4 ms·
>> It's worth so much that a person shouldn't be required to pay for it. Like a right. It can't be a right. That would mean someone has an obligation to provid
by phkahler 9y ago
>> It's worth so much that a person shouldn't be required to pay for it. Like a right.
It can't be a right. That would mean someone has an obligation to provide it. I would say it's worth so much that a monopoly on it should not be allowed.
- orbitur 9y agoIf you show up in a random hospital with an injury or disease, they are already obligated to provide care, it's just you're directly responsible for the bill. The individual shouldn't be paying.
- thescriptkiddie 9y agoIn the US it actually doesn't work this way. Hospitals are only obligated to provide care for people whose lives are in immediate danger. Once the patient is stabilized, the hospital is free to kick them out. There are a handful of exceptions and many hospitals will provide care out of charity, but don't expect to get a half-million dollar cancer treatment unless you have health insurance or really good credit.
- ceejayoz 9y ago> It can't be a right. That would mean someone has an obligation to provide it. By that logic, voting can't be a right, because someone has to register voters, run the polling booths, count the votes, etc.
- njarboe 9y agoIf the health care system was mostly staffed by unpaid volunteers, I might agree. As it stands health care is 17% of US GDP (10% global) and growing.
- accountyaccount 9y agoSociety has an obligation to provide it, just as it does drinking water.
- camiller 9y agoI get a water bill every month... Also, I know folks on well water that live outside of the city, society does not provide their drinking water. Also, There is Flint MI.
- accountyaccount 9y agoYOU get a bill. Society pays for public drinking fountains, homeless shelters, section 8 housing, etc... where water is provided for the less fortunate at a scaled societal contribution (or free). Flint MI is an absolute crisis and the government has stepped in, the state of Michigan sued the city, and there have been over a dozen criminal indictments. Multiple governments have stepped in to repair the obligation of clean drinking water, and to punish those who failed the citizens.
- phkahler 9y agoYou got it backwards. There is no obligation to provide drinking water. In fact most places where the city puts it in they force people to use the provided water and NOT put in wells. Then they send a bill.
- bykovich2 9y agoThis is bonkers logic. It's wrong to coerce someone into providing the cure, but it's right to coerce someone out of forming a monopoly?
- PeterisP 9y agoAn IP-based monopoly can't exist unless the society enforces the concept of that IP, e.g. coerces anyone to not make the treatment without a valid licence. The monopoly isn't made by the company, it's a conditional and time-limited offer given by the society to promote the creation of such things.