3 ms·
It seems like what he is claiming is that his mom instantly clicks like on everything and so the post gets gated before his other friends ever have the opportun
by emodendroket 9y ago
It seems like what he is claiming is that his mom instantly clicks like on everything and so the post gets gated before his other friends ever have the opportunity to indicate whether they like it.
- ghostly_s 9y agoThe missing detail here of course is...maybe his posts aren't getting engagement outside of mom because his Facebook 'friends' aren't interested in them?
- emodendroket 9y agoWell, that would seem to be contradicted by the observation that his friends do engage with them if he hides the posts from his mom.
- scottmf 9y agoI feel like accounting for people who like everything would be one of the first things built into such an algorithm. He should try alternating the privacy settings with each post.
- emodendroket 9y agoI realize there isn't an extreme level of rigor here, but it gets tiresome reading HN comments where it's just a series of increasingly extravagant hoops for the original article to jump through before the commenter is willing to accept that the findings might be valid and give any consideration to the article's implications.
- aeturnum 9y agoA lot of this seems like it comes down to how that initial pool of users is treated. If they show it to 5 users and his mom is the only one (ever) that likes it, then it makes sense to show that content to people common to him and his mom. If the other users like it, they should distribute it more widely and maybe include users from other non-overlapping networks. That all seems good. If mom likes 90% of the posts, then show that 90% to the family and maybe they care and maybe they don't. If it gets engagement from other people, share it more widely. That seems like a good approach. The wrong way to do it would be to show it to 5 people and as soon as his mom likes the content, decide the content won't be interesting to the other 4 people they showed it to. I haven't seen any evidence of that happening, and I don't think the article points to any (anecdotal or otherwise).
- emodendroket 9y agoWell, like I said to the other guy, I don't know how you account for the fact that he gets engagement from other people if he hides the posts from his mom then.