5 ms·
I've been disappointed in linux filesystems and Intel hardware lately. Little integrity checking in ext4 and btrfs is still having growing pains. Recent searc
by mixmastamyk 9y ago
I've been disappointed in linux filesystems and Intel hardware lately. Little integrity checking in ext4 and btrfs is still having growing pains. Recent search for a svelte laptop with ECC memory yielded nothing. Sheesh, wasn't this stuff invented like 30+ years ago?
I understand Intel is segmenting reliability into higher-priced business gear, but as a developer that depends on this stuff for their livelihood the current status quo is not acceptable.
Linux should have better options since profit margins are not an impediment.
- edgan 9y agoThe closest you will get that I know of is a Lenovo P50/P51. They have builds with Xeons with ECC. But I remember when ECC memory dropped out of favor. I wish it had never happened.
- solotronics 9y agoall the new AMD chips have ECC by default which is exciting we will see how their mobile chips stack up
- zokier 9y agoHasn't all "big" AMD CPUs supported ECC to some degree as long as the memory controller has been on the CPU? The real problem on that side has been motherboard support which has been afaik pretty much nonexistent.
- Teknoman117 9y agoAll of the FX series CPUs supported ECC memory (albeit the unbuffered kind). As you said, finding a compatible motherboard was a pain. All the ones I found used the massively power hungry 990FX-A chipset. But I did get one, and my home NAS uses an FX-8350. Kind of scary getting an automated email every week or so about a bit flip that would have otherwise been silent corruption on my home desktop.
- dmm 9y agoA bit flip every week is way higher than it should be.
- zokier 9y agoI have to agree, segmenting on ECC feels really outmoded these days. With Intel you basically need a Xeon even before you can start thinking about ECC, and that does limit your options somewhat. Luckily at least these days Intel is making mobile Xeons, so you can get ECC laptops from most major manufacturers (I checked Dell, HP and Fujitsu, and according to sibling comment Lenovo too).
- ianai 9y agoIt's the laptop manufacturers that are to blame. Check out the specs on this i3 with ecc support. http://ark.intel.com/products/90734/Intel-Core-i3-6100T-Processor-3M-Cache-3_20-GHz http://ark.intel.com/products/90734/Intel-Core-i3-6100T-Proc... Granted, that's still not a laptop CPU. But it's not a Xeon either.
- dijit 9y agoDell Precision 5520 with a Xeon supports ECC memory (up to 64G DDR4) and it's the same size as an XPS.
- thijsvandien 9y agoThe CPU supports it but I still don't see the option to actually configure it with ECC memory (which has been keeping me from buying one for quite a while now).
- dijit 9y agoI have one with ECC memory that's seen my archlinux. I had to buy the memory myself but I was looking for "better" memory anyway.
- thijsvandien 9y agoAre you absolutely positive that ECC is functional? What memory did you opt for? Does this void warranty?
- dijit 9y agoMemory upgrades on this line to not void warranty; however it seems my exact memory is not commercially available (yet). I can see the full "width" in linux, which indicates that the OS can see it.
- Roritharr 9y agoSo you bought it with 8GB non-ECC, plugged in 2* 32GB ECC Dimms and it works? I can't find those DIMMs, 16GB DIMMs are the biggest I can find.
- dijit 9y agoYep, I think I'm using memory that is not commercially available although I didn't know it before. I can't find them online. For reference they're Samsung branded, I can take a photo if you like; you can see the "width" of the channel in linux which tells you if you're using ECC or not.
- ioquatix 9y agoHere is a decent build that I recently did for my home server: https://forums.freenas.org/index.php?threads/any-help-with-my-build-appreciated.54377/page-2 https://forums.freenas.org/index.php?threads/any-help-with-m... It uses the Intel G4560 which supports ECC, and is very inexpensive. It's low power too.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]