2 ms·
To counter that example, Reddit effectively has tags (by splitting the site in to sub-reddits). There's virtually no restriction on the tags (or sub-reddits) y
by pmoriarty 9y ago
To counter that example, Reddit effectively has tags (by splitting the site in to sub-reddits). There's virtually no restriction on the tags (or sub-reddits) you can create, and Reddit is far more popular than HN.
I've heard people argue against tags on HN by saying they don't want HN to become another Reddit, but HN differentiates itself from Reddit in all sorts of other ways, like community and norms. I don't think HN would lose anything by having tags, and if someone wanted to use "HN Classic", as it were, they could just ignore the tags.
- seanwilson 9y agoThe best subreddits have good moderators though. For the same thing, you'd need knowledgable and strict moderators to make the tags accurate.