9 ms·
Saying Sorry When Things Go Wrong [pdf]
- brian_herman 9y ago?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- valbaca 9y agoI'm sorry, but what's the point of this?
- jbob2000 9y agoIn the US, doctors will not tell you if they made a mistake and caused your condition to worsen, or if the mistake caused the death of your loved one. In the UK, doctors are allowed (and by the looks of this memo, expressly encouraged) to inform the patient of their mistakes and to apologize.
- jslampe 9y agoI believe he was being facetious.
- DanBC 9y agoIn the UK there is a requirement - the duty of candour - to tell people a mistake has been made, and to apologise for it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duty_of_candour https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duty_of_candour I posted it here because I've seen a bunch of apologies also posted to HN recently, and most of them were lousy.
- dm319 9y agoWhy do people post apologies to HN? Any examples?
- arethuza 9y agoI've certainly apologized a few times - usually for writing something that is badly worded, unintentionally inflammatory or simply plain wrong. I certainly apologised profusely when I wrote something that annoyed dang.... :-)
- DanBC 9y agothere have been a few businesses that lost data, or got hacked, or shut down.
- eberkund 9y agoThat's because of the lawsuit culture in the US, apologizing for a mistake admits wrongdoing and could expose you to millions of dollars in damages.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoI had a then-teenage cousin who had a surgical...geez, either a breathing stent or a cerebrospinal shunt, I forget...installed backwards, resulting in minor permanent brain damage before the surgeon realized his mistake. This apparently involved the surgeon sprinting back into the operating room past my aunt and uncle, yelling "I screwed up your kid, meet me here with a lawyer in three hours!"
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoThe point is that you should apologize if your mistake harms someone. Refusing to own up to your errors is unprofessional. That's hardly limited to medicine.
- karmellad 9y agoDoctors don't learn to say sorry in the us?
- smcg 9y agoNote that the above is a UK publication and the laws around apologies are different in other countries. This document I have here (1996, pdf) is a rather good journal article on the subject for US legalities. http://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1313&context=jdr http://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?arti... tl;dr apologies are usually a good thing in your personal life and can prevent litigation in legal matters and are rarely admissible as proof of guilt. I am not a lawyer.
- ntumlin 9y agoOn an unrelated point, I was surprised when I saw how many citations there were in the linked document. I guess it's a law thing but it seemed like every sentence had something to back it up, even stuff like the meaning of "sorry" in the first two sentences, which I thought could be assumed.
- schoen 9y agoVery typical of law review articles (academic publications in legal journals). Compare this famous humorous law review article, "The Common Law Origins of the Infield Fly Rule", http://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=5322&context=penn_law_review http://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article... (As something of a joke, it starts off by giving a citation for the meaning of the word "The".)
- quirkot 9y agoKnowing how to apologize well, being successfully heartfelt, is a perennially too uncommon skill
- magic_beans 9y agoThis is really not relevant to anyone but healthcare professionals in the UK...
- DanBC 9y agoMany people need to apologise. Most of those people haven't just killed a relative of yours, or caused you physical harm - they've maybe deleted your data or closed your account or charged you too much.
- jessriedel 9y ago1. It says that an apology is not of itself an admission of guilt. But it doesn't say that an apology can't be used as one piece of evidence of negligence/wrong-doing. 2. This document conflates negligent/avoidable mistakes with situations where "there has been an unintended or unexpected event" and "includes recognised complications referred to in the consent process". In the latter cases, "I'm sorry" is an expression of sympathy, not a true apology. 3. These sort of apologies are required by statute. How meaningful can they be?
- alex_young 9y agoIs saying "I'm sorry" an admission of guilt somehow? Genuinely interested.
- davchana 9y agoI read somewhere that in Canada they passed a law that saying sorry in case of car accident does not mean you are at fault for that accident. Edit: found in this same thread at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14749389 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14749389
- asfdsfggtfd 9y agoSimilar in UK. Insurers tell you never to say sorry for a car accident.
- davchana 9y agoOpposite in Canada, you "can" say sorry, and it can not be used as admission of guilt or fault.
