2 ms·
It is an interesting project and shows significant accomplishment. I'm not sold on the idea of "professional level" except in so far as people getting paid to m
by brudgers 9y ago
It is an interesting project and shows significant accomplishment. I'm not sold on the idea of "professional level" except in so far as people getting paid to make images. I am not sold because the little details of the images don't really hold up to close scrutiny (and I don't mean pixel peeping).
1. The diagonal lines in the clouds and the bright tree trunk at the extreme right of the first image are distractions that don't support the general aesthetic.
2. The bright linear object impinging on the right edge of the cow image and the bright patch of the partial face of the mountain on the extreme left. Probably the gravel at the left too since it does not really support the central theme.
3. The big black lump that obscures the 'corner' where the midground mountain meets the ground plane in the house image.
4. The minimal snow on the peaks in the snow capped mountain image is more documenting a crime scene than creating interest. I mean technically, yes there is snow and the claim that there was snow would probably stand up in a court of law, but it's not very interesting snow.
For me, it's the attention to detail that separates better than average snapshots from professional art. Or to put it another way, these are not the grade of images that a professional photographer would put in their portfolio. Even if they would get lots of likes on Facebook.
Again, it's an interesting project and a significant accomplishment. I just don't think the criteria by which images are being judged professional are adequate.
- arcticfox 9y agoBut the emphasis was on the processing, not the content of the images themselves, other than cropping. I don't think the intention at this point was to get into adding / removing actual physical elements from the scene. Edit: I guess it depends if there were other images in their corpus that didn't have any flaws, but who's to know?
- brudgers 9y agoWith the exception of the weakly snow capped mountains (part of photography is showing up at the right time) different crops would have eliminated the conditions I described. But to unpack my critique a bit further, an unwillingness to make compromises like the weakly snowcapped mountains and paying the price of an extra week in the field waiting on foul weather is part of how professional photographers get professional shots...and part of how the maintain their professional reputation is not publishing shots that don't live up to a high standard. Or to put it another way, compare the images in the blog post to Carter Gowl's http://www.gowlphoto.com http://www.gowlphoto.com. Gowl produces a couple of images a year and those are good enough to charge a couple of hundred dollars per print. Even if the images in the blog post were appropriately high resolution, I don't see them commanding a similar price. YMMV.
- ma2rten 9y agoThe blog post itself actually confirms what you are saying. They say they asked professional photographers to rate their creations. 40% of their creations were rated at semi-pro or pro level. Looking at their plot only very few of them got a solid 4.0 (professional rating). So, the headline is kind of misleading.
- brudgers 9y agoOut of curiosity, I looked at the linked photos of Jasper National Park (one of the locations) on Google maps. They make an interesting point of comparison, https://www.google.com/search?q=jasper+national+park https://www.google.com/search?q=jasper+national+park
- stephencanon 9y agoIn our modern era of digital photography, 99% of what makes a great photograph is the content, not the processing. Being able to make a technically flawless image is interesting, but to compare it to serious professional photography misses the point almost completely. To be fair, there's plenty of technically good but uninteresting professional photography, too.