story about Hari I see plausible claims that Switzerland has eliminated deaths due to needle-borne HIV, but no claims anywhere that prescribing heroin has eliminated all opiate fatalities. Can you cite a more rigorous source?
- tcj_phx 9y ago> but no claims anywhere that prescribing heroin has eliminated all opiate fatalities. Can you cite a more rigorous source? I have edited the comment above to add a word. The friend who taught me about her opiate addiction knew how to manage her dose pretty well. Then the mental health industry got her addicted to benzodiazepines, which changed her tolerance. She overdosed on me when trying to get off the benzos. The fire department revived her, then disappeared into the night. Those two doses of Naloxone stabilized her for about 2 weeks... A lot of the deaths in the United States' present opiate overdose epidemic has to do with contamination of the heroin supply with more powerful synthetic opiates. When the supply includes elephant opiates, addicts don't know how much to use.
- nimish 9y agoIf you totally discount the good manufacturing practices and traceability that pharmaceuticals have to follow, sure you can hack together a cheap substitute that might not work when the chips are down Except for biologics, many drugs are not that expensive to manufacture. The cost is in proving they will do what they say they do on the package.
- maxerickson 9y agoIt's clear enough that the manufacturer is enjoying their market position rather than having their costs spiral out of control as demand increases.
- matthewaveryusa 9y agoDo you really believe that it costs upwards of 4000 dollars to track a little box with medication in it? For that money I hope each box comes with a solar rechargeable smartphone that sends a gps beacon every half hour.
- GhostVII 9y agoIt's not the tracking, it's the super long and expensive regulatory process, and the cost of researching the drugs. Remember that for every successful drug, there are probably many that the company spent lots of money working on, and didn't end up working out. Someone has to pay for those failed ones as well.
- anon946 9y agoHow does that explain that the autoinjector was $690 in 2014 but $4500 today?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mejin 9y agoI don't know about the autoinjector, but for a lot of medication the list price is there simply so that when the insurance company negotiates a lower price, the manufacturer will get a reasonable amount. in many cases expensive drugs can even be free if your income is low enough.
- Quequau 9y agoAfter struggling with alcoholism for decades I used Naltrexone to stop drinking five or six years ago. It wasn't a simple taper but when I had my last drink it was easier to walk away from than anything I could have ever imagined before I did it.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoThank you for posting this; it'll help me help someone who is a self destructive alcoholic.
- Quequau 9y agoIf it helps I used the treatment program outlined in the "sinclair method" which I found online and bought his book off Amazon. In the country I now live in, using Naltrexone in this way isn't exactly unheard of but it was definitely not the status quo treatment program. The docs that I found to prescribe it for me really wanted me to subject myself to antabuse (Disulfiram) which is a profoundly sadistic strategy that creates a major sensitivity / negative reaction to even small amounts of alcohol that can be incredibly distressing and even life threatening. Naltrexone on the other hand simply took away most of the euphoric experience I was getting from drinking and after a 4-6 weeks of using it every time I drank, I quit after a night of heavy drinking and morning of regret. After decades of quitting only to find myself drawn back to it, it was a profoundly liberating experience to actually be sober and not want a drink at all. It still is actually (though in a different sort of way). I have to say that drinking while taking Naltrexone was a pretty weird experience because many of the signals I'd grown accustomed to for gauging my intoxication were muted... so I "felt" kinda sober but at the same time clearly was not. I think if there is a major risk in this it's possibility of deciding to drive because of "feeling sober". So that's the thing I think people need to be really cautious about.
- dredmorbius 9y agoAlternate access: https://outline.com/R36DZt https://outline.com/R36DZt NB: I have no association with outline.com, nor do I even know who's running this, though if anyone has information on that, I'd like to know. It is ... staggeringly useful.
- refurb 9y agoBig Pharma has found a way to jack the price of this generic drug too. Take a look at what companies make these generic drugs. It's not big Pharma at all. It's small companies. Most big pharma give up on a drug once it goes generic.
- ivanbakel 9y agoHow can it be acceptable that you would declare people too expensive to save, rather than challenge the prices of a profit-making company that is bringing those costs in the first place? Shouldn't you be able to detect the sheer amount of corporate worship in such a statement before it leaves your mouth? It breaks my heart to keep reading about this epidemic, with such a consistent reaction of hatred from so many people. This state of vulnerability should be met with support, but because opiates are nominally pleasurable, everything surrounding them must be a failure of personal responsibility - of people getting in over their heads.
