4 ms·
Ubuntu has a history of doing things that don't go anywhere: upstart, unity, their phone thing. Fedora has concentrated on being a solid, traditional Linux desk
by nailer 9y ago
Ubuntu has a history of doing things that don't go anywhere: upstart, unity, their phone thing. Fedora has concentrated on being a solid, traditional Linux desktop. If that's what you want, Fedora could be it.
- JdeBP 9y agoThat argument would have worked better if it hadn't been the case that Fedora used upstart for a few years.
- nailer 9y agoMain thing is that Ubuntu used it in their LTS distro in 14.04 when everyone else had already shifted to .service files.
- JdeBP 9y agoAnd that argument would have worked better if Ubuntu 14.04 had not been released in April 2014, before Debian made its decision. It was only Debian, by the way, not everyone else. Indeed, everyone has has not shifted to .service files even now.
- Longhanks 9y agoUbuntu also has a history of things that go pretty well: Easy setup for average users including nonfree drivers, reaching a point of popularity where developers target Ubuntu first, PPAs as lightweight repositories for own packages, huge offspring of distros based on it. Not everything is black and white, and while Ubuntu has failed in some aspects, it succeeded in others. Also, they are not hesitant to admit a failure, upstart is a thing of the past with Ubuntu using systemd, unity and "their phone thing" are being discontinued with focus shifting to the Gnome desktop and the traditional PC/Laptop/server market.
- glogla 9y ago> Fedora has concentrated on being a solid, traditional Linux desktop. If you consider pulseaudio, systemd and not being able to play mp3 traditional. Also, they used to fuck with encryption in some way, not sure if they still do it. In the end, do you trust more Poettering or Debian or Ubuntu developers?
- proaralyst 9y agoRed Hat took $2.4 billion in revenue last year.[0] I trust them more. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Hat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Hat
- falcolas 9y agoRevenue generates trust? How do you feel about Oracle? Only a little sarcastic; RHEL and Red Hat's historic treatment of CentOS had a lot of echos of Oracle's treatment of similar projects. They've gotten a little better in some regards (now own CentOS and seem to care about it) and worse in others (the of marketing and politics instead of merit).
- nailer 9y ago> "RHEL and Red Hat's historic treatment of CentOS" What? Red Hat didn't treat CentOS badly: they happily let people make trademark-less respins of their OS per the license and didn't try and stop anyone from doing so. (Disclaimer: worked for RH around 2003-6)
- Annatar 9y agoIn Bryan Cantrill, Jerry Jelinek, Adam Leventhal, Eric Schrock, Matt Ahrens, Bill Moore, Jeff Bonwick, Robert Mustacci and Dan Price we trust; all others pay cash.
- JdeBP 9y agoFalse dichotomy. When last measured, the ninth most prolific systemd developer, out of just under 600, was Martin Pitt, of Canonical.
- abrowne 9y agoAs long as "[doesn't] go anywhere" means in RHEL for upstart (before being replaced by systemd) and on more desktops than Fedora for Unity.
- fundabulousrIII 9y agoFedora is bleeding edge for RHEL. This is the test distro for enterprise. If you want consistent behavior maybe fedora isn't for you. In general, RHEL has made some controversial decisions for userspace and fedora is the first place you will find these.