6 ms·
The headline is missing the part where it's the transcripts of your interactions with that developer's service. They're not handing over your full transcripts o
by mikeash 9y ago
The headline is missing the part where it's the transcripts of your interactions with that developer's service. They're not handing over your full transcripts of all interaction with the device. Rather misleading.
My only reaction to this is that it's kind of weird they weren't already doing it.
- throwaway2016a 9y agoExactly this. Being able to see what users are actually saying to your chat bot is critical to do development. Without it, it is like trying to debug an issue with a website without being able to see the HTTP access logs. Furthermore, the bot already knows when you say the right things to it, because what command you issued is sent to the developer's lambda endpoint so they can fulfill your request. This is just telling the developer when you say things to their app that weren't properly recognized by the AI. Previously it was like telling a developer: you got this many 404 errors but we won't tell you what page they were on. This is just telling the developer what page.
- snarf21 9y agoYeah, and this is the information that is needed to really move these skills forward. I wish you could set a threshold on the intents based on confidence level and prioritization to have more of a custom fall through logic.
- ceejayoz 9y agoI understand entirely the need... but at some point some developer's going to get a transcript that goes "Alexa, order me an Uber." "To where?" "OH NO YOU DON'T ASSHOLE YOU HAD SEX WITH MY COUSIN AND WE'RE GOING TO TALK ABOUT THIS RIGHT NOW".
- throwaway2016a 9y agoWhile I think that is possible the same is true if I'm on the phone with the dispatcher at a Taxi company and no one is saying the phone company is disrespecting my privacy for sending the full uncensored audio of what I say into the phone to the phone number I called. I actually like that analogy better than the website one I gave... effectively when you activate a bot of any kind you are calling that bot.
- DougWebb 9y agoThat's a good analogy, but two things: 1) It's a lot easier to call a bot accidentally than to make a phone call accidentally, since the phone requires you to press your butt against it, but the bot is just listening to you talk near it. 2) Accidental phone calls are also ephemeral. Even if it goes to voicemail, only the recipient is likely to ever hear it, and it generally won't be kept forever. With Alexia, it goes into some big training pool, probably permanently.
- throwaway2016a 9y ago1) While I might buy that for accidentally triggering Alexa itself. Accidentally triggering an app is quite a bit harder because it requires a specific sequence of words. 2) Most phone carrier store voicemails in the cloud. We have no guarantee they delete them.
- waisbrot 9y agoThe first concern is that not all services are alike. Probably nobody cares if I'm able to deduce how many Alexa users in NYC want to know about the weather forecast. But I think people would be creeped-out if I was looking at their hotel reservation info (where and when they're staying, how many rooms, etc). The second is that there might be leaks: what if Amazon miss-detects (or I misspeak) and I end up with transcripts from some other service.
- mikeash 9y agoI don't understand the hotel reservation example. If you're receiving that info, it's because you provide some sort of hotel booking service, so you have to receive that info one way or another. All this does is let you see the exact wording they used, not just the extracted data. Leaks do seem like a legitimate concern. I'd be interested to know how frequent they are.
- ams6110 9y ago> They're not handing over your full transcripts of all interaction with the device. Not yet.
- o_____________o 9y agoIn what scenario would that make any sense?
- Antrikshy 9y agoIn the scenario where I get to wear a shiny tinfoil hat.
- mikeash 9y agoSure, but if you're worried about potential actions in the future, that's been there from day one.
- throwaway2016a 9y agoWhat incentive would they possibly have to do that? They are a publicly traded company. The executives have a fiduciary duty to the shareholders and will be personally accountable if they willfully neglect that (vs just the company being liable). There is almost no valid argument that an executive could not anticipate the blowback from doing that and no executive in their right mind is going to risk personal liability like that. But say one did. The people who could leak that information include: - Every single third-part skill developer - Amazon employees - Government employees if they are giving it to the government - Any one with the technical skills to reverse engineer the hardware The conspiracy theory would reach hundreds of people if not thousands. If people are getting this worked up about this, the lawsuit would be inevitable and the executive that green lit it would be thrown under the bus and their career would be over and they would go bankrupt fighting the personal lawsuits.
- CaptSpify 9y ago> What incentive would they possibly have to do that? Besides the obvious financial one? It would be crazy if they started sharing this data, just like it would be crazy if the telecoms started sending your web traffic to governments. Or how crazy it would be if Google started snooping into your email. Or how crazy it would be if phone companies let someone else listen in on your calls and texts. It's a good thing those never happened either.