7 ms·
UK has best health system in developed world, US analysis concludes
- tehabe 9y agoIs the abstract really shorted and the author is mentioned but as affiliation it only says "London". They really don't want to know much about the paper before you pay for this paid research.
- zkms 9y agoUse sci-hub to avoid paying anything to get full-text PDF.
- adambj 9y agoHey zkms, this reply isn't about the main thread, but bear with me. I happened upon your comment here (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13454185 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13454185) asking about the status of Parabix. Granted, that was almost half a year ago, so you may not even remember making the comment. But just in case you're still curious about Parabix, yes it is still very much in development! I've been working on it since about the time you made that comment. The most fully featured application we've built so far is icgrep -- an attempt to rewrite grep from the ground up using Parabix. It's still a bit rough around the edges, but it's usable and exceptionally fast. On large collections of files (10s or hundreds of GBs) it's often orders of magnitude faster than grep, and has more robust Unicode support to boot. We're working on some other pretty neat stuff too, but they aren't quite ready for widespread release yet. I'll see what I can do about getting our website updated! Thanks for your interest.
- salted-fry 9y agoThe full article is only 1 page long, and lists the following for references: http://www.commonwealthfund.org/~/media/files/publications/fund-report/2014/jun/1755_davis_mirror_mirror_2014.pdf http://www.commonwealthfund.org/~/media/files/publications/f... http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/2017/jul/mirror-mirror-international-comparisons-2017 http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/20...
- dbcooper 9y agoThe report: http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/2017/jul/mirror-mirror-international-comparisons-2017 http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/20... It ranks the UK 10th out of 11 on "Health Care Outcomes".
- staofbur 9y agoGood spot. BMJ won't be crowing that one though.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- inopinatus 9y agoThey could, because it also points out the UK had the "fastest reduction in deaths amenable to health care in the past decade" i.e. the most improvement in that category. If you take a look at the raw data, you can see the basis of comparison (four major diseases: heart attack, stroke, breast cancer, colon cancer, + overall mortality data). The biggest outlier for the UK is clearly the cancer survival rate, where it is more than two standard deviations worse than average and this has been known for some time. The underlying reasons are complex, partly social, mostly ones of late diagnosis, partly due to failure to implement good screening programmes; reports on the topic vary in their tendency to blame patients for presenting late or for comorbidity factors, but here's one of the more measured, from 2011: https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/sites/files/kf/How-to-improve-cancer-survival-Explaining-England-poor-rates-Kings-Fund-June-2011.pdf https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/sites/files/kf/How-to-improve-c... Most tellingly, with breast cancer, a 2008 report suggested that if you remove all the women who die within a year of diagnosis (whose cancers were likely to have been diagnosed at a very advanced stage), then UK survival rates fall into line with the European average. In other words, the UK has a problem with late diagnosis. Note that the UK also has a better cancer registry. Germany only captures 1% of the population, the UK captures 80%. Unsure whether the OP report has attempted to detect any resulting skew in the statistics. Bottom line: if the UK improves the five-year cancer survival rate to OECD standards - and note that the data in this report is from 2015 - then it will flip its position in those rankings and totally cement the #1 position overall.
- comstock 9y agoThis analysis of a report seems pretty bad, even with only the title and abstract available. Firstly, the report doesn't even cover the entire developed world, just 11 countries. Notably, Japan doesn't appear to be included. To be honest, I found that slightly offensive. Secondly the U.K. isn't the overall clear "best" of those 11. It's not bad, and does better on some things, worse on others. In my subjective experience (as a Brit) British people often think the NHS is the best health service in the world. It's not bad, and it's free. Waiting times are often long, particularly for non-urgent conditions. Compared to the U.S. system I prefer the NHS, but there are other options, and the NHS could provide a better service than it does.
- mboto 9y agoAs a fellow Brit I'd agree we're proud of the NHS but I don't think people believe it's the best in the world. We complain too much for that.
