6 ms·
Here I was looking for the Dr. Strangelove equivalent of the "AI Gap" :-) Given that in the next four years it is likely that more than half of the PhDs awarde
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
Here I was looking for the Dr. Strangelove equivalent of the "AI Gap" :-)
Given that in the next four years it is likely that more than half of the PhDs awarded by top US schools are awarded to foreign nationals[1], and our current government policy is to restrict immigration as much as possible, we are on a path to insuring that soon the world will have a much better pool of talent to draw on to do the research than the US will.
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/r/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/2016/07/13/Editorial-Opinion/Graphics/KF_Report.pdf https://www.washingtonpost.com/r/2010-2019/WashingtonPost/20...
- Leader2light 9y agoImmigration is not the solution. Do you have any idea how restrictive China is on immigration?
- justicezyx 9y agoThe point is that Top Chinese PhDs got degrees from Top us schools are forced back. Not that immigration are needed for China.
- flyinglizard 9y agoThe point is that educating the best minds of the world and then expelling them to their origin countries is not a wise practice.
- iamcurious 9y agoIt is a very wise practice from a soft power perspective.
- yohui 9y agoChina also restricts democracy and access to the internet, but that's not to say the US wouldn't be harmed by a move in that direction. China has different strengths and weaknesses; the US would be ill advised to give up its own strengths.
- dilemma 9y agoFar less restrictive than US and EU.
- erva 9y agoNot to sound like an anti-intellectual, but it could be a mistake to assume that innovation comes from academia. Nassim Nicholas Taleb has a convincing chapter (I think it is Chapter 13: Lecturing Birds to Fly) in his book "Antifragile" about this very thing. Then there are cultural differences that could be at play concerning innovation. It is a general observation that east asian cultures tend to suppress risk-taking and innovation. Whereas, western cultures seem to promote risk-taking and innovation. That is not to say that there aren't risk takers in China and risk averse individuals in the West...just that overall there may be asymmetry. And, very little asymmetry can create very big differences. So, have all the smartest people you want, doing all the research you want; but if they have no pressure to put that research to practice, nor a desire or support to take the risks associated with implementation then you might as well have nobody doing anything. Just a thought.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Not to sound like an anti-intellectual, but could it be a misnomer to assume that innovation comes from academia. The use of “misnomer” in that sentence is, itself, misnomer. What you describe is, perhaps, a mistake, but not in naming.
- nullnilvoid 9y agoArguably, it is better for the entire humanity if PhDs and other talent are spread out across the whole world rather than monopolized by one single nation. That's how knowledge gets transferred and the whole world improves.