3 ms·
Not for nothing, but ain't greenhouse gases only the short term problem? The Earth radiates a fixed amount of energy into space every year. But when we produce
by EGreg 9y ago
Not for nothing, but ain't greenhouse gases only the short term problem?
The Earth radiates a fixed amount of energy into space every year. But when we produce electricity etc. no matter how we do it, more than half of the energy escapes as heat - a byproduct of boiling the water or whatever!
This isn't sustainable in the long run either! We are basically raising the temperature of the atmosphere even without greenhouse gases.
Tell me where I'm going wrong:
https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist...
https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2011/10/why-not-space/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2011/10/why-not-space/
- maxerickson 9y agoThe slightly warmer planet cools off faster (Newton's law of cooling). The heat doesn't just statically build up over time. As long as we still have cold seasons, it is safe to assume that solar inputs are dominating our own.
- lostapathy 9y agoRight. When we generate electricity via solar or wind, the heat involved has (essentially) been shifted from elsewhere. That energy was going to reach our planet either way. Whether we use a solar panel to shift it somewhere we can use it, or if it just heats the whatever it would have otherwise ran into, we aren't adding energy to the system by shifting it around. The waste heat from solar panels is just the energy from the sun, less whatever gets turned into electricity. No new energy was created - if there was, you could just create a perpetual motion machine to solve the problem.
- EGreg 9y agoSo then, isn't fossil fuel energy "just" stored sun energy too? If it hadn't wound up underground, our planet would have been slightly hotter already.
- lostapathy 9y agoYes, it's just stored energy from the past. But when we release it now, we get heat now. When we leave it in the ground, we avoid that heat.
- cestith 9y agoFossil fuel is stored chemical energy. Burning it releases the energy. Photovoltaic solar power is converting one type of energy (light) into another (electricity), with the waste heat being the same waste heat the light would've created by shining on something else. Solar thermal energy is using the heat from the sun to do work (which may include heating oils, air, or water to drive a turbine to generate electricity) or to generate electricity (using, say, thermal-piezo conversion). The only effective ways we have to store solar power are batteries, supercapacitors (once they're viable), large heat masses (such as stone or water), growing plants, or putting energy into chemicals for later storage (electrolysis and storing the hydrogen, forming artificial hydrocarbons, recycling aluminum for aluminum/air power cells, pumping water uphill to power a turbine later, pressurizing gases to later drive a turbine, stuff like that). Not all of the things I mentioned work at every scale. Some of them are more efficient than others. They may all have advantages and drawbacks.
- comicjk 9y agoNewton's law is for convection of heat into the air. The cooling of the earth happens by radiation into vacuum, so it's actually much MORE temperature-sensitive: the heat radiated is proportional to the fourth power of the temperature. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stefan%E2%80%93Boltzmann_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stefan%E2%80%93Boltzmann_law
- maxerickson 9y agoThanks for the correction.
- tasty_freeze 9y agoObviously solar input dominate over whatever energy we add through burning fossil fuels. Nobody contests that. You must have heard of the greenhouse effect. THAT is the issue. By changing the composition of the atmosphere, a fractionally greater percentage of the astounding amount of energy is reflected back to the earth instead of escaping into the atmosphere, raising the temperature of the atmosphere and oceans. Imagine sitting in the sun on a warm but not hot day. Now imagine you are sitting in a car in the same spot in the same conditions with the windows rolled up. There is no extra energy being released, just the plain old sun, but the temperature you experience is going to be much higher. Indeed, the temperature increase doesn't grow without bound, but it is meaningfully higher.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe post I replied to literally says "Not for nothing, but ain't greenhouse gases only the short term problem?" Do I still have to go through the imagination exercise?
- bluGill 9y agoTechnically it isn't a fixed amount radiated every year. many factors influence it, one of which is temperature: the higher the temperature difference between earth and space the more that is radiated. Thus as global warming happens he temperature difference raises and the amount the earth radiates increases. This won't be enough to make up the difference, there is no loop hole to solve global warming. Global warming is about the equalization temperature - when the energy in (mostly from the sun despite all the other energy sources we use) equals energy out.
- philipkglass 9y agoYes, constantly increasing energy consumption by a fixed percentage per year projects out to physical absurdities like boiling the oceans or needing to expand colonies throughout the universe faster-than-light. But Tom Murphy is employing a straw-economist ("Note: because I have a better retention of my own thoughts than those of my conversational companion, this recreation is lopsided to represent my own points/words.") to make a point. I thought that was one of his weaker blog entries and I was a regular reader of his blog. The Earth radiates a finite but not fixed amount of energy into space every year. Radiated power goes up with the 4th power of absolute temperature (modulated by greenhouse effect). The effects of increasing the greenhouse effect from fossil combustion are much greater than the direct waste heat from fossil combustion, because the greenhouse effect slightly amplifies the warming effects of the ~10^17 watts of sunlight reaching Earth's surface. Fossil combustion directly accounts for ~10^13 watts of terrestrial heating. Note the 4 orders of magnitude difference.