- comstock 9y agowell, this is all pretty subjective. But the attitude I often seem to encounter in the U.K. is "it's not great, but everything is bad everywhere and it's the best".
- hackerboos 9y agoFrance ranks higher in some studies. I did a lot of personal research after "Sicko" the movie was released.
- ramchip 9y agoI'm also really puzzled by the omission of Japan. It has the highest life expectancy in the world, I would expect a comparison of health systems in the developed world to include it.
- comstock 9y agoThe original report is better. This report is really about saying "the US system could be a lot better" rather than an overall ranking of healthcare. The way it's being used here, to say the NHS is wonderful, doesn't work very well in my opinion.
- cmurf 9y agoUnsurprising. We pay more money per capita, to get worse results, BUT at least we get to, in one way or another, exclude people who aren't paying their own way. And that's what red states in this country appear to want, because they keep voting for Republican governors who campaign on sabotaging health care and then succeeding. http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-baker-obamacare-red-state-20170713-story.html http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-baker-obamacare-r... Today on NPR I listened to rural red state folks who lament how far they have to drive to see a doctor. And how many times they've had to change doctors, because their doctor left the area. And most often they leave for cities where they can earn more money. So the red state voter gets conned into this nonsensical "free market" idea of health care as a product, they vote for this, and then when the doctor says "you don't pay me enough, bye" this rural voter is confused. And so now some of these rural areas are looking at forgiving medical school debt if young doctors will do a "tour" (in effect) as a rural doctor. Isn't government paying for school debt socialism? crickets And the bureaucracy of middle men and bean counters, it's a major employment sector now. Obliterating it comes with its own economic and policial damage. But that's the way forward, or it just keeps growing bigger until it catastrophically breaks. Medicaid for all. Wipe away Medicare, the VA, and private insurers. Bye. Apply strong anti-fraud measured funded and mandated by law. And fund it with some variable matching of Federal dollars because, yes, rural areas are going to have to be subsidized, like like we've done with roads, sewers, water, and telephones, since forever, because everything costs more in rural areas. Cities are cheaper in many ways because of economies of scale. Of course everyone else has a better system.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- IsaacL 9y agoThis really is a matter of what variables you choose to measure. For example, the US is by far the world leader in medical research spending - 44% of global medical research is spent in the US. (Until recently it was even higher). [1] On the same note, many nations regulate the price of prescription drugs - drugs where the initial R&D was done in the states. (Yes, drugs are sold at a huge markup, but that's to recoup the huge initial costs of research). In other words, Americans are taking it in the chin to invest in pharmaceutical innovations, which other countries then treat as a public good. An additional point that's often obscured: there's no purely capitalistic healthcare system in the world. Even pre-Obamacare, the US system was about 46% funded by the government. (As with the US education system, the availability of government funds has massively pushed up prices). [2] On a personal note - I'm a brit, but I've lived abroad, and the NHS is one of the reasons I'm considering settling abroad long-term. I simply don't trust the organisation as a whole to take care of my health. If you get assigned a good doctor for your condition, you're OK, but I have my own stories (and I've heard many others) of conditions being ignored or misdiagnosed, even after multiple visits. In contrast, I went to a hospital in Bangkok that was of far higher quality than the average NHS hospital. (Granted, this was a private hospital, but it puts things into perspective). One Israeli friend said that walking into a UK clinic was like walking into a clinic in a third-world country. It's shabby, the wait is long, the bureaucracy is confusing, etc. Strange as it may sound, I trust a for-profit entity more with my health, because their livelihood directly depends on taking good care of me. The common argument that healthcare can't be a market because of information asymmetry and doctors being in a position of power doesn't wash: the same holds true for other complex services, like auto repair, and the solution is simple: third party reviews. (On the moral argument, about affordability, I think with a truly private healthcare system entrepreneurs would be able to drive the costs down for people on middle-incomes, and only the bottom 15-20% would be reliant on government or charity spending). [1] https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/news/story/4233/u.s.-slipping-as-global-leader-in-medical-research.aspx https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/news/story/4233/u.s.-slipping... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_health_expenditure_covered_by_government https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_health_ex...
