14 ms·
One of the main problems was the speed with which systemd was rolled out on all the major Linux distros, despite it being relatively immature and very controver
by pmoriarty 9y ago
One of the main problems was the speed with which systemd was rolled out on all the major Linux distros, despite it being relatively immature and very controversial at that.
The second major issue is it growing way out of the bounds of being just an init replacement, thereby violating the so-called Unix Philosophy of doing one-thing well. For a user app to do that is one thing, but for a core OS component to do that just smells way too much like forcing Linux to be more like Windows, which a lot of hard-core Linux users are ideologically opposed to.
The third major issue is that on most major Linux distros, users are not given an easy way to avoid using systemd, no matter how much they hate it or oppose it.
The fourth issue is the apparent arrogance of the people responsible for systemd, and their off-hand dismissal of mature and widely respected unix conventions.
All of this adds up to a storm of controversy that the systemd people mostly brought upon themselves. Had they just been more humble about their creation and waited until it was mature and well-tested and did all the wonderful things they claim it could and should do instead of stuffing what was widely seen as a broken-by-design piece of garbage down everybody's throat, maybe much of the Linux community wouldn't have been nearly so outraged by it.
- KirinDave 9y ago> One of the main problems was the speed with which systemd was rolled out on all the major Linux distros, despite it being relatively immature and very controversial at that. I agree this is a big part of the problem, and appreciate it being raised. > All of this adds up to a storm of controversy that the systemd people mostly brought upon themselves I think Systemd comports itself as project exactly like most free software projects do, including Linux. Linus creates a template and then rages about how he doesn't like it.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoDon't forget security. When there's a problem with systemd shit hits the fan. When there's a problem with a widely used piece of software that only does one job the mess is smaller and easier to clean up.
- KirinDave 9y agoI'm sorry, but this just isn't a fair comparison. Software is hard and the impact of software security issues is seldom limited to just one tiny place where it originates.
- lomnakkus 9y agoWhat? Need I remind you of Heartbleed?
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoYes, it was an issue in one moving part. The fix did not require significant tiptoeing around to prevent breaking everything else. It's a perfect example of the "do one thing well" philosophy paying off.
- sseveran 9y agoAll that may be true. But I prefer today writing a little file that is a systemd service than fixing up someone else's init scripts. If it is as broken as you say why was it adopted?
- bitwize 9y agoBecause Lennart has a lot of pull at Red Hat, and Red Hat has a lot of pull in the Linux community. The BSDs have really straightforward to maintain init scripts. Mainly because all the boilerplate junk is hidden in sourced-in files. Runit takes a more advanced approach, but its service files are still simple scripts a few lines long. We don't need a reinvent-the-world solution like systemd to address the most complained about problems with init.
- horusthecat 9y ago> Because Lennart has a lot of pull at Red Hat... We don't need a reinvent-the-world solution like systemd to address the most complained about problems with init. You work in software right? You never ever "just" replace a system with an improved feature-alike product, you go apeshit crazy with cool stuff you wanted for the past 5 years but couldn't get approved, until you run out of budget. Duh.
- KirinDave 9y agoThey're straightforward because they both do less and appeal to she'll scripting to get it done. I specifically want Turing completeness out of my configuration languages.
- digi_owl 9y agoAt the rate they are adding and modifying stuff, i am sure we can turn service files touring complete soon enough...
- jcrites 9y agoIt was adopted because the maintainers of distributions like Debian examined the alternatives and decided that systemd was technically superior. For example, please see the analysis of systemd and upstart by Debian maintainer and then-Technical Committee member Russ Allbery: https://lists.debian.org/debian-ctte/2013/12/msg00234.html https://lists.debian.org/debian-ctte/2013/12/msg00234.html
- happypants23 9y agoThe second major issue is it growing way out of the bounds of being just an init replacement, thereby violating the so-called Unix Philosophy of doing one-thing well. I keep on hearing this overly worn "Unix Philosophy" argument against systemd, which in the absence of any non-religious technical justification, basically boils down to "its different". All of this adds up to a storm of controversy that the systemd people mostly brought upon themselves. Had they just been more humble about their creation and waited until it was mature and well-tested and did all the wonderful things they claim it could and should do instead of stuffing what was widely seen as a broken-by-design piece of garbage down everybody's throat, maybe much of the Linux community wouldn't have been nearly so outraged by it. Nobody shoved anything down anyone's throat, least not the SystemD developers. And the same goes for PulseAudio, DBUS, and all the other projects on freedesktop.org. Anyway, in reality, software does not become mature and well-tested without early exposure to real users and systems. Chicken-and-egg problem there. I feel absolutely no sympathy for those who are outraged. There are many distributions out there (including Devuan) which align with their particular vision of an OS should be.
- dijit 9y ago> There are many distributions out there (including Devuan) which align with their particular vision of an OS should be. None of which are used in many companies. I'm pushing my company to go to FreeBSD, but there are many who are completely powerless. "Oh you don't like systemd, better not work on any Linux systems in any company" is the basic gist of what this means.
- sliken 9y agoWhy does an init system need a DNS implementation? Why not use named, unbound, or any of the other implementations? Instead they implement it poorly, have had various problems with it, and of course there have been security problems with it. Do you really want an init system that replaces a ton of functionality poorly like dns, ntp, syslog, xinetd, etc etc etc?
- happypants23 9y ago> Do you really want an init system that replaces a ton of functionality poorly like dns, ntp, syslog, xinetd, etc etc etc? SystemD is not just an "init" system. You have to look at the larger vision for it being a set of building blocks for Linux system and service management. I think this is a very good thing. Its about time that Linux had a unified and self-consistent approach to system management and configuration.
- ksk 9y ago>, thereby violating the so-called Unix Philosophy of doing one-thing well. For a user app to do that is one thing, but for a core OS component to do that just smells way too much like forcing Linux to be more like Windows, which a lot of hard-core Linux users are ideologically opposed to. That ship sailed a long ago when Linus ranted against microkernels :) Linux was never meant to follow a 'do one-thing well' design. It was designed to be a monolithic do-all-things design that's also highly modular.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"That ship sailed a long ago when Linus ranted against microkernels" Was Solaris a microkernel OS? How about SunOS? Irix? DEC OSF/1? HP/UX? Last I checked, they weren't yet all were considered examples of Unix, and all existed before Linux.
- ksk 9y agoThat is great, but I'm not sure what I'm supposed to do with that information? I was merely responding to your inaccurate statement about Linux as it pertains to your opinion on what the "Unix Philosophy" is. Which itself is a mostly irrelevant vague and subjective term that anyone can apply in any way they seem fit, so I suppose there is no point in even arguing over it. Good day !
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]