6 ms·
Visa to Pay Restaurants to Stop Taking Cash
- phil21 9y agoI'm curious how this would work in a sit-down resturant, if the server doesn't explicitly state this (or require payment) prior to ordering. Once the food is ordered and consumed, you are then presented with a check. This is now a debt. Vendors certainly are not required to accept cash during a transaction, but you are absolutely required to accept cash if someone is settling a debt. Might be an interesting case at some point. This is simply ignoring Visa trying to enact their merchant discount tax on every transaction within the US economy though. This road (lack of anonymous and free means of payment) ends in tears.
- scotu 9y agoI don't think it's a problem, the first time that happens is a mess, the second one it's written on the menu. Problem solved
- scott_s 9y agoWriting on a menu does not prevent it from happening, in either good faith (customer didn't see it) or bad faith (customer knows it, and is trying to see if they can get a free meal) situations.
- dragonwriter 9y agoLeaving cash on the table at a sit-down restaurant to pay for a meal isn't “trying to get a free meal.”
- scott_s 9y agoI agree. I was imagining a situation where the (bad faith) customer insists on using cash, the restaurant does not have the infrastructure for cash, and as a result (for whatever reason) the customer ends up not paying. Leaving cash on the table would be a good faith customer.
- Spivak 9y agoI don't think the courts would agree. Unless you pay for your food up front you've still acquired debt which must be payable in dollars.
- rsj_hn 9y agoIt's not solved at all. You eat your meal. Now you owe a debt. Pay with cash. The whole point of legal tender laws is that you can always settle a debt with cash, regardless of what is says on the menu. What the restaurant would need to do is ask you to pay up front with visa, or to provide your visa prior to ordering so that they could charge you. That would solve the problem if they charged you before you ate the meal, but if they try to charge your visa after the meal and the charge is declined, you can still settle with cash. But somehow, with the tax avoidance issues with tips, they would either not do this or ask for the tip in cash.
- ue_ 9y agoI don't understand this. Surely it's up to me to accept whatever I want? If I tell you in advance that I want 5 apples in return for my 10 potatoes, that's all I'll accept. I don't want money, I want apples. Why is this any different? Can you really "always settle a debt with cash"? Even if you are told beforehand that the deal isn't for cash? Would this mean that I am effectively forced to accept cash for rendering goods or services?
- phil21 9y ago> Surely it's up to me to accept whatever I want? It is, up until the point you turn it into a debt. This means you can require trading apples in return for potatoes, but you have to do the transaction up-front. So if you ran a food stand and rejected any cash transactions at the point of sale, you are completely within the law. You could not give your apples to your neighbor in the spring, and force them to settle up via potatoes in the fall. If they wanted to, they could pay you the equivalent of their potato debt in cash. And yes, if someone ends up owing you money and offers you cash to settle - you must accept it, with very few exceptions. All debts public and private actually does have some serious teeth after all. A long time ago I had to settle a bet on this topic, and it was more extensive than this. The tldr; is that at no time in US history have you been forced to take US currency, with the exception of debts. It actually does make sense. What happens in the event your neighbors potato harvest fails and they get out of the business? If you sued them in court, the court would award you the market value of the replacement cost of the potatoes you did not receive (most likely). And thus they would be settling up via cash either way.
- EGreg 9y agoDollars are legal tender for all debts, public and private. It means you can walk out without paying and if they sue you, they'll just get the dollars anyway. To be honest, no one would spend money to sue you for $30 anyway. However, you won't be able to go to that restauran again. Also, I believe even if they WARN YOU in advance that they don't take cash, you could STILL go and eat and then offer cash! Because LEGAL TENDER. Estoppel is only a defense, can't be used to prosecute someone and get them to pay by VISA.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- refurb 9y agoThere is, however, no Federal statute mandating that a private business, a person or an organization must accept currency or coins as for payment for goods and/or services. Private businesses are free to develop their own policies on whether or not to accept cash unless there is a State law which says otherwise.[1] [1]http://www.news-leader.com/story/news/watchdog/2014/12/24/ask-watchdog-can-business-refuse-cash/20883777/ http://www.news-leader.com/story/news/watchdog/2014/12/24/as...
- URSpider94 9y agoFrom the article: "What about debts already incurred, such as a restaurant bill presented after the meal is eaten, a lawsuit judgment or an annual tax bill? For those debts, a plain reading of the Coinage Act suggests that any kind of legal tender, whether coins or bills, must be accepted."
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> It means you can walk out without paying and if they sue you, they'll just get the dollars anyway. I'm pretty sure dine-and-dashers don't just get sued - they get arrested. I'm wary of people offering legal advice and interpretation without some credentials.
