3 ms·
This OP suffers from the same delusion as a lot of financial professionals. The "Investment capital" that he talks about mostly goes to buy and sell stocks and
by jtbigwoo 16y ago
This OP suffers from the same delusion as a lot of financial professionals.
The "Investment capital" that he talks about mostly goes to buy and sell stocks and bonds. These are not real capital investments, but wagers on future prices. I bought $5000 of Google stock last year. To say that the $5000 did anything to help Google is foolish. I bought someone's bet and now he has $5000 more while I have $5000 less. He may have invested it in something useful (buying goods or services) but more likely he used it to make another wager. No true value was created, though the brokers and money managers (like the OP) take their cut. On the other hand, if I had purchased government bonds, the bond money would have been injected much more broadly into the economy via capital spending or entitlements. Don't pretend that money that doesn't go to government bonds would go to building bridges.
Should or national savings rate be higher? Yes. Should we move toward a balanced budget? Yes. Should we try to fix these things while on the edge of a double-dip recession? Most certainly not.
- hga 16y ago"I bought $5000 of Google stock last year." And obviously the people from who you bought it burned that 5K in a bonfire.... An illiquid financial system helps no one (well, no one good).
- jtbigwoo 16y agoI'm not saying that $5000 didn't go anywhere... About one percent of it was eaten by fees and the rest probably went to make another wager. It almost certainly did not go into anything resembling capital investment as the OP suggests. I'm not attacking the market system, merely pointing out that the post-IPO "capital" market for a stock does not produce any capital investment but is rather a means for trading wagers on the performance of the underlying company. Real capital investment is mostly financed by bonds (including government bonds, which the OP appears to dislike.)