- creaghpatr 9y agoThis is what happens in the UK right now. The government decides when the life support machine gets turned off- they pay for it so it's their choice. Not a common or planned outcome, but an unfortunate byproduct of nationalized healthcare. http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-40423371 http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-40423371
- extra88 9y agoNot really comparable, that's a rare situation with no chance of recovery.
- songshu 9y agoCommercial private medicine and commercial private medical insurance are legal in the UK and do exist although the markets are fairly small. If anything private medicine is less regulated in the UK than it is in the US (for example it's easier to call a doctor and get a price list, on enroll at any time in a plan). The legal basis of not allowing Charlie Gard's parents to take him to the US is not related to the existence of nationalized healthcare.
- ivanbakel 9y agoThe Charlie case is not comparable - the question discussed by the court is not whether it should pay to keep him alive, but whether it's ethical to, given that he's constantly incurring brain damage and few people in the medical community believe he has any chance of survival at all. The justification used is that of "continued suffering", not cost.
- flatfilefan 9y agoCompare it to the money US spent on Afghanistan invasion and the explosion in opium production there. Where do you think the production goes and who is running the operations? Wouldn't it be fair to divert part of those budgets to help civilians in US to cope with the results? The bitter thing is that even Trump will boost military budgets, not much change here from the previous regime.
- extra88 9y agoI agree about the costs of war (though I think Iraq was a war of choice, to the detriment of the campaign in Afghanistan) but "nearly all of the heroin available in the United States comes from Mexico and South America." [0] This problem was also started with prescription meds, due to deception by pharma companies and lack of attention and mismanagement by the medical professions and government. This sheriff is an asshole. He says he doesn't want his deputies carrying Narcan playing paramedic, does he also not want them trained in administering CPR or basic first aid? [0] http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/sep/13/donald-trump/trump-right-heroin-coming-through-southern-border/ http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/sep/...
- robk 9y agoWhy is the price increasing as volume has gone up? Is it FDA-type regulation that's preventing new market entrants or patents? Or something else artificially preventing new market entry like legal risk?
- TomMarius 9y agoNot sure why you differentiate, patents are regulations too.
- extra88 9y agoPatents are intellectual property rights established by law. Congress passes laws giving the executive branch the right and responsibility to create regulations but much of the content of those regulations are not dictated by law.
- zanny 9y agoThe patents didn't exist until the federal patent office approved them, in the same mechanical structure a regulatory agency approves a regulation. It is still on the authority of the executive to approve a patent or not.
- darpa_escapee 9y agoThreaten to nationalize manufacturing of Naloxone, then do it if prices aren't brought down. If there's an epidemic and private manufacturers can't respond to the demand without raising prices by a factor of 10, something needs to be done. Annual overdose deaths have doubled over the last ten years. To bring a certain brand of hyperbole to the table, 2016 saw a loss of life equivalent to about thirty times that of 9/11. Some see that as national crisis, others see it as an opportunity to gouge our people, towns and country.
- refurb 9y agoThreaten to nationalize manufacturing of Naloxone, then do it if prices aren't brought down. That should do wonders for R&D investment in the US!!
- zanny 9y agoThe majority of useful drug R&D (ie, not more penis enlargement pills) comes from research grants and university labs, not from private drug companies. It is a great meme Big Pharma has spread as a means to protect their lavish profit structure. The US leads in pharma research because it has the best research universities, not because it has private drug companies and no universal healthcare.
- refurb 9y agoThe majority of useful drug R&D (ie, not more penis enlargement pills) comes from research grants and university labs Absolutely false. Only 24% of new, innovative drugs come from academia. 76% come from biotech or pharma companies.[1] And even if they were discovered by an academic center, someone still has to take it all the way to the finish line which is where most of the cost comes from. [1]http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2010/11/04/where_drugs_come_from_the_numbers http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2010/11/04/whe...