- raverbashing 9y ago
- justboxing 9y ago> This is now a debt. This exactly. That's why I always pay cash, incl. tips. A charge on a credit card is essentially a loan from the Credit Card Company at the agreed upon interest rate. So I'm not comfortable taking out a loan to pay for my food -- granted you don't pay any interest if you pay your bills in full on time, but still it just feels wrong. I also pay cash because I want the wait staff to get the entire tip amount I leave -- usually generous around 25% to 30% minimum. Because I was told by several waiters (mostly at Indian / Pakistani restaurants here in San Francisco) that if the tip is left on the card, that they never see it ever * . [ * A waiter friend at Dosa on Fillmore told me this is illegal and that I should report it. Who do I report it to? And will they really take action? In a couple of Indian restaurants in downtown, the wait staff doesn't get the cash tip either. 1 waiter friend discouraged me from leaving any tip because they don't get a single penny. I tried to insert some cash in his pocket and he got scared. I think the owners forbid them from taking any cash from customers even if it's tip ]
- code_duck 9y agoWhat about using a debit card? That's not a loan.
- justboxing 9y agoCorrect. That's why I explicitly said > A charge on a credit card
- jrs235 9y agoBut depending on how the debit card is run (often as a credit card) there are still fees and a cut being taken by Visa or MasterCard... I wonder if the establishment eats all of the transaction costs and gives the full tip amount on receipt to the wait staff or if some pass on some of the transaction cost(s) and take it off the top of the tip (unscrupulous and shady if they do).
- code_duck 9y agoYes, and then you said you always pay cash for that reason, but didn't mention debit cards as an alternative. The desire to make sure the waitstaff gets your tips still applies.
- dragonwriter 9y agoEven with notice, the same logic applies, and, anyway, what are they going to do when you leave cash on the table? Not deposit it and treat the person who paid it like a dine-and-dasher? On the fast-food and fast-casual end with payment up front, OTOH, this might work in theory, but that's the segment that can least afford to exclude the unbanked, so the payment is going to have to be significant.
- prostoalex 9y ago> if the server doesn't explicitly state this (or require payment) prior to ordering. Seems like asking for an immediate credit card pre-auth wouldn't be that much of a shift in cultural norms.
- spiralpolitik 9y agoGas stations already ask cash users to pre-pay and pre-auth credit/debit cards so the shift would be tiny.
- gist 9y agoThere is almost certainly nothing legally to prevent them from taking cash. The idea is simply (probably) to get them to say they only take credit cards. Obviously they will take cash if the person only has cash and insists. They post that they don't accept cash and if someone doesn't see that they will take cash and Visa will be fine with it (where 'fine' means they will look the other way). It's the golden rule. He who has the gold rules. [1] The one with the balance of power wins. [1] Let's say in the normal course of business you are owed $5000 and have been trying to get a deadbeat customer to pay for a year. It's obvious that you don't want to get paid in pennies. In this case the customer says 'I will pay you but it has to be pennies'. What would anyone do? Accept the pennies.
- DoctorBit 9y agoPlease stop linking to pay walled articles.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- martinald 9y agoThis is becoming increasingly common in the UK. A lot of popup stores only take card (contactless). I very rarely see people using cash these days - so it's a lot of hassle to collect and process cash for a small % of customers that do use it.
- EGreg 9y agoBristol Pounds!
- sofaofthedamned 9y agoHaha. I live near there in Cheltenham and have read quite a bit about the BP. Do people actually use it, what's the acceptance rate, and is it a good thing?
- EGreg 9y agoWell from what I heard, it helps keep money circulating within the economy. When you pay someone in BP you are in a sense investing in Bristol's continued vibrancy.
- heimatau 9y agoI don't like this idea one bit. We have a digital cash solution (crypto-currency) but there are too many hurdles to implement it (USA probably doesn't want to give up their de-facto status as the world's reserve currency and...it's ability to change it's value with the flip of a switch [i.e. Fed's recent QE programs]). I'm not sure how society will grapple with this (cashless society) but I hope we simplify crypto to make it as simple as cash.
- prostoalex 9y agoWhat's the cost of a single BTC transaction in today's dollars?
- heimatau 9y agoToo much, imho.
- oval-atom 9y agoVISA would have to make it worth while to compensate for unreported cash sales.
- gregw134 9y agoLet's hope visa doesn't convince society that getting rid of cash is the future. Not only would that be a terrible blow to privacy, it would entrench the need to pay Visa or another credit card company 2% of every transaction.
- __jal 9y agoI'll stop eating at any place that doesn't take cash. I mostly use cash for small transactions, because I like it. As you say, I see no reason why the CC cartel should get 1/50th of retail transactions by virtue of being too big to fail (or too big to stop from colluding).
