12 ms·
Uber Backers Discuss Stock Sale to SoftBank, Others
- Animats 9y agoMust ... find ... new ... sucker ... and ... feed. Uber runs out of cash next year if they don't. If Softbank puts money in, it will probably be on terms very favorable to Softbank. Uber's funding rounds: [1] The "undisclosed amount" round in 2017 was reportedly not big enough to change the fundamentals. [1] https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/uber/funding-rounds https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/uber/funding-rounds
- kartD 9y agoAm I missing something? According to this (Link: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/31/technology/uber-limits-loss-to-708-million-in-first-quarter.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/31/technology/uber-limits-lo...) Uber has $7.2B sitting in the bank, with losses reducing ($708M) in the first 3 months of 2017. I'm sure they can get profitable or break-even in that time.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoI think the concern is that the value of each rider is actually negative, and till now this cost was hidden by VC subsidy. There are several ways this could play out. One possibility is that if Uber raises their rates, people will mass-migrate to Lyft. Whoever survives that war of attrition may monopolize the space.
- QAPereo 9y agoIt seems the "Death Star" strategy is at least as flawed as its namesake, and really, can they keep selling a fantasy of just-around-the-corner level 5 automation to rich idiots?
- ghaff 9y agoA lot of people still seem to believe that fantasy. I find that a bit puzzling as many of those people would be more realistic about other engineering timelines. But there's nonetheless this belief in door-to-door automation that's relevant in a VC time horizon.
- matt4077 9y agoI don't even understand how self-driving cars would help Uber. It seems their biggest advantage is their experience with managing all the different ways human drivers can screw up. The day Mercedes ships the first self-driving car, it will come with "Go make yourself useful"-mode where it shuttles other people from A to X. There'll be dozens of almost identical services that handle the transactions and insurance for 3%-4% of the revenue. Nothing Uber has done so far will be helpful in such a world. Because you won't need to manage humans, to grope women, or to break workplace safety laws in such a business.
- ThomPete 9y agoBy allowing them to not have to pay and subsidice drivers the primary expense.
- apendleton 9y agoYour model assumes most people still own general-purpose cars, and farm them out on the side. Uber's assumes it will become more possible for people not to, and that they will instead rely on trip-optimized vehicles available centrally on a case-by-case basis. I think they have reason for optimism there... For one, many times when Uber is in highest demand are also times when car owners most want to use their own vehicles (say, rush hour), so this notion that an Uber-like service can rely entirely on spare hours of personal vehicles is a little silly; sure, there are tons of idle cars at 4am on a Tuesday morning, but who needs to use them all then? For another, I can totally foresee a future where we move away from this idiotic practice of having the typical vehicle on the road by a five-seater with one person in it, which is hugely inefficient. Commuting alone? Have a tiny car. Going on a trip with the family? Enjoy this self-driving SUV. Need to get from DC to Florida? Enjoy this self-driving bed, and wake up at your destination in the morning. Etc., etc.
- joejerryronnie 9y agoBenchmark is trying to cut their losses and limit their exposure to a complete Uber meltdown. If possible, they would probably offload the bulk of their shares to SoftBank at a loss just to wash their hands of the situation. - Uber cannot support its operational business without massive VC subsidies (without drastically raising prices and losing their primary competitive advantage) - It's too easy for small, local competitors to enter the market - Uber has been trounced in two of the largest non-US markets - Waymo legal mess - The sheer volume/scale of scandal engulfing the company may be impossible to recover from - Current valuation makes an IPO under less than perfect conditions very challenging. If this was a well organized, planned round of funding, Benchmark wouldn't have gone behind the backs of the other board members & major shareholders to try and strike some shady deal.
- capkutay 9y ago> Benchmark is trying to cut their losses Didn't Benchmark get in very early? If they got in Series A or B..there are no losses for them. They probably have at least a 10-20x payout already.
- praneshp 9y ago- Uber has been trounced in two of the largest non-US markets I assume one is China, which is the other one?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoRussia. (Forced Yandex merger at unfavorable terms)
- furioussloth 9y agoWhy are the terms unfavorable? Financially the terms look very favorable in one of politically toughest marker outside US.
- lenley 9y agoIt looks like Uber maybe pulling out of India as well: https://www.recode.net/2017/7/14/15964808/uber-global-domination-yandex-didi https://www.recode.net/2017/7/14/15964808/uber-global-domina...
