3 ms·
I would say that the lecture model works, but only when specific preconditions are met: 1) Eager learners who have reflected on the same material before coming
by SilasX 9y ago
I would say that the lecture model works, but only when specific preconditions are met:
1) Eager learners who have reflected on the same material before coming in, to the extent that they know the gaps in their understanding.
2) A lecturer who is above the students' level (on the material) and willing/able to answer arbitrary questions about the topic.
3) Students keeping up and asking questions to ensure that they stay that way (but not so often that progress crawls to a halt).
That was probably typical of medieval universities that taught that way (just a guess though, haven't actually researched it).
Today? Not so much, and so the typical lecture is almost pure waste.
- ghaff 9y agoAmong other things, you're also describing what teaching using case studies looks like for example. There's pre-class reading and the class is built around interactive discussions. It's harder to see how this works for most technical topics outside of project-based courses.
- chongli 9y agoAlmost anything works with eager learners. They learn in spite of the bad teaching methods. They are the best candidates to be autodidacts.
- kwhitefoot 9y agoWe're discussing university lectures? If so why are there any non-eager learners?
- bluGill 9y agoToday it is considered expected to have a degree, but most students do not really understand why, and will not understand until it is too late. They are not motivated, but they know "dad" expects them to get the degree so they slog on learning just enough to get by.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]