- Spivak 9y agoNah, let Visa destroy themselves with terrible business decisions. If they successfully eliminate cash then the logical step is to create a nationalized payment processor.
- dragonwriter 9y agoExactly; when banknotes displace coin as the main payment mechanism, it wasn't long till government extended their monopoly to banknotes. So, yeah, I can see VISA inadvertently hastening the day when everyone pays with their Federal Reserve Card.
- giggles_giggles 9y agoIsn't it illegal for a merchant to refuse US currency in the US?
- adammunich 9y agoAfter debts incurred, yes.
- Sohcahtoa82 9y agoAt the point of sale, no. For a debt, yes. If you go to a store or a fast-food restaurant where you pay before being able to take the goods, then they can legally refuse to accept cash. But at a full service restaurant, once your food has been delivered to you and you have eaten it, your bill to the restaurant is considered a debt. They legally MUST take cash in this case.
- seiferteric 9y agoAren't restaurants already paying visa by way of transaction fees? Unless the amount visa is giving back is > the amount in transaction fees, what is the incentive?
- pm90 9y agoExcellent point. And this does seem to be the case: > United States coins and currency (including Federal reserve notes and circulating notes of Federal reserve banks and national banks) are legal tender for all debts, public charges, taxes and dues. Foreign gold or silver coins are not legal tender for debts.
- URSpider94 9y agoCash has costs too. You have to track it, it gets stolen, you have to write out deposit slips and drive it to the bank every night. Banks also charge for treasury services, I.e. Processing your cash deposits and keeping you stocked with coins and small bills. I've never seen a full accounting, but I wouldn't be surprised if a fully cash-free business actually had better overall costs, even with the card fee taken into account.
- sofaofthedamned 9y agoAFAIK this is a reason supermarkets give cashback, as it reduces their cash processing costs (and isn't charged at the normal rate by the CC providers). Is this true?
- URSpider94 9y agoDon't know, but I do know a lot of supermarkets used to offer their employees to cash their paychecks in the store - probably for the same reason, to reduce deposits.
- jaclaz 9y agoLer's make a practical example. We are talking here of (smallish) restaurants. You get 4,000 dollars in cash, after having prepared and sold in your restaurant 100 meals at 40 US$ each on average. Visa (or other card processor+ all the fees) will get (example taken from here): https://www.paypal.com/us/webapps/mpp/brc/demystifying-credit-card-processor-fees https://www.paypal.com/us/webapps/mpp/brc/demystifying-credi... 3%+0.25 US$/transaction. That is 0.034000+0.25100=120+25=145 dollars If you have cash and while driving home you deposit the money at the bank you have 4,000 US$, if you go all Visa you have 3,855 dollars. You get 155 dollars for spending 10 minutes more on the way home. Even if you manage to get half of that rate, you get 75 dollars for 10 minutes. Before, you probably worked (once detracted costs) for 10% net of the 4,000 dollars i.e. 400 dollars for 8 to 10 hours of (hard) work or 40-50 dollars per hour (and the average small restaurant cook/owner rarely can make that much).
- circadiam 9y agoPaywall removed https://outline.com/6gJU6n https://outline.com/6gJU6n
- _0ffh 9y agoI guess this move would be outright illegal in at least some countries. Cash is legal tender, nearly everywhere. In some countries that means if you're selling something to someone in person, you have to accept it as a payment method.
- Alex3917 9y agoWouldn't this have the effect of preventing many minorities from dining at certain restaurants? E.g.: http://www.creditcards.com/credit-card-news/race-age-gender-statistics.php http://www.creditcards.com/credit-card-news/race-age-gender-...
- dragonwriter 9y agoThat's actually a reason some restaurants might sign up for it; it's racial discrimination they can get away with.
- TearsInTheRain 9y agoUgh the libertarian in me just died a little inside.
- rdtsc 9y agoSo that shady servers can take away your card, copy the numbers including the 3 digit extra "security" code and then use it to buy things online with it. At least if restaurants had those portable scanner machine like they do in other countries, but they don't here in US usually.
- grandalf 9y agoI dealt with this issue as a young boy when trying to pay for some candy at the local bodega with a large sack of pennies. The clerk simply refused my business. I was outraged and asked some lawyers in my family to look into it. Turns out the business had no obligation to accept the transaction. "Legal Tender" means that the currency may be legally used as currency, not that it must be accepted when offered/tendered.
- CupOfJava 9y agoYour situation is similar. However, did you consume the candy before paying? Or maybe restaurants will ask customers to pay first if they use this.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThere is a difference between accepting a purchase transaction offered and accepting payment for a debt which has been occurred. The former is a matter of whether a contract is formed at immediately fulfilled and the latter of whether an existing contract is violated in a manner that the State will concern itself with. Restaurants sometimes operate in the former mode (fast-food and fast-casual) and sometimes in the latter (full table service).
