6 ms·
This doesn't touch the real problem. Nobody intentionally creates a policy that will take $20K from someone with $40K and give it to someone with $10K. When tha
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
This doesn't touch the real problem. Nobody intentionally creates a policy that will take $20K from someone with $40K and give it to someone with $10K. When that happens at all it's unintentional (e.g. 20 programs to transfer $1K that weren't expected to overlap) and people who discover that outcome find it outrageous.
Because that was never the problem with income inequality to begin with.
The problem isn't that one person makes $10,000 while another makes $40,000. Those people are both struggling. The problem is that one person makes $10,000 (or $40,000) while another makes $10,000,000.
Reversal never even enters into it. If you took $9,900,000 of the richer person's money and split it between 1000 poorer people, the richer person would still have more money. Even though that would imply a 99% tax rate.
- ronilan 9y ago> This doesn't touch the real problem. Well, that. But also the real real problem: Economic professors making up social theories by conducting a "simple experiment using a game" (and childish slides).
- KekDemaga 9y agoNot if the poorer people start with $101.
- yorwba 9y ago10,000,000 - 9,900,000 = 100,000 9,900,000 / 1,000 = 9,900 The 1,000 people would need to start with more than $90,100 before rank reversal occurs.
- RangerScience 9y agoWell, right, but now you've got the issue of perception. The message I got from the whole "1%" slogan was just this: That it's not even close. If I think it's close, then what the researched observed may kick in, even if it's no where near close.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Nobody intentionally creates a policy that will take $20K from someone with $40K and give it to someone with $10K. When that happens at all it's unintentional" Actually, plenty of revolutions intentionally did just that, and much, much worse (as in executing aristocrats and land owners and giving all of their possessions to the poor).
- KayEss 9y agoI came here to make this very point, several large scale experiments have already been performed into rank levelling and it seems that the ranks don't stay levelled for very long, and the economic disruption caused takes a long time to settle out. Whether that leaves the countries better or worse in the mid-term than places where the levelling wasn't done (Russia, China versus US, Europe) is something I'm sure can be long debated.
- Kenji 9y ago>The problem is that one person makes $10,000 (or $40,000) while another makes $10,000,000. Explain to me, how is that a problem. Suppose someone invents a method to make lots of clean renewable energy very cheaply. They make a company and earn $10,000,000. Did they not deserve the fruit of their labour? Is that a problem?
- naasking 9y agoIgnoring the 10,000 externalities your scenario completely ignores, why should such a person enjoy any more compensation than any other job? Everyone is enjoying the "fruits of their labour" from their wage. What makes you think this deserves more compensation?
- golemotron 9y agoEnvy is the real problem. It has serious health effects [1] [1] http://charris.ucsd.edu/articles/harris_salovey_2008.pdf http://charris.ucsd.edu/articles/harris_salovey_2008.pdf
- falcolas 9y ago> What makes you think this deserves more compensation? The idea that we live in a meritocracy, and intelligence and novelty are rewarded more than being a corporate drone. We don't live in a meritocracy, but it's an ideal that many (probably a lot of folks who work in startups) would rather push towards: replace the "lucky" rich with the "deserving" rich.
- naasking 9y ago> The idea that we live in a meritocracy, and intelligence and novelty are rewarded more than being a corporate drone. But this argument assumes that financial incentives actually encourage and yield good work. Studies have shown this to be false. When you provide monetary incentives to achieve a goal, the outcomes are worse than the outcomes from people who pursued the same goals for no financial incentives. Without financial incentives, people do work that gives them purpose and meaning, which ends up helping other people more than any financially incentivized goals.
- pasquinelli 9y ago"The problem isn't that one person makes $10,000 while another makes $40,000. Those people are both struggling. The problem is that one person makes $10,000 (or $40,000) while another makes $10,000,000." No, the real problem is that the one making $10,000,000, (or ten billion), gets away with murder. Anything they do can be excused, and anything done to the one making ten thousand can be excused. Inequality as it pertains to those real social consequences of money is the problem, not who has how much of it.