5 ms·
To the best of my knowledge, there is no safeguard in place that could prevent such a course of action if it were attempted I can tell you for certain that the
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
To the best of my knowledge, there is no safeguard in place that could prevent such a course of action if it were attempted
I can tell you for certain that there are dozens of safeguards. That scenario not only isn't possible, it's not plausible. Yes the President has the "codes" but those codes don't launch the missiles [1]. The scenario described is one in which there are literally nuclear warheads on a ballistic trajectory headed to the US with a verified source of origin.
I think the trope stays around because people, despite what they say publicly, like the idea of an emperor style president with supreme power.
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/politics/graphics/2016-nuclear-weapon-launch/ https://www.bloomberg.com/politics/graphics/2016-nuclear-wea...
- alexilliamson 9y agoI think the article you mention supports the opposing from the one you are defending: that article seems to be saying the ultimately the President can decide to ignore everyone else's judgement and launch anyway. Care to elaborate on the dozens of safeguards? Anything that could actually stop the Donald if he decided he'd had enough? A recent radiolab episode (http://www.radiolab.org/story/nukes/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/nukes/) made a pretty convincing argument that any US president could on a whim destroy the world. It goes into the whole history of why that power was given to a civilian, and not the military.
- avar 9y agoRadiolab did an episode recently[1] which disagrees with that Bloomberg article. They interview ex-Secretary of Defense William Perry asking him what controls there are, if any, on a crazy president just willy-nilly deciding to nuke something. He says there's absolutely none, even if the president is in a room full of people who vehemently disagree with him he alone makes the call to launch. 1. http://www.radiolab.org/story/nukes/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/nukes/
- mr_spothawk 9y agothe Gov has a vested interest in other Govs believing that the president's button can do a thing. i'm not sure who to trust... but I did learn the word "Verisimilitude" the other day.
- komali2 9y agoEx secretary isn't really part of "The Gov" anymore.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoYes yes, but... The President can make the call to launch and everyone in the room can ignore him, arrest him, tape his mouth shut. Or just shoot him. Edit: fixed a word
- astronautjones 9y agoYeah, you'd think that if nothing else, our current governmental situation proves that all expected norms should now be discarded. If this dipshit can act this way w/o recompense, there's no reason that the rest of the chain of command should follow orders...
- throwaway7312 9y agoNuttiness. This is the same President the MSM declared had "finally become President" after he bombed a Syrian air base following a (hoaxed?) chemical attack. Then got attacked endlessly by the MSM for not continuing to bomb Syria and for deescalating the military-industrial "WWIII with Russia so we can all make a lot of money" campaign. There's an argument to be made for checks on presidential power to wage nuclear war at a pin drop. President Trump pulling us back from the joint establishment Democrat and establishment Republican push for worldwide nuclear armageddon is not it.
- Bakary 9y agoIt's pretty generous to assume that will happen. It might, but it's far from a certainty.
- ekianjo 9y agoMany people were morally opposed to nuking Japan in ww2 yet the president still went ahead and issued the order. Not sure what you expect from the military, they are formatted to follow orders.
- wwweston 9y agoThe article you're citing appears to support the point it seems like you're trying to contradict -- it describes a system where the president is given explicit authority at every stage. There are opportunities for others to dissuade him, but he has every freedom to disregard them, and they have absolutely nothing in the way of legal power to stop him. The only check currently seems to be people disobeying his orders, and even that is accounted for to some extent (see "mutiny is unlikely" in the article you cited). It remains possible that ranking members of the executive branch and military might cooperate to make sure the president is isolated and unable to execute the protocol, and perhaps even conceivable (if unlikely) that enough of the military would refuse to participate. But that's the only real check, and it extralegal rather than any part of the system. If you've ever been suspicious of "the deep state", think about that for a minute here, because it's really just another catchy term for the one of a half-handful of checks on the power under discussion here. > I think the trope stays around because people, despite what they say publicly, like the idea of an emperor style president with supreme power. I suspect that people really want to believe the system works, it can't be that messed up, someone else thought of this, some one else is paying attention, and they want things to be better, not worse, and they will take care of it for you.
- redy 9y agoMutiny is likely. American officers in particular will tend not to follow orders to commit an obvious war crime. This isn't an extralegal check , it's very much legal. But the system will fail if "the whole chain is stupid." This is why it's so dangerous to have a President obsessed with loyalty.
- astronautjones 9y agoYes, and that's why we have so many obligatory legal oaths. It is kind of astonishing that Americans without the internet developed a pretty rigorous system so long ago - Joe Rogan (sorry) summarized it well when he said that smart people think they're smart, but they're actually just regurgitating things they've learned from truly genius people from past generations
- deleted 9y ago
- archgoon 9y agoI'm afraid that you have misunderstood the Bloomberg article. Nothing in it is about checking the power of the president (it says itself the president determines when to end the meetings and whether to ignore advice). It is all about verifying that The President has issued the order, and then ensuring that order is carried out. The President is contacted in this scenario simply because he's the only one who can actually authorize retaliation. He is enabled to do that independently, which is what the nuclear football is for. Alex Wellerstein is a academic researcher on the history of nuclear weapons, and he describes the situation thus: http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2016/11/18/the-president-and-the-bomb/ http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2016/11/18/the-president-and-... """ >>Are there any checks in place to keep the US President from starting a nuclear war? What's amazing about this question, really, is how seriously it misunderstands the logic of the US command and control system. It gets it exactly backwards. The entire point of the US command and control system is to guarantee that the President and _only_ the President is capable of authorizing nuclear war whenever he needs to. It is about enabling the President's power, not checking or restricting him. """
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoThe keywords here are "whenever he needs to". Are there verified nuclear warheads on verified trajectories from verified origins? Does the US President need to retaliated?
- sooheon 9y agoThe problem is that nobody else's opinion matters. If the president wants to retaliate based on 0 evidence, they can.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI was just describing the official process. Having spent 14 years in the military I can tell you that it's more complex than just that. The entire point of the US command and control system is to guarantee that the President and only the President is capable of authorizing nuclear war whenever he needs to. Yes, legally and formally. Informally though, as I said, it won't go down like that, especially if it's not completely unambiguous that there is a nuclear attack on the US.
- jtmb 9y agoIt makes for good drama. Like House of Cards. Or Fallout. We enjoy thinking our way through doomsday scenarios.