- grandalf 9y agoI've never thought of it that way before in terms of a contract. Very interesting.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- boomboomsubban 9y agoFrom what I can tell, Visa is offering an essay contest food establishments can enter on why their store would benefit from going cashless. Then they "pledge" to go cashless and get the money. Hard to say for sure when the site for it says "details coming" and every article is using the same press release. So, an ad campaign saying "credit cards are better than cash."
- justboxing 9y agoThis won't fly. Lot of mom'n'pops restaurants prefer cash so they can under-report their income and save on tax. In fact, quite a few restaurants that I've been to in San Francisco take only cash. Ex: Udipi on Valencia near Dosa has a big board at door and at counter that says in caps "CASH ONLY"
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Lot of mom'n'pops restaurants prefer cash so they can under-report their income and save on tax. Or just avoid paying the private tax on card processing.
- sofaofthedamned 9y agoPlenty of chinese takeaways in the UK that only accept cash. The one near me doesn't put it in the till, it's taken to the back, and asking for a receipt infuriates them. There's plenty of reasons to take cash only over and above CC charges.
- likpok 9y agoAIUI though this can be something of a false economy. Cash has processing fees too: you need to pay someone to count it, secure it, take it to the bank. Plus you need to deal with shrinkage. I can't find numbers now, but I remember seeing somewhere that suggested all of this was not all that much less than credit card processing fees. The only citation I can find now is that theft is something like $40 billion, falling most heavily on small businesses that don't pay for transport.
- snakeanus 9y agoSome people just hate privacy and not depending on 3rd party companies, huh?
- code_duck 9y agoAs a retail merchant, I'd never want to intentionally restrict accepted payment methods. It's bound to lose you some sales, period. I don't think $10,000 would even be worth it for a food business. I'm more used to encountering the opposite - establishments that, sometimes unexpectedly, only accept cash. If an ATM of my bank isn't nearby, usually the only option is to use a 3rd party ATM, which incurs fees that usually total 10-30%. The one time I've found t difficult to have only cash and not a credit card is when driving in remote areas at night. You may encounter gas stations that are closed, but have pumps on for card transactions, but no way to pay with cash.
- ryandrake 9y agoFrom the small snippet of the article I can actually read without the paywall, it looks like Visa is not offering to pay restaurants--it's offering to upgrade their payment systems for them (which have some dollar value). I'd love to know: 1. Why on Earth a restaurant would willingly turn down a customer who has cash in hand and is willing to pay, and 2. How on Earth Visa is going to verify that the restaurant doesn't take cash. For 1. many restaurants I've been to love cash and give you the stink eye when you pull out a card (because fees). The incentives seem to not make sense. For 2. is Visa actually going to send spies into restaurants and have them offer cash and see if the owner bites? I don't know this just all seems like crazy-land.
- prostoalex 9y ago> 1. Why on Earth a restaurant would willingly turn down a customer who has cash in hand and is willing to pay There's a risk of employees stealing cash, a risk of being robbed, the cost to store and bank the cash (purchasing the safe, depositing the cash in the bank account, making sure the restaurant has the right coins and bills to make change), the risk of accepting counterfeited cash. Those risks and costs widely among the restaurants, of course. From the article: "Michael Ryan, the co-owner and co-founder, said he never ordered cash drawers or a safe. By not having to count cash, visit a bank or order change, Mr. Ryan estimates, the manager on duty saves about 23 hours a week."
- jaclaz 9y ago>From the article: "Michael Ryan, the co-owner and co-founder, said he never ordered cash drawers or a safe. By not having to count cash, visit a bank or order change, Mr. Ryan estimates, the manager on duty saves about 23 hours a week." Still from the article: "Some merchants have already stopped taking cash. New York City-based 2nd City, a Filipino taqueria, hasn’t accepted cash since it opened its doors in 2016." The owner and co-founder has seemingly more than a whopping whole year of experience in the field. How much does he pay in transaction fees per week in order to save the (calculated/estimated) 23 hours of work? As a testimonial, I would like to have someone who managed a restaurant for 10-20 years and then in 2016 decided to go "no cash".
- spiralpolitik 9y agoAdding a cash handling charge to any cash users would remove the incentive to use cash. In Europe and Canada chip and pin reduced the use of cash significantly. Contactless and mobile payment options like Apple Pay is the next nail in the coffin. Merchant's like it (not have to transfer large sums of cash to the back, significantly reduced risk of fraud), Government's like it (easier to ensure that the correct tax is being paid on transactions) and Consumers like it (don't have to carry cash). The US is significantly behind in this area which is why credit cards getting cloned and used at physical stores is still an issue.
- revmoo 9y agoDon't post paywalled content