5 ms·
It's not a better alternative, because it makes DRM too easily accessible. Many companies that would never have used Flash for DRM are now using EME or consider
by kuschku 9y ago
It's not a better alternative, because it makes DRM too easily accessible. Many companies that would never have used Flash for DRM are now using EME or considering it. Including YouTube, Twitter, Facebook, etc.
In a few years every video on the web will use DRM, and you won't even be able to download YouTube videos.
- SquareWheel 9y agoA platform being simple to implement doesn't seem like a good argument against that platform, even if you dislike it for other reasons.
- meesterdude 9y agoif that platform is anti-social, you want to raise the barrier for entry, not lower it.
- lordlimecat 9y agoIf the platform is obnoxious, people will abandon it for other alternatives. You know, like the crappy ones (flash, silverlight) we've been trying to ditch for a decade now.
- karmadog 9y agoIf that's what content creators want, isn't it in their right? You're technically not allowed to download YouTube videos anyway, there just isn't a convenient measure against it. You're not paying, you're probably blocking ads and now you want to download stuff for free? You're worthless to creators. Also, you're not getting to see all the videos that aren't on Youtube exactly because there is no DRM.
- mnarayan01 9y ago> If that's what content creators want, isn't it in their right? Absolutely. That's not particularly relevant to the normative question of whether the HTML standard should make adding DRM less of a pain point though.
- AlexandrB 9y ago> If that's what content creators want, isn't it in their right? No, because DRM + DMCA has repeatedly been used to violate consumers' and researchers' fair use rights. It's my right to lock my house, unless you're inside it and I'm effectively turning it into a prison.
- kuschku 9y agoNo, it’s not in their right. If I buy a book on Amazon, I have a right to make a copy, but DRM prevents me from that. If I buy a movie on Google Play Movies, I have the right to make up to 7 backups without DRM, but DRM prevents me from that.
- syshum 9y ago>If that's what content creators want, isn't it in their right? No, they have no right to control my computer
- FussyZeus 9y ago> It's not a better alternative, because it makes DRM too easily accessible As anti-DRM as I am, what you're basically saying is that DRM which is essentially encryption used with some sort of e-commerce system should be difficult and obtuse, so as to discourage it's use, while at least implying (and I'm betting you are) that you'd be pro-encryption on the user's side for security and privacy. You have the right to privacy and to use encryption to enforce that privacy, but so do content creators have the right to lock you out until you're willing to pay money, watch ads, or whatever system they have in mind. You aren't entitled to content any more than Doubleclick is entitled to your browsing history.
- ginko 9y ago> DRM which is essentially encryption used with some sort of e-commerce system I'd say this is incorrect. At it's core DRM requires a locked-down system, either on the hardware or software level, but always closed source, to hide operations from the owner of the device. Encryption is a big part of this but technically doesn't need to be. I agree that content creators have the right to stop me from consuming their content if I don't pay money, watch ads or whatever, but they don't have the right to require me to install unknown software or hardware on my computer.
- FussyZeus 9y ago> but they don't have the right to require me to install unknown software or hardware on my computer. Yes and that's why they're adding DRM support to HTML5, so you don't need to and the browser you're using can act as the endpoint allowing access to the content. Now you don't need to install Flash or ick Silverlight to do so. More to the point though, they absolutely do. A content creator can set any kind of wacky requirements for you to consume their content that they see fit; and it's your decision as a content consumer to decide if you're going to jump through whatever hoops of fire to do so. You, and no one else aside from the creator (or more likely, distributor) has a right to say what is a reasonable expectation and what is an unreasonable expectation. I would however add that recently there has been a push to "Steamify" many content delivery systems to remove the friction typically associated with DRM and to make consuming DRM-enabled content more seamless. I think content distributors are slowly waking up to the fact that they cannot stop the Piracy end of things, so the solution is to do what Steam did for video games: make Piracy less attractive by making legal ownership better value for money, and less effort.