5 ms·
Do you agree with his jail sentence and permanent house arrest?
by pavlov 9y ago
Do you agree with his jail sentence and permanent house arrest?
- ideal0227 9y agoWhat are you trying to say? Is this a question related to my last view or trying to question me?! I cannot figure your point really.
- pavlov 9y agoI'm honestly curious to know if you feel that his treatment by the Chinese authorities was just (i.e. in proportion to the perceived crime).
- ideal0227 9y agoThere are a lot of problems with Chinese authorities. There are a lot of things I cannot agree on with them, and I am one of the Chinese people that are trying hard to fix them by doing real work. Moreover, China != Chinese government. I, personally, hate the opinion that Chinese people who has a "traditional" view is inferior. Yes, they might be "washed" by todays "Chinese system" or education, and you disagree with them. But, it is not their fault. And most of Liu's view is going towards the direction I really hate. Another example is his calling Chinese people "slaves transformed by the education system". Again, I am not saying the authorities did the right or best thing. But just Liu is not the person that I would respect.
- mcguire 9y agoIn other words, if I understand you, imprisoning someone for advocating white supremacy, say, is wrong. On the other hand, advocating white supremacy is not good even if it would be wrong to imprison someone for it.
- revelation 9y agoIt's a very simple question, you know. Love it when topics on China or India pop up. You get all the same subservient pundits posting, but anecdotally the Chinese bots have spelling on their side.
- dis-sys 9y agohow about just focus on the core issue here? the core issue here is how come someone with such an extremist style view got awarded a nobel prize. or you may want to explain to me how this whole "China needs to be colonized by the west for 300 years" crap is not extremist style.
- jaggederest 9y agoThat is not even close to the core issue. The core issue is that the Chinese government locked someone up for stating an opinion. An opinion not much different in substance than then ones you are stating in this thread. Would you consider it just for you to be imprisoned for your views alone? I would not, and I think that is also true for other people.
- dis-sys 9y agohe is not jailed for stating that view. the reason for this lock up can be easily searched online.
- pavlov 9y agoWhy don't you provide a credible source? "Just google for it" is generally what people say to support arguments based on conspiracy theories.
- ideal0227 9y agoSince that is a well known issue about him. No one thinks it is conspiracy theory. If you want to discuss about Liu, I assume you should do some homework first?
- dis-sys 9y agowhat I said is something well known, widely reported - he got jailed for a completely different matter. if you couldn't bother to even search for that, what is the point joining the discussion? let me know if google.com is too hard for you to use.
- xupybd 9y agoI'd imagine that's not a 'safe' question for a Chinese national to answer publicly.