3 ms·
Enigma was much more vulnerable to known plaintext attacks than modern ciphers are, because enigma was actually fantastically flawed as ciphers go. When space
by KirinDave 16y ago
Enigma was much more vulnerable to known plaintext attacks than modern ciphers are, because enigma was actually fantastically flawed as ciphers go.
When space isn't a constraint, it's fairly easy to greatly reduce the advantage a known plaintext block gives an attacker by using random padding. Now instead of having to try every key looking for your zip header from offset 0, they have N places to start. There are techniques to mitigate this problem as well, but it's much more of a hassle. In any case, SOME simple compression is generally the order of the day with stenography message passing; you only get a few bits per pixel (usually not even a byte per pixel) so space becomes a premium.
Perhaps known-plaintext attacks are how the FBI managed to produce an example of a message with hidden data in it. To me, it seems like such a thing would be very difficult to prove. Anyone with sufficient sophistication to carry out such an attack probably has the sophistication to hide their ability to do it (via, say, hidden truecrypt volumes as workspaces). Because the FBI & DHS has leveled some pretty absurd allegations at suspected terrorists in the past, including random doodles being secret attack plans, simple home movies being terrorist scouting videos (“Do you see the way the camera flicked towards that trash can? That's signaling the terrorists that this trashcan is a good place for a bomb.”), and innocuous phone conversations being elaborate code systems. In all cases, the DHS and FBI experts swore that only someone hyper-trained could ever detect the hidden messages; a normal person could not even if they were told it was there. It was BS, of course, but people can be so afraid of terrorism that they're too scared not to give that kind of argument credibility.