18 ms·
Most ideas won't make it past the "economic calculation" litmus test. If a system cannot do economic calculation, than it's impossible to implement or only get
by kiba 16y ago
Most ideas won't make it past the "economic calculation" litmus test. If a system cannot do economic calculation, than it's impossible to implement or only get by imitating the price structure of existing free market systems.
You could dismiss capitalism by merely saying it's an ideology. Yet, capitalism's strength is not so much that its supporter exists, but that it works and exists. It's a natural and a spontaneous formation in society.
In North Korea, people make by with black markets. The problem there is that the government wiped out people saving by inflating the currency in an effort to revive their failing state factories.
All the other system I ever heard of requires central planning, and some kind of authority. It doesn't relies on some kind of spontaneous cooperation that happen in western society. It relies on iron fists and lot of policing.
What are you merely doing is blaming distinct structures of society together as "capitalism", as if western nations adopt a pure version. It is not. It is a cacophonous mixture of all kind. Street gangs, the institution of statism, regulatory frameworks, and the system of laws and rules all works to create an emergent society. All of these system and institution are all moving parts, each creating its own disincentives and incentives, some perverse, and some positive. Organizations itself doesn't stay the same, it grows, and dies, based on the incentive system placed within that organizations. For example, gangs become more violent to increase its power and earn more money. The public got tired and told the police to curb it or lose their jobs. The gangs eventually become more discreet dues to its leadership and memberships getting decimated. The police evolve special gangs unit to catch them now that it is expected of them to stop gangsters.
Some are feudal-like, some are socialist, some are anarchist/voluntary, and some are statist/coercive.
So some part of western society have some capitalism. It doesn't tell us that capitalism itself is a failure just because of recent economic crisis that pervades western nations. You didn't consider the democratic system of government, the nature of our regulatory system, and the kind of incentive structure it imparts on human actors.