4 ms·
I can't help but feel badly for SoundCloud and their CEO. Over the years I've seen dozens of companies get to a point where its clear that the future is not wha
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
I can't help but feel badly for SoundCloud and their CEO. Over the years I've seen dozens of companies get to a point where its clear that the future is not what they had envisioned. It's that moment of facing reality of "If we were likely to win, we would have by now, but we didn't so really what is next for us?" It is that point where the investors have seen perhaps three or four internal projects that haven't pushed them into that accelerating growth point, and there really isn't enough money to go further. So the investors have said to themselves, "I'm thinking this one isn't a winner." Let's focus on some of the more promising companies in our portfolio.
The CEO is massively constrained in what they can say when a company reaches this point, so they all say the same thing, "We've got great things happening, really hated to have to let go some great people, we're aligning the company on this awesome plan to take us to the next level."
The alternative is saying "Nothing we've been able to think of to date has created a viable business. We're now at the point that we are losing money so fast that even our most optimistic ideas about what might work were beyond the point where we cross $0 and go negative. We're laying off a bunch of staff which will slow are burn rate enough to pursue both a "Hail Mary"[1] strategy and look for a way to liquidate the company and claim victory anyway."
Hedge funds and other private equity firms will come out and review what things they have and how they might be re-packaged or sold, internal investors will squabble over terms and conditions of bridge (aka Debt) financing to let them live long enough to get there, management will be constrained by this effort to focus mostly on selling the company and less on actually making it a viable proposition. It sets the clock, and when the debt financing runs out, everyone goes home sad.
But nobody ever says that. They say "We've got this new direction we are super excited about."
[1] "Hail Mary", made popular by quarter back Roger Staubach (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hail_Mary_pass https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hail_Mary_pass) is a plan that conceptually can be successful but is probabilistically unlikely to succeed.
- roundupReady 9y agowin what?
- thesmallestcat 9y agoCry me a river, poor well-connected CEO will have to go Serial Entrepreneur another company on the wings of investors. These people only have to deal with mental anguish, the ones with consciences at least. I feel badly for the employees and, to a certain extent, the customers.
- anatari 9y agoYes, and I only feel bad for those who have cancer, and have no food to eat. The employees only have to worry about the mental anguish of suffering through some stupid whiteboard coding problems to get their next job. /sarcasm off.
- thesmallestcat 9y agoCritical hit! I didn't realize that cancer patients and the starving were part of this discussion of Soundcloud's layoffs. I will go lick my wounds and perform the required penance of reading five PG essays for suggesting that CEOs have it relatively easy.
- flyinglizard 9y agoDo you suggest that being a CEO is an easy job - let alone of a company in the situation of SoundCloud?
- buchhalter 9y agoThis specific CEO had a reasonably easy job/life/career: http://www.businessinsider.com/life-of-soundcloud-founder-ceo-alexander-ljung-2015-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/life-of-soundcloud-founder-ce... Both him and his cofounder are paper rich from Angel investments they made (they just got a massive windfall with the IPO of Delivery Hero), by the way, so I'm sure they'll do just fine.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- acjohnson55 9y agoBut some companies actually come out of that, especially when they've built valuable assets. It took a long time before it seemed like Facebook could be turned into a profitable business from being a plaything. But the fact that they were sitting on this growing social graph gave people enough faith to believe it might be worthwhile to give them some more rope. At least that's the way I see it -- maybe they started monetizing effectively earlier than I recall.
- cstejerean 9y agoWhere there massive layoffs at Facebook? I don't recall anything like what is happening at SoundCloud.
- harmmonica 9y agoDo you think that employees stick around because the CEO/leadership says "we've got this new direction we are super excited about" and they would bail if they got "nothing... has created a viable business"? That is, are the employees who stick around happy to stick their heads in the sand as long as the leadership throws out the "we're excited" bone? I would prefer the honesty about the hail mary and I would think most HN readers would feel the same, but I wonder if that's the norm and CEOs/leaders just can't/won't (shouldn't?) admit the reality regardless of how obvious that reality is. EDIT: I should also say that I'd likely go to the mat for the person who's honest about the hail mary.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI can't speak for Berlin of course, but in the Bay Area the employees are usually in a pretty reasonable position. They can leave if they want and get jobs somewhere else, often the company will provide incentives for some or all of them to stay that probably pay dividends whether or not the company succeeds at making it into a new direction. I prefer to be honest with folks who work for me in such situations as well, but that is generally a leadership style that is particular to the leader.
- ThrowawayR2 9y ago> Do you think that employees stick around because the CEO/leadership says "we've got this new direction we are super excited about" and they would bail if they got "nothing... has created a viable business"? That is, are the employees who stick around happy to stick their heads in the sand as long as the leadership throws out the "we're excited" bone? I think you underestimate the capacity for people to delude themselves. Change is painful and a change that leaves behind a projects that you've invested heavily in is even more painful (sunk cost fallacy). Talking about the realities of the situation shatters that self-delusion. You also fail to account for morale. We've all heard of tightly-knit teams who managed to succeed against incredible odds because they believed in what they were doing; the converse is much less talked about: teams that believe they cannot succeed, inevitably won't. So, from a management perspective, it never makes sense to admit one is in a "Hail Mary" situation, even when it's patently obvious. > EDIT: I should also say that I'd likely go to the mat for the person who's honest about the hail mary. Bluntly, why? Your family and your future retirement depends on your income and career success. If the prospects for success are that bleak, how does it make sense for you to take on that risk personally? "For the good of the company?" For your own sake, I would hope not.
- draw_down 9y agoEverything changes. Apple was once 90 days from bankruptcy, according to Steve Jobs.