4 ms·
Free markets and unbridled competition have a much better track record of driving prices down, making new technologies available to the masses. In industries w
by w1ntermute 16y ago
Free markets and unbridled competition have a much better track record of driving prices down, making new technologies available to the masses.
In industries with a high barrier to entry, the market naturally tends away from competition. Broadband is one such industry, due to the enormous initial infrastructure costs.
- dantheman 16y agoI don't think so, if you look at the united states the broadband industry is heavily regulated.
- _delirium 16y agoThat's partly because it's nearly impossible to build a telecommunications network in the private sector, due to the fact that you don't have eminent domain power, can't dig up roads, etc. And if we're going to have the government assisting private businesses, granting them local monopolies, etc., then sure, they should be regulated.
- w1ntermute 16y agoI never said the US broadband industry isn't regulated, I was just correcting an economic misconception of his. It is entirely true that if the broadband industry were left completely unregulated, there would be a few dominant players in the industry, and their dominance would be a result of the high barriers to entry, and not because of their inherent superiority.
- stretchwithme 16y agoI disagree. People would join voluntary local cooperative that can better deals with network providers. They can take a loan out to build the last mile and then just pay to connect to a bigger hub and then even have ability to switch. Condo home owner associations get better deals for a lot of things than the individual could. One might think that a city is just one big cooperative, but of course, its not really voluntary at all (except that you decide to live there) and is usually not as transparent or as responsive as a cooperative that forms without any coercion. There's a certain point where increasing size of a group causes more overhead managing the size of the group (otherwise know as "politics and corruption" than it gets you in buying power. Of course, such things can't really happen once a provider convinces a municipality to to make it a regulated monopoly. Once it is a monopoly, it can devote itself perpetually to reducing this regulation instead of improving its service, as incentives to do so are greatly reduced.
- jquery 16y ago> In industries with a high barrier to entry, the market naturally tends away from competition. Broadband is one such industry, due to the enormous initial infrastructure costs. Maybe things are different where you live, but the bandwidth / price ratio has increased over 400% in the past 4 years for me where I live. Not a single website was blocked because the greedy corporation didn't want me to see it. Perhaps a few people were able to pay extra to video-conference, watch HDTV on demand, or do remote-surgery because my torrent downloads were throttled imperceptibly, but I think that's probably a good thing.
- w1ntermute 16y agoWhat is your point? From your post, I'm going to assume you live in the US. If so, you should know that your broadband access is the result of heavy government regulation.