3 ms·
We need to take a page out of the old Russian system. Get the younger generation prepared for a STEM field to excel. The USSR did a lot of things in hamfisted
by mc32 9y ago
We need to take a page out of the old Russian system. Get the younger generation prepared for a STEM field to excel. The USSR did a lot of things in hamfisted ways, but one thing they did right was strengthening their STEM education and cranking out very good scientists and mathematicians. We can do that too, if we put the effort into it.
Instead we crank out liberal arts kids and other low value add degrees --I mean, nice to have well rounded education, but don't add to the economy as much as they could in other fields.
China isn't getting to where they are by having a bunch of kids graduating with humanities degrees, that's for sure.
- notimetorelax 9y agoTo continue your analogy: get Russian younger generation prepared for a STEM and then see all of them go to other countries for work. If US companies cannot profit from diversity they would have to open offices elsewhere.
- mc32 9y agoRussian graduates would love to stay in country, but the the gov't and economy are both big turnoffs... so, while they would love to stay and contribute their "motherland" many who have the option, opt for greener pastures. It's a bit sad to see a country lose all its talent and potential due to bad economics and politics. If Russia just tried a little harder to open up, they would have the potential to be contenders. But the brain drain certainly does not help their cause.
- closeparen 9y agoWhat are you talking about? There are far too many STEM graduates already. Brilliant people with PhDs from great schools often can't find living-wage work in their fields. Becoming highly educated in STEM isn't just low-value-add, it destroys value: a smart person wastes years of his life and productive capacity training for a research position he'll never get, then (optimistically) gets a programming or finance job which barely (if at all) leverages a few of his undergrad classes. The economy, and basic human compassion, require that we stop wasting these people's youth and loading them up with debt. We need drastic cuts to STEM programs until we're producing graduates at somewhere near the rate at which we're hiring them. That, or a massive investment in private sector R&D and public grant writing such that the output of the existing STEM education machine can find decent, relevant work.
- mc32 9y agoEither companies i know don't know how to find the surplus of domestic stem students and thus hire from abroad (and actively complain about the changes), or maybe we just don't pay enough to syphon people away from the high paying liberal arts professions. Who knows, maybe the administration is right, we have a glut and need to restrict outside pressure in those fields.
- closeparen 9y agoCompanies for the most part don't hire scientists and mathematicians. Quant finance may use advanced science and math degrees as a signal to find exceptionally smart and capable people, but the physics majors at hedge funds aren't doing physics. What little work there is for math & science is in government-funded academic research. Engineers (real ones, not programmers) have a reliable path to middle-class life, I suppose, but this is mostly due to their scarcity. There's enough demand for new bridges, cars, and airplanes to sustain the profession, but not a ravenous expansion. That leaves technology. Where is technology education? There are some trade schools that will teach you to administer and support Microsoft and Cisco business-oriented products for a decent lower-midde-class life, though they are slowly being eaten by The Cloud. And then there's Computer Science, which is a precursor to working as a programmer only because we lack more direct pedagogical methods.
- pizza 9y agoWe definitely need the latter more than the former. STEM employment insecurity just drives up profitability of the companies that can hire exceptional talent for less than they're worth, and same for typical employees. Same can be said for most workers today, as wages have been suppressed for a while now afaik
- raverbashing 9y agoYes, the academic world is a racket. To be honest you don't need to be rubber stamped by academia to do research. Companies should have started to realise that. People should aim for STEM degrees, but there's no need to burn years on a PhD.
- tanilama 9y agoTo have a Russian/China system, is not really that easy. Russian/China system builds on a competitive hierarchy of exams to basically classify people into buckets according to their intelligence level. Even though it may be good on a national scale, it is indeed a cruel system to individuals. Your confidence or personality is least of this system's concern, and living a micro society where score is literally everything and the ones with low score will be looked down upon by teachers and peers alike and being told constantly low score meaning no future, I doubt such system will be welcomed here by American society for, you know, greater good. Disclaimer: survivor of such system, not really miss it though. It almost destroys my love for science, which only recovers many years later.
- xfer 9y agoIt exists everywhere. You can't just magically get into a good school in your respective field.
- int_19h 9y agoI don't think you can conflate the Russian and the Chinese systems together. In the Russian system (at least as it was), not all students were driven to push the limits. Generally speaking, teachers would identify those with potential, and push them. But no-one told others that "low score means no future". Indeed, the system tended to segregate the aforementioned buckets - bright students would go into specialized math schools - and so different messaging could be done to students in different buckets, and their peers would be from the same bucket, as well.
- vixen99 9y agoRomania also has a competitive school system. Surprising to me (from UK) to find that even the class (in addition to the school) you get to attend in high school depends only on the final published mark you get in the National Evaluation (taken in 8th grade) plus your course mark. The exams don't measure intelligence as such, they measure performance in the subjects examined and how else should one objectively measure this? No one defends the making of unwarranted perjorative conclusions from low scores other than as a measure of competence in the subject tested.