3 ms·
That’s another one of these half-assed solutions that the world has too many of, just like credit cards or using SSN as auth. No. We’ve solved all these issue
by kuschku 9y ago
That’s another one of these half-assed solutions that the world has too many of, just like credit cards or using SSN as auth.
No.
We’ve solved all these issues before, OpenID was a good solution, and OpenID Connect – a complete rewrite – can be used to replace it, and is used already for Google and Facebook login.
Just use OIDC, on every page, and allow users to choose an identity provider. Problem solved.
- StavrosK 9y agoI kind of agree, using OIDC with users selecting providers in the form of an email address (i.e. you enter an email address and the provider is selected based on that) seems like ideal UX.
- curun1r 9y ago> OpenID was a good solution Ugh...no. Just no. If you believe that, I'm not sure there's anything I can say that will get through to you...we're just going to have diametrically opposed opinions. But let me tell you that I've implemented it quite a few times on various sites and it's been a nightmare every time, so it's not like my 'half-assed' approach was ignorant of it being an option. It was based on specifically discarding that option as poorly conceived, poorly implemented and simply not being an option in many cases. Banks, for example, should never let a 3rd party IDP be part of their authentication process. And if your solution is inapplicable in situations where tight security is required, you've got to ask yourself whether you're actually solving the problem or just requiring users to be aware of two different ways of logging in instead of the one that they currently understand. Even if they do have to remember different passwords for most sites, most people can deal with username/password conceptually in a way that using a third-party IDP confuses them.
- kuschku 9y agoBanks should only allow auth via EMV chip and pin, like all German banks already allow. And for anyone else OIDC is more than good enough. Username and Password is in any situation less secure than OIDC.