2 ms·
I don't follow your argument - are you aware of how much flying is conducted under autopilot? Commercial aviation is very safe.
by mannykannot 9y ago
I don't follow your argument - are you aware of how much flying is conducted under autopilot? Commercial aviation is very safe.
- Retric 9y agoAutopilots on commercial aircraft work well, because of the infrastructure surrounding them. Small aircraft is not commercial aviation. One of the most common failures in small aircraft is running out of fuel and then having the sudden need to find somewhere to land. That's a very rare problem in commercial aviation. Basically, commercial aviation succeeds because it avoids the vast number of failure modes. Fully automated car autopilots are not a simpler problem, they simply need to deal with the mess which aircraft autopilots sidestep. Ex: 747's autopilot does not have a look for an open field I can land in which I can then take off from again after I refuel.
- mannykannot 9y agoI am still not sure I get it - are you saying that autopilots are not a good analogy for autonomous cars because the car problem is more like that of using an autopilot in a small airplane? If so, be aware that autopilots for small single-engine airplanes are available [1]. Automobile automation is actually a much harder problem than that, and the "mess which aircraft autopilots sidestep" cannot be "simply" dealt with. BTW, if you do have an engine failure in a single-engine airplane (or double failure on an A320), being able to take off again should be low on your priorities in picking a place to put down on. [1] http://wiki.flightgear.org/Bendix/King_KAP140_Autopilot http://wiki.flightgear.org/Bendix/King_KAP140_Autopilot
- falcolas 9y agoThe trick about autopilots (especially those in smaller aircraft) is that they operate almost exclusively based on information about their own state. Wing levelers just operate to keep the wings parallel to the ground, using information from a gyro. Direction keepers keep you on a particular heading, as determined by a gyro (which is corrected by a magnetometer). Even landing systems rely on radio signals being beamed at them. The big exception to this is collision avoidance systems which use a radar combined with transponders; and is limited to fairly expensive aircraft as a result. Autonomous cars have to start with radar-based collision avoidance simply to provide "smart" cruise control, and work outwards with lane detection for lane keeping, lidar and prediction for external body collision avoidance (deer, children, bikers), and so forth. Aircraft autopilot is dead simple in comparison, and still has its share of failures. And speaking of failures, the other advantage of aircraft is that in the case of failure (in any phase of the flight other than takeoff/landing), pilots have tens of seconds to take over and hours each year of deliberate practice at flying compromised aircraft. Drivers, on the other hand, will be lucky to have a single second to realize their car isn't going to stop when they expect it to.
- Retric 9y agoI think your still missing my point. A small aircraft running out of fuel is a common problem. If you turn on an autopilot when there is not enough fuel to get to an airport they don't deal with this situation. So, no we don't have fully autonomous small aircraft autopilots. We have the equivalent of lane following + collision avoidance not the full range of piloting skills because they are designed as assistants for pilots not replacements for pilots. Worse a pilot in the aircraft or on ground would also needs to deal with air traffic control which is a vastly larger jump than reading road signs etc. PS: Yes aircraft autopilots can deal with ~99% of the time flying just fine. But, that last 1% has dragons. Getting an autonomous trick to drive on highways in most weather conditions but which would drive into road construction is a good analogy.