4 ms·
Probably true but it doesn't really take away from the point of resources being tied up by a percentage that is significantly less than 50% of the population.
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
Probably true but it doesn't really take away from the point of resources being tied up by a percentage that is significantly less than 50% of the population.
Rents businesses essentially "short circuit" the flow of capital through the economy. So a "one percenter"[1] buys a cabin which he rents through AirBnB to other "one percenters". Because he isn't a hospitality business he doesn't hire desk staff, a concierge, or pay taxes that are funding local government efforts. Instead the 'rents' just recirculate right back into the "one percenter" pool.
The absurd extreme of this notion is something like the vision in Elysium of a rich people enclave with no need of any human "non rich" staff.
I don't see that actually coming to pass but as Gates and others have noted, it is important to understand how technology can distort an economy and work on ways to repair that distortion.
[1] In quotes because it is a stand end for 'top n% where n << 50'
- wbl 9y agoIncreased affordable housing supply in these areas would help. Unfortunately residents often don't want it.
- blackguardx 9y agoThey generally used to be very affordable until highly paid remote workers and vacation rentals became more popular.
- mistermann 9y agoQ: What's the difference between a developer and an environmentalist? A: A developer is someone who wants to build a cabin in the woods; an environmentalist is someone who already has one.
- Consultant32452 9y agoIf you're talking about a true 1%er they're hiring handy-man types and maids. They're paying property tax on those homes, funding roads and schools they will never use. It's highly likely they are paying other state and local taxes too, including but not limited to income taxes. All of the other 1%ers who come into that area are spending money at local restaurants or other venues which is pulling money out of the 1% and into the hands of locals. If you're talking more like a 20%er, then they are either doing the same thing, or they live locally so even though they're not hiring a maid/handy-man, money is going from the 1%er to a person living in the local economy (themselves).
- mistermann 9y agoWhew, I feel better now that it's clearly going to all work out with just a temporary minor hiccup as the economy readjusts.
- Consultant32452 9y agoIf the citizens of these towns want more affordable housing, they are free to vote such zoning into existence. If they continue to shoot themselves in the foot, then I'm not sure how many crocodile tears I'm supposed to shed for them.
- mistermann 9y agoOh right, in a democracy "the people" make the decisions, I forgot about that. /s
- Consultant32452 9y agoThe smaller the government the easier it is for the people to have control. I mean, we're talking about towns of a few thousand people here. It has to be pretty easy to sway an election over a single issue like this if the people are in your favor.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI see it a bit differently, I started from a differential point of view like this; Assume the cabin exists. It can be owned by someone who lives in it, or someone who really just rents it. In either scenario property taxes are going to be paid. And in either scenario the cabin will be maintained by local service agencies (plumbers, electricians, etc). The only difference might be that the 1%er is paying a laundry and maid service, and a local to pick up and give out the keys to the place. There is no special "business property tax" for AirBnB/VRBO type rentals and according to Fresno many VRBO/AirBnB types don't actually report their income (this annoys the state equalization board), and according to the Sunnyvale city manager people who rent out rooms or their houses should have a business license but they generally don't and it is hard to enforce. My suggestion was that if you differentiated between a VRBO/AirBnB place and a bonafide hospitality business, like a Bed and Breakfast, there is both significant additional tax revenues and additional documented employment.