3 ms·
> Of course against all of this, the analog EEs laugh at us and continue to make things that just /work/. Uh, yeah, no. LOL. We just had an entire article de
by bsder 9y ago
> Of course against all of this, the analog EEs laugh at us and continue to make things that just /work/.
Uh, yeah, no. LOL. We just had an entire article dedicated to the weird and wacky ways that things can fail in the analog world (corrosion, light, standing waves, etc.).
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14765868 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14765868
There is a reason everybody moves as much of analog and RF circuitry into digital as they can as soon as they can.
Analog and RF are notoriously unreliable and disgustingly difficult to debug. Once things hit digital land, they become repeatable and debuggable.
Hunting down a stack smasher is nothing compared to hunting down some screwball oscillation in an amplifier.
- jpindar 9y agoBesides, the individual rf components like synthesizers, attenuators, switches etc. that make up a system are all digitally controlled. You don't need much of a microcontroller to control them - I generally just use a PIC - but you need something. And once you have a product with a serial or USB interface, some manager is sure to ask if you can add a LAN connection.
- makomk 9y agoYeah, and - to extend the smoke detector discussion - most modern smoke detectors are photoelectric and seem to have a somewhat involved state machine that periodically checks that the sensor is still working, calibrates for ambient light and component ageing, reduces false triggering, etc.
- MarkMMullin 9y agoI was once told a long time ago that analog is proof that god hates us :-)