4 ms·
In my subjective experience (as a Brit) British people often think the NHS is the best health service in the world Having experienced it, I'm surprised that Br
by jseliger 9y ago
In my subjective experience (as a Brit) British people often think the NHS is the best health service in the world
Having experienced it, I'm surprised that Brits feel that way. When I was studying abroad a while ago (which was not a great experience for other reasons... https://jakeseliger.com/2012/11/18/about-the-university-of-east-anglia-uea-why-you-shouldnt-go/ https://jakeseliger.com/2012/11/18/about-the-university-of-e...), I needed an x-ray and then a CT scan for what appeared to be a minor issue. So I went to the clinic and signed up for one, only to discover a week later that an x-ray typically takes 6 - 8 weeks to be done! I asked around and was told to go to Bupa facility (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bupa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bupa). To the Brits this seemed like an obvious solution, and paying in cash is in fact a good way to get things done quickly. It turns out that when people have something really wrong with them, the solution is often to just pay out of pocket!
This disabused me of any notion that publicly-provided healthcare is automatically superior.
- mikeash 9y agoIs it really a big deal to wait 6-8 weeks to get an x-ray for a minor issue? Obviously this is not ideal, but it seems pretty minor compared to the ridiculous stuff we deal with in the US system, especially if you compare to the pre-ACA US system.
- _dps 9y agoYes, it certainly can be a big deal. You are assuming that there is a reliable way to evaluate "minor" and that the bureaucrats in charge will make that decision well in most cases (even though their incentive structure, parallel to an insurance company's, pushes them to trade bounded-but-not-lethal suffering against the bottom line every day). I speak from personal experience in a country with an NHS-like "free" system. A close relative of mine flew to the US for short-term treatment of what was considered a "minor" eye problem, because he didn't want to spend 2-3 months functionally blind. It's true that the condition didn't threaten his life, but it did threaten his livelihood and personal autonomy on a daily basis; the bureaucratic process assessing priority decided this was a "minor" problem. It's easy for us as the general population who isn't suffering to decide "minor, non-life-threatening" medical conditions can be comfortably shoved to the side. *edited to remove language that could be considered inflammatory in the final paragraph, which was not my intent
- mikeash 9y agoAs I said, it's not ideal, but it doesn't seem nearly on the same level as the US system. I'd rather spend 2-3 months functionally blind than be bankrupted because of a pre-existing condition. Socialized medicine horror stories all seem to be along the lines of, "I had to wait months, it was very inconvenient," possibly with the addition of "I decided to pay extra to get it taken care of sooner." US medical horror stories are more like, "I couldn't afford to see the doctor, so I just hoped it would go away. When the pain became unbearable, I tried self-surgery. It got infected and now I'm dead."
- _dps 9y agoTo be clear: I'm not suggesting the US system is good or that the NHS-style system is bad. But I do think there is a systematic diminuation of the badness of wait times among advocates of NHS-style systems. I, personally, find descriptions like "it's not ideal" to substantially underplay the human suffering involved. And "it's very inconvenient" is, again in my opinion, a gross understatement of the suffering of losing your vision for a few months.
- arethuza 9y agoA couple of years back my son developed an eye infection that didn't respond to the antibiotic drops our GP prescribed. I took him back a couple of days later and we were referred first to a private ophthalmologist (who we didn't have to pay for) and then to the specialist eye department of the local hospital that same day (associated with the medical school of a world top 20 university) where he was regularly seen twice a week until the condition cleared up. I know the NHS isn't perfect, and I don't really care whether it is #1 or #10 in some ranking. But what I do know that over the last 20+ years of having a family with multiple serious accidents (rugby, climbing etc.), childbirths etc. they've provided excellent and timely care. Did I have to wait three weeks to get an MRI scan for a sinus infection that was recurring? Yes I did. Did I care if it was being used for properly ill people in the meantime? No I didn't. It's not perfect, put it is pretty bloody good.
- 9y ago
- DanBC 9y agoSome people in UK have very long waits (over 6 months) for treatment that should be relatively easy to provide and for things that are not minor. One example would be 'community based psychological therapies' - long form talking therapies. these are an alternative to far more expensive inpatient hospital stays. Without it people are subjected to increased detentions under S136 of the MHA; they use A&E more often; they use crisis teams more often. And those are all more expensive than a talking therapy.
- Boothroid 9y agoI don't think the gatekeeper GP system helps. What are GPs for? Hugely overpaid generalists supported by a powerful lobby (BMA) that cares little about patients and overwhelmingly about increasing doctors' pay and conditions. I'm hoping technology undermines their position over time.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoThe trend seems to be towards giving GPs more responsibility. My surgery seems to do a lot more than they did twenty years ago. You are right about the BMA though.
- 2skep 9y agoActually, I never understood this. Is demand and supply matched and this is just the lag in the system (ie 6-8 weeks remains 6-8 weeks forever) or demand is greater than supply and this number will grow. If it is the former then there doesn't seem to be a cost advantage for the wait. A temporary increase in supply could bring this waiting time to zero with just the cost of 6-8 weeks worth of x-rays outsourced. And then you have a steady state system with zero waiting.
