4 ms·
He his talking about "best level of data protection in a small office/home office (SOHO) environment". Trying to do this with FS features is misguided. You ne
by fulafel 9y ago
He his talking about "best level of data protection in a small office/home office (SOHO) environment".
Trying to do this with FS features is misguided.
You need to have backups, and have regular practice in restoring from backups.
Some organizations need fancy filesystems in addition to backups, because they want to have high availability that will bridge storage failures. But that has a high cost in complexity, you should only consider it if you have IT/sysadmin staff and the risk management says it's worth the investment in cognitive opportunity cost, IT infrastructure complexity and time spent.
- kev009 9y agoNegative, you wont know you _need_ to use the backups without these FS features, and by the time you finally do you could have rotated through them.
- fulafel 9y agoThe article didn't mention backups at all. If a SOHO environment can afford only either backups or a ZFS storage system, choosing backups leaves much less residual risk on the table. Yes, there is still a risk that corrupted data may end up in backups, but that's true even with ZFS. Ideally you want end-to-end integrity checking and verification, that means application layer and should also be done for backups. But like with all risk management, there are diminishing returns...
- kev009 9y agoThat is the most contrived nonsense I've heard in a long time. You can't not afford to use ZFS, it works fine on a single disk and at least you'd know your data had mutated.