4 ms·
The main thing NASA needs to land people on Mars (or the Moon for that matter) is a lander. NASA does not have one, nor is one being funded. All the other detai
by Robotbeat 9y ago
The main thing NASA needs to land people on Mars (or the Moon for that matter) is a lander. NASA does not have one, nor is one being funded. All the other details for Mars can be done with variants of what already exists or will fly shortly (commercial crew vehicles or even Soyuz, ISS modules for a transfer craft, launch vehicles like the EELVs used by the military or Falcon 9 or Falcon Heavy, in-orbit docking and propellant transfer which is commonly used on the Space Station, etc). If you see a lander being developed and tested, then you know you have a serious human space exploration program.
NASA has sufficient funding for accomplishing a human Mars landing. But not the political freedom to direct that funding where it's most critical (i.e. a lander).
SpaceX, on the other hand, is developing this technology for a lander. Their reuse technology for Falcon 9 proved for the first time the feasibility of supersonic retropropulsion, a CRITICAL technology needed for a human-scale Mars lander. A vertically landing reusable upper stage, which SpaceX intends to develop next (after block 5 Falcon 9) as part of their Mars rocket plans, is essentially a Mars lander prototype.
SpaceX, even though they have less funding and have to rely on funding from commercial launches (as well as capital used for developing commercially viable hardware, like the constellation) to develop their Mars lander, is thus on a better and surer path to Mars than NASA.
This is SpaceX's Mars architecture in a nutshell:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0qo78R_yYFA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0qo78R_yYFA
In order to pay for it, they will develop a smaller (but still tremendously huge) and more economical version of the rocket shown in that video to replace Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy. They will use it to launch and maintain their 12,000 satellite megaconstellation (thousands of satellites per year), something that would BARELY be feasible with their partially reusable Falcon architecture (but not feasible with expendable rockets) but which fits nicely and economically into the capability of their subscale Mars rocket. This way, they can leverage capital they'll raise for their megaconstellation to build the primary pieces of their human Mars transportation architecture.
- beisner 9y agoLander aside, the biggest limiting factor is getting astronauts back from Mars! We already know how to get things there, and I think the lander issue is relatively easy to solve, but getting all the equipment and -- most importantly -- fuel for the return flight is the hardest problem to solve economically. Of course we could send like, 12 missions to deliver all the required components, but coordinating the assembly of a rocket on Mars is no walk in the park.
- Robotbeat 9y agoCorrect. In my post, I was assuming "lander" would either be a two-stage vehicle like the Apollo lunar lander capable of both landing and later ascending (with or without refueling) or a single-stage vehicle (like SpaceX is developing with ITS/BFS) that is capable of being refueled on the surface for ascending. And yes, fueling up on the surface is a difficult problem to solve. It will involve at least extraction and electrolysis of CO2 from the Mars atmosphere (as NASA is going to demonstrate on the Mars 2020 Rover), but most probably will also include extraction of water, probably by using a robotic machine to dig up regolith (which contains at least 2% absorbed water almost anywhere on the surface of Mars) or buried ice, electrolysis of that water and reaction of the resultant hydrogen with CO2 from the atmosphere to make methane. (And in both cases of electrolysis, you'll be producing sufficient oxygen.) This is, of course, partly why SpaceX is developing a methane-based engine for their next-generation launch vehicle. But you have to develop the lander first otherwise you can't feasibly land enough equipment (using existing techniques limited to just a single ton) to refuel.
- 0xffff2 9y ago>All the other details for Mars can be done with variants of what already exists or will fly shortly (commercial crew vehicles or even Soyuz, ISS modules for a transfer craft, launch vehicles like the EELVs used by the military or Falcon 9 or Falcon Heavy, in-orbit docking and propellant transfer which is commonly used on the Space Station, etc). I'll grant you a lot of that, but do you really think re-using ISS modules for transfer craft would be remotely feasible? The vastly different radiation regimes between LEO and interplanetary space make me doubt that this would work.
- Robotbeat 9y agoYes it is feasible. The radiation regimes are not vastly different. They're within roughly a factor of two of one another. And since the transit time is about half a year, and we've had multiple people experience ~year-long trips in orbit at a time, I think we're well within our existing knowledge to say they'd do fine radiation-wise, though perhaps with a slightly higher risk than usual. Still better than being a smoker. That is not at all the showstopper. If you choose to remain in orbit around Mars instead of landing, however, you'll be exposed to a higher dose. Mars' surface has a level of radiation that's below that of ISS plus contains plenty of material for shielding your habitat. Therefore, the lander helps address the radiation problem as well by getting you down to the surface for most of the mission's duration (instead of doing initial missions in Mars orbit only due to lack of money for a Mars lander as is the current NASA plan). (Using the ISS spare pool is only one possible solution, by the way, and not likely to be the most optimum.)
- CydeWeys 9y agoThere's also the issue of coronal mass ejections (though CMEs pointing right at us are admittedly rare, so maybe you just eat the risk). They will absolutely fry anything in their path, but take 1-3 days to reach the Earth from the Sun, which is long enough to bring any astronauts on the ISS back down to Earth. I believe there are contingency plans for this; there is always a crew return vehicle attached to the station ready to go for example. If that happens while you're on the way to Mars, though, you're all fried.
- 9y ago