4 ms·
Not sure I agree with that. There's good landscape/portrait photography, and there's really great landscape/portrait photography. Great landscape photography t
by dheera 9y ago
Not sure I agree with that. There's good landscape/portrait photography, and there's really great landscape/portrait photography.
Great landscape photography takes you to an interesting location or interesting angle. A post-processing algorithm cannot take you somewhere interesting.
Good landscape photography makes you say, "Wow, that's beautiful!"
Great landscape photography makes you say, "Holy crap, what is that? Where is that?"
https://500px.com/photo/4505244/rainbow-glass-by-junya-hasegawa https://500px.com/photo/4505244/rainbow-glass-by-junya-haseg...
https://1x.com/photo/41156/portfolio/60972 https://1x.com/photo/41156/portfolio/60972
https://500px.com/photo/103746295/the-white-silence-by-daniel-kordan https://500px.com/photo/103746295/the-white-silence-by-danie...
http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2008/08/photo-contest/steinmetz-text http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2008/08/photo-contest/stei...
http://hongwrong.com/verical-horizon-hk/ http://hongwrong.com/verical-horizon-hk/
https://500px.com/photo/103960697/one-thousand-and-one-nights-by-%C4%B0lhan-eroglu https://500px.com/photo/103960697/one-thousand-and-one-night...
https://500px.com/photo/5211062/harvest-by-rob-kruyt https://500px.com/photo/5211062/harvest-by-rob-kruyt
- gervase 9y agoThank you for taking the time to find some examples supporting your argument; I found them quite persuasive.
- Retric 9y agoI significantly prefer the article's photos to those. Buildings are boring as is snow, photo of person or animal / shadows not landscape, and over edited. Now, I suspect as someone that's looking at a lot of photos those pinged some novelty feeling in you, but that does not mean they are objectively good. By comparison the article's photos (and those linked: http://google.github.io/creatism http://google.github.io/creatism) generally evoked that I wish I was there feeling.
- eru 9y agoI see what you mean, though I do like buildings. (But I always had a soft spot for Hong Kong.) I predict a similar divide will crop up in computer generated music: very soon normal people will prefer their pleasant sounds, even while more discerning (semi-) pros will deride their lack of artistic merit for a lot longer. Computer generated art will shine as Gebrauchskunst first---eg get a 'professional level' soundtrack and video editing for your youtube video shot on a phone.
- beojan 9y ago> Great landscape photography takes you to an interesting location or interesting angle. A post-processing algorithm cannot take you somewhere interesting. This isn't just a post-processing algorithm. It also picks the place from Google Street View.
- CWuestefeld 9y agoI believe the point is that even before you can process the photo, the photographer has to see the potential in a scene and actually take the picture.
- BeetleB 9y agoAt least 4 of those photos are heavily post-processed. While they may look nice without the post processing, they would not look anywhere near as nice. I struggled for years to make good photographs until I learned to post process well enough. For an average viewer, the difference is one of "side glance and ignore" and "wow, great photo". It's instructive to look at photographers who post their originals. Even ones that appear to show an "interesting angle" can be quite distorted to show just that angle (as in if you travel there, you will never see the nice angles you saw in the photo).
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoNot sure how your examples refute my point. I didn't say that you can't have great landscape photography or that there can't be mediocre photography. I was talking about how there typically isn't an 'external' story to landscape photography the way there is for photojournalism.