- losteverything 9y agoYes. It does. Or it is insincere. Saying "im sorry" or never saying "im sorry" has expansive meanings and "sides"- --- "My favorite mug is broken." "Im sorry." "Did you break it?" "No." "Then why apologize??!!!" ("I feel bad" is a better response) I was reared in an "im sorry" said often environment. It was used to placate and move past someone's issue. A phrase that was never meant but effective. I work now with a man that will always say (after hearing someone say im sorry), "Never say you're sorry. Its a sign of weakness." where i say im sorry to make others feel comfortable and to relate to complainers. A sibling had and will never say she is sorry. It is like a commandment. Thou shall not ever apologize. I do an im sorry test when i meet someone. Do they ever say that phrase? There is no real simple answer "does it mean guilt" but my decades of experience say "Yes" more than "no"
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Kenji 9y agoWhy be sorry? It's an admission of guilt and weakness. Take a page out of Donald Trump's book - never be sorry for anything. You do what you do and the others can deal with it. That gets you the presidency in today's world, it seems. I don't even want to get political here but the US elections have shown me how you get ahead in life.
- sctb 9y agoDo we really need another political flamewar here? I don't think we do.
- Kenji 9y agoAs mentioned in the post, it wasn't about politics. Republican or democrat, it doesn't matter. It was about human psychology and how apologizing is a hinderance to getting ahead.
- transitionnel 9y agoSometimes it is necessary to have a strong example of what is wrong to be able to define what right is. Most people on this forum are the type that can learn without touching the hot skillet for themselves, but we still benefit from helping others to not burn themselves.
- ineedasername 9y agoI know the context of the PDF is a little different, but towards making the sentiment more broadly applicable, I'd suggest that an ability to own up to a mistake of any sort is a very useful professional "skill". Lacking that skill, it can be much more difficult to correct a problem before it becomes an issue (You hesitate, because a change implies the pre-change situation was "wrong") Once there's an issue, it also makes the cleanup much harder, more awkward, etc. If you practice being comfortable saying something like, "I'm sorry, I overlooked X. I'm fixing it now, and will do my best to make sure it doesn't happen again" then your professional and personal life may be just a tad smoother. All of this implies, and requires, a mindset that is self-aware enough to evaluate itself. That can be the difficult part, that requires regular practice and resistance of instincts to go on the defensive and justify something, even if it was "right" at the time, if circumstances now show otherwise.
- blacksmythe 9y agoFor me the key work skill is a willingness to answer "I don't know". People that can't say that when they don't know the answer are inevitably pompous time-wasters.
- tkahnoski 9y agoSimilarly "I need help" and "How can I help?" are powerful things.
- beobab 9y agoI still have trouble with "I need help". I can work out what I need to do, but I have trouble doling out work in a way which means that it gets done to the specification I have got in my head, so I am not sure how to accept the offers of help. I think I need help writing specifications for my fellow developers.
- tkahnoski 9y agoThat would be the trick in delegation. Giving others the authority to get things done. I don't know the specifics of what your dealing with but it might be defining a common starting place like an API contract with some architectural/non-functional requirements on the implementation or more recurring things like coding style guides or other documentation.
- brandon272 9y agoAs a Canadian I already know all of this. Seriously though, I find myself apologizing profusely all of the time in ordinary conversation. Ordinarily I would think that it's a habit I need to curb, but the sorries are all genuine!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ryanbrunner 9y agoIn fact, in Ontario apologizing is protected by law as inadmissible as evidence of wrongdoing: https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/09a03 https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/09a03
- susam 9y agoOff-topic: I am reminded me of a few comic strips based on the Canadian "sorry". Soh-ry: http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2738 http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2738 I'm Canadian: http://explosm.net/comics/4272/ http://explosm.net/comics/4272/ Canadian Problems: http://completelyseriouscomics.com/?p=269 http://completelyseriouscomics.com/?p=269 The Canadian Front: http://www.escapistmagazine.com/articles/view/comicsandcosplay/comics/critical-miss/10318-The-Canadian-Front http://www.escapistmagazine.com/articles/view/comicsandcospl...
