3 ms·
"Net neutrality is the idea that there should be a specific QoS setting required by law." That's not correct. Net neutrality is the idea that the ISP should n
by yellowapple 9y ago
"Net neutrality is the idea that there should be a specific QoS setting required by law."
That's not correct. Net neutrality is the idea that the ISP should not be enforcing QoS settings. Instead, that should be left to each customer to decide for one's own allocated bandwidth.
The fact that ISPs choose to oversell their residential bandwidth is the ISPs' problem alone. Punishing the customer (or third parties which which the customer does business) for the ISP's poor business decisions is nonsensical.
"If the ISP de-prioritizes youtube.com a bit so that its own VOIP offering can remain crystal clear during heavy usage, that should be completely up to the ISP."
No, it absolutely should not. The customer - and the customer alone - is the one who ought to decide how said customer's bandwidth is allocated.
"There is no need for net neutrality because ISPs want to make customers happy, and if they fail to do so, another ISP will."
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
No.
ISPs - especially in the United States - couldn't care less if the customer is happy. The customer will pay no matter what, because the customer has very few (if any) choices.
"The last thing the internet needs is non-technical people creating regulation for it."
Indeed. Too bad the vast majority of the technical people are in favor of net neutrality.
- grandalf 9y ago> that should be left to each customer to decide for one's own allocated bandwidth Bandwidth cannot be conceptualized without a notion of time, which is the essence of QoS. Traffic shaping over time. I'd argue that consumers choose their QoS when choosing a residential circuit instead of a business class circuit. Business class circuits offer dedicated bandwidth, and residential circuits offer shared bandwidth and are priced accordingly. > ISPs choose to oversell their residential bandwidth is the ISPs' problem alone This is not a problem it is the definition of residential bandwidth as compared with dedicated circuit bandwidth which is typically sold to business customers at a higher price. In a business class circuit the traffic typically uses the full capability of the circuit up to the hardware/connection limits. > customer alone - is the one who ought to decide I agree circuits like this should be sold, but they would not sell for the same price as residential bandwidth. The only way residential circuits can be sold at a profit is by ISPs doing the arbitrage differently because they are not agreeing to provide a specific amount of peak/average bandwidth 24/7 as they do in a business class contract. > customer has very few (if any) choices What better way to identify areas where ISPs are abusing their market power than by observing the QoS settings they use? I'd prefer to let ISPs operate unhindered and then have regulators attack the ones that are specifically abusing their last mile monopolies. > Too bad the vast majority of the technical people are in favor of net neutrality This is indeed too bad. It stems from the last mile monopolies, which are a legacy of a heavily regulated telecom space. Note that POTS circuits had a minimum latency requirement and are still lower latency for long distance real time audio than many internet circuits using voip codecs. I think the name "net neutrality" was wisely chosen and has made many people believe that ISPs do not have an incentive to deliver generally neutral services. Residential bandwidth needs to be the mass market option without regulatory impediments. It's hard to predict how net neutrality will harm the internet, but over time the harm will be substantial.
- yellowapple 9y ago"This is not a problem it is the definition of residential bandwidth" Which is a problem. If an ISP chooses to oversell its bandwidth for a given segment of its residential customer-base, then it's already in the business of deceiving its customers. If the ISPs didn't do this (or at the very least provided some minimum guaranteed bandwidth, with or without a maximum "burst" speed similar to what's happening now for residential customers), then they wouldn't be in a situation where they feel it necessary to be the ones imposing QoS settings upon their customers. > I agree circuits like this should be sold It doesn't even have to be a different kind of circuit. Just because the ISP chooses to oversell its bandwidth allocations doesn't mean it has to dictate each residential customer's QoS settings. If we have a neighborhood of 10 households, each with a 100Mbps plan, all sharing a single 100Mbps pipe, then the question of how the ISP needs to divide this bandwidth at peak hours is simple: divide evenly between the households. Then, each household can decide what to do with the resulting 10Mbps pipe. At non-peak, when maybe two houses are using the Internet heavily, they can then each decide what to do with their respective 50Mbps (or probably a bit less, since there will surely be some mild Internet use in the less-active households). That means ISPs don't get to force their residential customers to make room for the ISP's own over-the-Internet products, though. What customer would possibly prefer Hulu and Vonage over the ISP's own half-baked shoddy TV and VoIP solutions? The customers obviously don't know what they want! "I'd prefer to let ISPs operate unhindered and then have regulators attack the ones that are specifically abusing their last mile monopolies." The fact that ISPs have last mile monopolies in the first place is exactly why they should be regulated like any other public utility. I'd much prefer that actually happen than pretend that the not-actually-free market will magically fix anything (if the last 30 years are anything to go by: it won't). "has made many people believe that ISPs do not have an incentive to deliver generally neutral services." Because they don't. Not unless net neutrality is enforced (and even then). Without net neutrality, ISPs have every incentive to squeeze every last penny out of their customers while not actually improving anything. We as a society have witnessed this for decades. In rural parts (and even quite a few urban parts) of America, this is still an ongoing struggle, and one which I've personally and repeatedly witnessed and experienced firsthand.
- 9y ago