- Boothroid 9y agox-rays are generally pretty quick in the UK in my personal experience - I'm not sure the 6-8 weeks is representative. x ray technology is widespread and the procedure usually very simple and non-invasive. It's the more exotic scans that take longer to wait for as there are not as many machines, and if you need a gadolinium contrast for example that requires someone to pump the stuff into you during the procedure thus skilled staff requirement, thus bottleneck. I suspect the temporary increase in supply you mention is not realistic for the NHS budget and there simply may not be the skilled staff available to step up resourcing, and there's a fair chance that some of the people requiring the x-ray will recover during the wait! This last point is I think one of the tactics the NHS has been forced to rely on due to lack of budget. It's sad really. Not to grind a political axe but I suspect the NHS's status as provider of healthcare to all migrants free of charge hasn't helped, and may even have been a factor behind Brexit. I have a manageable condition for which I'm seen in a hospital in London every 6 months or so, and every time I vist it's apparent that most of the people at the clinic do not appear to have been born in Britain. I'm guessing this based on their physical appearance, the clothes they wear, and the fact that often they do not appear to have English as their first language. It doesn't seem fair to me that people that have probably paid little into the system are getting some of the finest care in the world out of it (at this particular clinic I mean. It's a world class research centre) free of charge. How am I supposed to feel about this when I have paid in for decades and have to wait months to be seen for things? I'm hoping the pressure on the NHS budget will eventually force a change to something like the Dutch system, where insurance is compulsory but reasonably priced at the bottom end and everyone is ensured at least a minimum level of treatment, but has scope to buy a better level of treatment within the same system. If that were the case I wouldn't feel so bad about migrants bringing over their grandad for a heart bypass, or pregnant foreign women turning up at British hospitals in labour (there are documented examples).
- einpoklum 9y agoIn a country with decent health care, you should not wait more than the time it takes to get to the relevant clinic. i.e. the fact that you have to wait at all is ridiculous. There should be - and there typically are - enough X-ray machines so that the line is not 6-8 week long, it's 10 minute long.
- grey-area 9y agoIt's superior because of outcomes for a given cost, not customer experience. The suggestion if Bupa was probably made because of your expectations of prompt service.
- comstock 9y agoDo you have data that shows that the NHS is better value for money than most/all other providers? Because the data I've seen [1] doesn't suggest that. [1] http://wjmc.blogspot.jp/2011/03/us-healthcare-costs-vs-life-expectancy.html?m=1 http://wjmc.blogspot.jp/2011/03/us-healthcare-costs-vs-life-...
- DanBC 9y ago> Do you have data that shows that the NHS is better value for money than most/all other providers I'm not sure how your link supports your point. the US spends far more on healthcare than the UK, but has lower life expectancy. Even if you remove private spending and only include government spending the US spends more on healthcare.
- comstock 9y agoDoes it show that the NHS provides better value for money than other providers excluding the US? (It doesn't look like it does to me). The US is a massive outlier globally. They have expensive, poor healthcare in comparison to the rest of the world. Compare any country to the US and that country will likely out-perform the US on most metrics.
- grey-area 9y agoI wouldn't make a claim as strong as that, but it wouldn't surprise me that it's among the best value for money - it's a tradeoff - you could spend more for better outcomes but at some point it's not worth it any more. The important thing is universal coverage free at the point of use. The NHS is under severe demographic and funding pressure right now, but even that doesn't negate a clear advantage over US healthcare in terms of value for money as shown in the very chart you linked.
- Boothroid 9y ago'an x-ray typically takes 6 - 8 weeks to be done!' - this is one clinic, and they always prioritise on clinical need (as they gauge it). If your arm's hanging off you will be x rayed very swiftly.
- arethuza 9y agoI was in an NHS hospital last week for an infected bite on my arm. Time waiting for X-ray - maybe 30 seconds, mostly taken by the time for me to get to the X-ray room. Doctor in A&E said I needed an X-ray, I walk next door to X-ray department where they X-ray me immediately and I walk back to the A&E department where the doctor has already looked at the X-rays by the time I got back there (i.e. within a couple of minutes of them being taken).
- oliwarner 9y agoConsider the reason most Brits feel this way is that most Brits understand what the NHS is and isn't. Our expectations aren't that we get CT scans because we paid enough money, we get them when a doctor decides they're medically necessary, in a timeframe based on the urgency of that ailment, again decided by the doctor. Your post (and your anti-UEA PDF) make it sound like you broke a fingernail, you decided you needed multiple scans so went to the campus doctor (who doesn't have a scanner, can only refer into NNUH), was told there may be a wait while they book you an appointment and you immediately broke out your insurance to get what you wanted, regardless of medical need. Your insurance is yours to flaunt, but had this been something that "needed" a quick scan, you would have been sent to A&E (it's a 10 minute walk from UEA, 2 minute bus) and you'd have received prompt care.