2 ms·
I tried to vouch a sibling comment of Torba's, because shadowbanning people who call you out isn't going to change anyone's mind. If he's wrong, let him show hi
by throwanem 9y ago
I tried to vouch a sibling comment of Torba's, because shadowbanning people who call you out isn't going to change anyone's mind. If he's wrong, let him show himself to be so; attempting to no-platform him just keeps the question open.
The comment stayed dead. So it goes.
- tptacek 9y agoThat's not "shadowbanning". First, if you "showdead=true", you can see the comments and who wrote them. Second, that sibling comment was flagged off the site by users, not by some insidious shadowbanning apparatus. The "shadowbanning" regime that Paul Graham ran involved people being quietly banned from the site without being told; they would write comments and the site would do its best to make them believe everyone could see those comments, when in fact nobody could.
- throwanem 9y agoA sibling comment of mine, not of yours. It's [dead], but not [flagged]. Not all dead comments get that way by user flags. Some users' comment histories reveal a point past which there are only stillborns. I'm not sure that referring to shadowbanning here in the past tense is accurate. And "insidious" is your word, not mine. I don't disagree with the practice in general. I do consider it probably counterproductive in this case.