- dredmorbius 9y agoThe present drug R&D regime is remarkably ineffective. There's been little advance in overall mortality rates since the 1920s / 1930s. Much of that comes from public-health measures, including preventive care, water and environmental quality, food quality, risk reductions (e.g., safety standards on electrical and mechanical equipment, automobiles, etc.), through removal and reduction in contaminants (especially of environmental lead in paints and motor-vehicle fuels), an through, apropos this thread, reduction in habitual consumption of drugs, notably alcohol, tobacco, and various narcotics. What R&D exists has focused to a large extent on chronic conditions (far better treated through lifestyle changes), in specific high-value conditions (think impotence, though that's arguably a quality-of-life issue), and in treatments which offer often only very slight improvements in treatment. A notable exception would be the introduction of artificial birth control, notably hormonal contraception, "The Pill". In 1960. Fifty-seven years ago. (And yes, there've been incremental advances since.) The cancer that killed my good friend nearly 30 years ago? Still effectively untreatable. And the therapies used then were the same as had been used two, and for the most part three, decades earlier. Directed national policy sometimes is precisely the right tool to bring to bear. C.f., China. Or Friedrich List.
- scurvy 9y agoGenerally curious what the efficacy rates of opioid rehabilitation are. How many times does it take for someone to kick heroin? For how long? What's the cost breakdown for a turn in rehab?
- altotrees 9y agoThere is a big controversy about this in the area of Ohio I am from (overdose capital of the U.S., Coincidentally). A sheriff who presides over a country near my home is loudly deriding the use of Narcan, saying it will not be used by his deputies, due to moral and financial concerns. Needless to say, I have lost 8 high school classmates to the epidemic at last count, and of those, 5 had been revived multiple times. So I can see both sides. There is no easy answer, and this problem will not go away on it's own.
- enraged_camel 9y agoWhile we are dealing with this severe public health crisis, Republicans in Congress are about to pass a healthcare bill that will, according to the non-partisan CBO, result in millions of people losing their health insurance. There is really no word that adequately describes how disgusting it is.
- laser 9y agoWhy is ibogaine [1] still a fringe treatment for opiod addiction? It seems like a heroin -> methadone -> ibogaine treatment could get the vast majority of addicts cured. Instead, on one end of our medical system's pipeline we get people addicted to opiods, and on the other end we've created so many addicts we have to save them from overdosing. In this domain our "medical" pipeline is actually a disease-creating pipeline that's clogging itself up at the end... Research is still ongoing, but it seems likely that even the majority of opioid painkiller prescriptions can be replaced with cannabis. It seems then, that we can empty the pipeline by adding less opiod addicts in, by prescribing cannabis when possible instead of opiods, and clear out the end by actually effectively treating addicts. Unfortunately, our federal government is so out of touch with reality that it classifies both ibogaine and cannabis as Schedule I drugs, substances with "high potential for abuse", "no accepted medical use", and "lack of accepted safety for use under medical supervision". The irony is devastating, and it's ruining countless lives. [1] http://ww.iceers.org/docs/science/iboga/Alper%20et%20al_1999_Acute_Opiate_Withdrawal.pdf http://ww.iceers.org/docs/science/iboga/Alper%20et%20al_1999... [2] https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2016/11/a-new-test-of-pots-potential-to-replace-painkillers/507200/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2016/11/a-new-tes...
- dredmorbius 9y agoWhy are the opoid manufacturers who are creating this addiction in the first place not being billed for it?
- criddell 9y agoHow did they create it? Consumers can't buy direct, can they? There's always a middleman. Why not blame pharmacies or better yet, doctors?
- DanBC 9y ago> How did they create it? They mislead doctors about safe usage of their product.
- criddell 9y agoI'm not sure I buy that, at least not over the long term. People on the front line are going to see the effects of drug abuse more sharply than anybody. There's no way drug companies would be able to mislead a good doctor. Maybe once or twice, but eventually any doctor will start to see problems that they are creating. I think I would put most of the blame on doctors. IIRC, doctors themselves have a pretty bad record with respect to drug abuse and addiction.
- jtmcmc 9y agoYou mean like poppy plants? This addiction wasn't created by drugs - drugs are merely a coping mechanism for a world that people can't fucking deal with. The root causes aren't opioid manufacturing it's whole slew of things from poor physical and mental health care in this country, worsening job prospects for people, a culture that ties worth and value to working hard and monetary prosperity, etc...
- panic 9y agoWhile people's life situation is always a factor, the drug makers ought to take some responsibility for lying about their drugs to make them seem safer. Purdue Pharma in particular: http://theweek.com/articles/541564/how-american-opiate-epidemic-started-by-pharmaceutical-company http://theweek.com/articles/541564/how-american-opiate-epide...