- rlpb 9y ago> This really is a matter of what variables you choose to measure. > > For example, the US is by far the world leader in medical research spending... Medical research companies will naturally gravitate to a country where the medical industry is particularly profitable: for example in a country where citizens pay over the odds for healthcare due to disfunction. If this is the reason that the US spends the most on medical research, is that really something that qualifies as a valid variable for some definition of "best"?
- ggambetta 9y agoAs a resident of the UK and a former resident of Switzerland, I can't understand how they came to this conclusion. Don't get me wrong, the NHS is great and the system works much better than in the US, but health care in Switzerland is just on another level. Before you say "but in the UK it's free" - considering what I paid for (private, mandatory) insurance in Switzerland, and the National Insurance contribution that gets deducted from my paycheck in the UK, I'm not so sure...
- guelo 9y agoYou could read the report. Basically UK spends less overall, 9.9% of GDP vs SWIZ's 11.1%. While UK ranks higher than SWIZ on the report's definitions of Care Process, Access, Efficiency and Equity. SWIZ ranks higher on Health Care Outcomes.
- JamesMcMinn 9y agoI don't think anyone, in the UK at least, thinks the NHS is free. Most people in the UK who describe it as "free" really mean "free at the point of use" (i.e. no invoice after treatment), but that's a bit of a mouth full.
- mjevans 9y agoIt removes an entire department and source of variable from a 'company' that doesn't need it. Ultimately you aren't going to deny someone coverage based on cost*, they're going to end up in an ER and 'written off' which will then be billed in to everyone else's costs. Worse, the outcome for the individual is often less good and frequently means they will be, overall, more of a burden on society than if they had received proper treatment in an early stage. Instead, the 'cost' of billing that is 'outsourced' to the government's tax collectors, which are going to be the /very/ last thing removed if ever.
- HarryHirsch 9y agoUltimately you aren't going to deny someone coverage based on cost For acute conditions, yes, but in the American ER they do not treat chronic conditions, like cancer, depression and substance addiction. That's a public health issue.
- galadran 9y agohttps://pastebin.com/ibZM0C8Q https://pastebin.com/ibZM0C8Q Some of the data from the Appendix on Equality pulled out. The difference between countries is quite astounding!
- coldcode 9y agoOne can argue about who is best, but amongst first world countries, it's sadly not hard to figure out the worst.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoThat depends on whether you are rich or poor.
- warsharks 9y agohaving had a fair amount of experience of the british healthcare system i find this very hard to believe, ive been treated like shit by them many times, been talked into an operation i didnt really want (i think they were extra keen because its a rare condition) which they then managed to screw up and cripple me. another little gem is my current insurance claim, i was knocked off my motorbike over a year ago, yet i still havent received a payout from my insurance, id assumed their lawyers were dragging the process out but by this point she has been convicted, my insurance company have been paid by hers but i still havent had anything back, when i asked my lawyer what was holding it up he said it was just one thing they need, they are still awaiting the medical records from my GP which were requested and paid for back in September but despite monthly attempts to get them to send it they still havent done so and every time i try and contact them to ask why im told that the medical secretary isnt in at the moment and only she can deal with it, but they will tell her to call me as soon as she gets back in, i have yet to receive a single call from them. i could go on to site a ton of other various reports of shit service that i have personally experienced let alone that of others i know. if i was insurable id have taken private medical insurance long ago and still strongly advise any healthy person in the UK to get private medical insurance ASAP, sure its an extra cost no one wants to pay but if you ever do get sick youll be damn glad you have it
- jlarsson89 9y agoAs a swede living in London, I was shocked to find the NHS still uses paper prescriptions that are consumed upon use, at least in my limited experience. In Sweden, every prescription I have is digital and tied to my ID, accessible from any pharmacy or hospital in the country and is not necessarily consumed upon use, I can easily reuse it and renew it.