4 ms·
> If you are willing to believe that a smart speaker is compromised to a degree that violates your privacy IMHO the smart speaker's normal function violates my
by AlexandrB 9y ago
> If you are willing to believe that a smart speaker is compromised to a degree that violates your privacy
IMHO the smart speaker's normal function violates my privacy by recording what I'm saying and sending it to Google/Amazon/Whomever for unspecified data analysis and processing. It doesn't need to be compromised to do so.
> You cell phone is also likely to be present for every "conversation with a friend" at which your smart speaker is present so I think the "intimacy" issue is a red herring.
You're right, but the perception of privacy is not rational. A modern smartphone's primary interface is not its microphone - at least not yet. A smart speaker's primary interface is its always-on microphone. This is not too dissimilar from how Google Glass was creepy because one of its main features is as a potentially-always-on camera - even though a smartphone also has a camera.
- slg 9y ago>IMHO the smart speaker's normal function violates my privacy by recording what I'm saying and sending it to Google/Amazon/Whomever for unspecified data analysis and processing. It doesn't need to be compromised to do so. Then that is a fundamental misunderstanding of the stated and verified function of these devices. They only send data out after the devices have been activated with their wake word. Various consumer tests have shown this to be true. If you still don't trust these companies to actually tell the truth about what these devices do, I don't know why you would trust the same companies to not lie about what their smartphones/tablets do. Especially when that functionality would be easier to hide on a smartphone or tablet with a cellular connection. >You're right, but the perception of privacy is not rational. And that is my entire point. The privacy fear about these devices is not rational. They are no more dangerous than the laptop or smartphone that almost everybody already owns.