- torpfactory 9y agoI think we could add this to Jeff Bezos' ideas for philanthropic endeavors. Hell, it doesn't even need to be philanthropic. Amazon seems to have no problem with razor-thin profit margins: Why not create a company which has no problem making and selling generic-only drugs at razor-thin margins? There would seem to be a lot of room to undercut a business who sells for $4500 what might be produced for $20. I think our capitalism may actually suffer from too much profit taking and not enough competition. I want the market to serve me (the consumer) not the other way around. I'm sure the producer see things differently... There doesn't seem to be a lot of appetite for companies to go after profitable businesses that don't have big margins.
- Noumenon72 9y agoThere would be a Jeff Bezos if the drug market was as unregulated as the book market. Because of the regulations, instead there will be a Martin Shkreli.
- ninguem2 9y agoAre these overdoses accidental or deliberate? The article does not seem to address this question.
- Animats 9y agoIn the UK, naloxone with an injector costs £20.58, plus £4.16 VAT and £4.95 shipping, in quantity 1. Total is about US$38. The price goes down if you order in bulk. The supplier notes "You may be able to get naloxone free of charge from your local drug service, or GP." Note that this, like ephedrine, is an old drug, out of patent decades ago. There's an opportunity here for a startup. The startup doesn't even have to make the drug; there are contract pharmaceutical manufacturers who can do that.[3] The startup just has to handle marketing, distribution, and FDA approvals. Here's a list of makers worldwide.[4] Auto-injectors are available from various suppliers.[5][6] This project could be put together by a small team and would get very favorable publicity. Then, on to replacing the Epi-Pen. [1] http://www.exchangesupplies.org/shopdisp_prenoxad_naloxone_prefilled_syringe.php http://www.exchangesupplies.org/shopdisp_prenoxad_naloxone_p... [2] https://www.fda.gov/downloads/Drugs/NewsEvents/UCM454757.pdf https://www.fda.gov/downloads/Drugs/NewsEvents/UCM454757.pdf [3] http://www.contractpharma.com/csd/categories http://www.contractpharma.com/csd/categories [4] http://naloxoneinfo.org/get-started/where-to-get-naloxone http://naloxoneinfo.org/get-started/where-to-get-naloxone [5] http://www.medicalplasticsnews.com/news/autoinjector-landscape-changing-as-suppliers-re-evaluate-mar/ http://www.medicalplasticsnews.com/news/autoinjector-landsca... [6] http://www.shl-group.com/products/shl-medical/ http://www.shl-group.com/products/shl-medical/
- mnm1 9y ago"In recent weeks, Butler County Sheriff Richard K. Jones has drawn national attention for vowing that his deputies will never carry Narcan because he doesn’t want them playing the role of paramedic." This is one of the sickest, most disgusting, most disturbing, most inhumane things I have ever heard. I guess police are not satisfied with just shooting unarmed people, now they have to let sick addicts die. So they can save $50, an amount that would be even less if it could be negotiated by a program like Medicaid or Medicare. At least it finally confirms the fact that a lot of police, like Jones, would rather stand around, do nothing, and let the people they are supposed to serve and protect die while they watch. What a sick, disgusting mother fucker. No, there's isn't a word in the English language that even begins to describe this lowlife. And the give this piece of shit a fucking gun? I wonder how many he's murdered so far without impunity?
- valuearb 9y agoHow bout requiring opioid makers to pay for needed Narcan doses?
- justanother 9y agoRegardless of whether or not you regard opioid addiction as a disease, please please consider the slippery slope you're sledding down if you buy into this. Who's going to deny insulin to people whose credit card statements show more than 3 Dairy Queen visits this month? Who's going to deny chemo to people who smoked too many Pall Malls, in your opinion? This reeks from top to bottom, and yes, narcan isn't nearly as expensive as chemo, so yes, the slippery slope is pretty much guaranteed to go there. Proceed with caution.
- eagletusk 9y agoWhy hasn't the price come down. Can we expect the cartels to start to manufacture opioids and anti-opioids?
- thesz 9y agoI think it is time to (re)read The Final Circle of Paradise by A and B Strugatskie. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Final_Circle_of_Paradise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Final_Circle_of_Paradise Situation in US is quite close to one described there.
- berzerk5 9y agoThat's why I think Kratom could be of huge benefit to a lot of people struggling with opioid addiction. It's cheap, otc, and a ton of people have had success with it.