- nwatson 9y agoBye bye Common Stock options.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI forsee many a bitter Uber engineer on the horizon when those options end up worthless.
- xyzzy_plugh 9y agoTBH I don't understand this perspective. If you sign on to a startup as risky as Uber, you have to understand that there is a large chance your shares will be worth nothing. The fact that anyone might not understand this is everything wrong with Silicon Valley.
- stouset 9y agoMany of those engineers have likely stuck around for longer than they're happy with, and for less than market pay. It's one thing when you're excited about the outlook of the company and just started a few months ago. Even if the options turn out worthless, the work is enjoyable and you've gotten to work for a well-known company. Now it's been 5 years, the company looks to be cratering quickly, and you're burnt out. You've been hanging in there because it would be financially insane to quit when you've got a very high likelihood of walking away with millions. Take that last bit away, and you're telling me you can't understand why engineers might start walking away in droves?
- xyzzy_plugh 9y agoOf course I can understand why engineers might leave in droves -- but it's all a risk they were willing to take. It's silly to be bitter than your bet didn't pay off -- few of them ever do.
- mitrandimotor 9y agoIt's easy to be bitter when management squanders a good thing.
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoUber should have just gone public, now their future is too fragile because it depends on their small number of VC investors who probably are thinking that they will still make more money than breakeven if they exit now. People criticize Uber for operating in a red ocean but this was the case for Amazon too. They just stuck around and survived while everyone else in the dotcom era died off. But it's looking more like that kind of scenario is impossible now that their founder/CEO is out and the VCs are looking to get out.
- Kiro 9y agoThe "Uber runs out of money 2018" thing looks like it originated from this popular comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13793406 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13793406 It has been echoed so many times that it's now fact on HN and gets repeated in every thread but is there any real source on this?
- quintin 9y agoAnimats is a well-respected figure and lot of what he comments on point. 2 cents.
- Animats 9y agoZerohedge has an update.[1] So does NYT.[2] The loss rate is down a little, to $708 million per quarter. Uber claims to have $7.2 billion in cash. But that's not all investment capital; at least $1.15 billion of it is from debt. At their current burn rate, they have about two years of runway left before the investment capital runs out. So they can stretch things to mid-2019, if the investors are agreeable. Or maybe they can find another sucker. [1] http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-04-14/cash-burning-machine-uber-opens-its-books-shows-staggering-losses http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-04-14/cash-burning-machin... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/31/technology/uber-limits-loss-to-708-million-in-first-quarter.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/31/technology/uber-limits-lo...
- tmh79 9y agoThe thing about becoming profitable is that it extends your runway as you do it. So they may have 10 months of runway in q2, and 10 months of runway in q3 and 10 months of runway in q4 and 12 months of runway in q1 '18 and and 16 months of runway in q2 '18 and 48 months of runway in q3 '18 and profitable q4 2018.
- jaequery 9y agodespite all the tabloids, i still use uber here in LA and i honestly dont see that changing much for most people as well. all this backlash feels a bit strange to me, do people get paid to hate somehere ? lol
- RangerScience 9y agoSo, as a (sometimes) startup employee, how can I identify a setup such that when a major investor makes money off their stock, I too have the option of making money off my stock? I've heard of setups like this, but I don't remember what they're called - something like, you own stock, and when someone sells a percent of their shares, you can sell the percent of your shares at the same rate to the same party (or back to the company? or something?). What questions SHOULD you ask, and what kinds of answers are you looking for?
- sgs1370 9y agoI think it's a specialist question. All of this assumes you have leverage to get what you ask for. If you are concerned about a company you work for making a lot of money after lots of VC rounds: You would probably have to get warrants, written by someone* who is really smart. If you think the company won't need to do many rounds: just look for stock (if you're in really early, e.g. grant+zero-value-83b election still applies) or options (if you're in after the really early stages of the company). *Find a great accountant who internally has tax lawyers to help you negotiate.
- RangerScience 9y agoI imagine I will use this information somewhere in the "either stock that I can ensure some of the value of, or actually fair market wages". I had a conversation like this that could have benefited from this info not so long ago; I did end up walking away and no-one was happy.
- imjk 9y agoCall me cynical, but perhaps - just perhaps - this was part of the reason for Benchmark's fallout with Travis. Perhaps they wanted to realize some of the gains in their shares of Uber and knew Kalanick would be (or already had been) opposed to it. Benchmark already made astronomical gains on their shares (at least on paper) and perhaps they were looking for a way to now cash in on some of those returns.