3 ms·
The problem with a 'each state do their own thing' solution is the very problem with health care in this country in general - the freeloader problem. If Califo
by cortesoft 9y ago
The problem with a 'each state do their own thing' solution is the very problem with health care in this country in general - the freeloader problem.
If California implements a single payer system, it would make people in other states more likely to choose not to get healthcare; if they get sick, they can just move to California.
This is the reason the ACA has the 'individual mandate' to go along with preventing the denial of care because of pre-existing conditions - without some coercive force, there is no reason to buy health care until you get sick.
This is why a national single payer system is the solution.
- flavor8 9y agoI'm not convinced this is insurmountable. How do countries with single payer handle this? Surely you could require an newly established resident who wants treatment to pay a portion since they hadn't been funding it directly via taxes, and then add a further penalty if they move back out of state within a certain period of time (to discourage moving in-state just for treatment).
- Analemma_ 9y ago> I'm not convinced this is insurmountable. How do countries with single payer handle this? I'm confused by your question. Countries with single-payer have the same policy everywhere in the country, so there is no freeloading involved. Unless you're talking about people coming from other countries, in which case it's handled by their immigration policy.
- cortesoft 9y agoIt isn't insurmountable, it basically comes down to having to choose to deny care to someone. However, it is really hard to do it in a fair and humane way; to deny care to people trying to freeload but not deny care to people who aren't. The whole point of universal, single payer, healthcare is to avoid having to make this determination. This isn't an issue for a country because the number of new residents (immigrants) is not a large percentage of the total number of citizens. If it was a state, though, that ratio might not work out; there is a VERY large pool of possible 'freeloaders' who are legally allowed to move to the state whenever they want.
- rayiner 9y agoIt would be unconstitutional for a U.S. state to treat newly-established residents differently than long-established ones with regard to a welfare benefit: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm/supcourt/stories/court051899.htm http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm/supco.... Countries like Germany don't have this problem because they have the power to control their borders. Accessing Germany's healthcare system requires being a German resident. That, in general, requires applying for immigration, which the government may or may not grant. EU citizens can, of course, become German residents without applying for immigration, but every EU state has universal healthcare so there is no incentive to free-ride. And there's a push within Germany and other countries to limit access to welfare benefits for new residents, even ones from other EU countries: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/oct/12/german-government-approves-bill-to-stop-eu-migrants-claiming-benefits https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/oct/12/german-governm.... U.S. states don't have the power to do that.
- Spoom 9y agoThis is interesting; I wasn't aware of this particular ruling. That would make running a universal healthcare program on a state-by-state basis very difficult, if it in fact applied.
- cortesoft 9y agoInteresting... I wonder how places like California are allowed to still offer different rates for in-state vs out-of-state tuition at the UCs?
- tptacek 9y agoThis is a really good question. The most recent case I could find here is the one Rayiner cited, Saenz v. Roe. If you read it, both the opinion and the dissent grapple explicitly with college tuition. The reasoning goes, it seems, that only bona fide citizens of (say) California will consume welfare in California (you don't move to California to consume California welfare benefits in Ohio). But college education benefits are "portable"; you could conceivably move to California solely for the purpose of accumulating the benefits of a UC education, then take it back with you to Ohio. Further, the way in-state tuition benefits are structured, the residency requirement is (supposedly) carefully tailored to address just that scenario, by imposing relatively short durational requirements on residency, rather than evidence of permanent residency. It's tricky to piece out how health care would fit into this rubric. Depending on the condition, you might move to California to benefit from their health care and return to Ohio when you're cured, or you might need to stay in California indefinitely to treat a manageable illness.
- Spoom 9y ago> How do countries with single payer handle this? In Canada, generally you have to be a legal resident (i.e. hold a valid immigration status, not just limited to permanent resident or citizen) of the relevant province, and actually living there for a majority of the time, before being eligible for coverage under the province's health plan. See e.g. http://www.health.gov.on.ca/en/public/programs/ohip/ohipfaq_mn.aspx http://www.health.gov.on.ca/en/public/programs/ohip/ohipfaq_... California would probably have to add a waiting period since not all US residents would otherwise have coverage, as in Canada.
- ClassyJacket 9y agoI don't even understand your question. Countries with single payer handle this by making everyone pay with taxes and having immigration controls.
- luxuryballs 9y agoThis problem is exactly why a single payer system would fail entirely, imagine if you could easily be a freeloader without having to move at all? I don't think the US has the same demographics as the other countries where this currently appears to succeed. There are way more people who can't pay in the US, we're far too big for this.
- ClassyJacket 9y agoYou're proposing that the massive wealth inequality in the USA is a good reason to continue creating more wealth inequality? The old "America is just different to everywhere else" argument... we see this from the gun nuts too.