- BrendanD 9y agoSorry
- logicallee 9y ago(This comment is totally serious.) There is a chart with "Do say" and "Don't say" listening appropriate and inappropriate phrasing examples. I will ask an extreme question about it then make it a bit less reductionist. The chart doesn't say whether "I'm sorry I caused your son's death" falls under "Do say" or "Don't say". The thing is, although the above line exaggerates, if you are being transparent then there are a LOT of statements that reduce to "I (we) caused your son's death", but which are much more technical, i.e. regarding what was done. In this case it is unclear whether these are to be avoided or can be mentioned? It says "These steps include informing people about the incident" but it is not totally clear whether they mean it. Malpractice is the third-leading cause of death in the United States[1], so my question isn't an idle one. The PDF could be far more specific here. [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=malpractice+as+cause+of+death https://www.google.com/search?q=malpractice+as+cause+of+deat...
- verelo 9y agoLiterally 15 minutes ago I went to the neighbor behind my house [who complained in writing to me today] and apologized for letting construction workers work past 7pm in my backyard. I knew working past 7 was wrong, but no one had said anything and the project is behind schedule...so i let it slide. Today i had to go back and acknowledge that I was wrong to let that happen and that it won't happen again. I first wrote a note, but opted to deliver the message in person as they were home [also handed them the note at the end of it as it had my phone number and email on it should they need me]. At the end of the day, i think I've turned what was potentially the beginning of a bad situation into something that brought us closer together and more likely to communicate effectively in the future. Edit: One thing some people are saying further down is regarding admissions of guilt and i forgot to touch on that but it's clearly what I did here... I think we live in a society that is often scared that doing the right thing [often in the form of apologizing] will get us in trouble. Plenty of times this holds true, but i think if we all did it more often it might be for the greater good, plus sometimes getting in trouble teaches us a valuable lesson. Doing the right thing should be your priority, but when you mess up I feel it's very important to correct it or you will often suffer small but longer lasting side-effects [stress, bad relationships, etc].
- codyb 9y agoSimilarly to your seemingly effective quick nip in the butt, when it comes to the other end of the spectrum where you're the one who has a problem I've always found that being open, sincere, and forward quickly tends to be the best solution. Whether it's something as simple as someone humming at their chair in an open office layout or something a bit more complex such as you and your neighbors situation, presenting how feel in a clear and less emotional way always works out better than bottling up your feelings until one party blows up. People, for their part, seem to be genuinely reasonable and understanding when given the opportunity.
- tisdy 9y agoIt's "nip in the bud" EDIT: as in, cut off the flower bud before it blooms
- imhelpingu 9y agoIf I realize someone I know is one of those "never say you're sorry" people, I lose a little bit of respect for them.
- phyller 9y agoI lose a lot of respect for them, it's a symptom of so many (usually deep) flaws.
- roceasta 9y agoThe corollary of this is: don't use people's apologies against them. If they are sincere then accept. Don't exploit for political or financial gain or to make it look like you 'won'.
- turbulents 9y agoClinicians seem to think that everyone is out to get them, or at least want to project the image that they're so vulnerable to lawsuits. The truth is, there's no threat to them. Only the most open-and-shut malpractice cases can realistically be litigated, due to the $250k damages cap (in California). And because there's such limited upside for the attorneys, most victims can't even get representation. But despite all that, as someone who lost a family member due to physicians' mistakes, all we wanted was for the doctors to acknowledge what went wrong and then find a way to learn from it so it doesn't happen again to someone else. Victims understand--doctors are people and people make mistakes. I'm not the type to pursue litigation, but if anything, this code-of-silence/denial/cover-up routine only serves to encourage litigation as a way of making sure the problem is openly discussed.
- r0m4n0 9y agoI had a simple encounter a few months back with some coworkers that has had a lasting impact on me... mostly because I realized I apologize too often. Drinking wine in a group around a table. Someone stepped around me to reach something in the middle of the table. This person knocked my resting glass and it violently wobbled almost toppling over. My first reaction was saying “sorry” in which my coworker responded with the dirtiest look. Saying sorry resulted in an immediate acceptance of fault. I’ve also seen similar reactions after a motor accident I was involved in. I know this anecdote can’t be applied everywhere but the info here can’t either... Sometimes it’s best just to keep quiet... especially when the other party is on edge.
- bshimmin 9y agoSaying sorry is: always the right thing to do not an admission of liability acknowledges that something could have gone better the first step to learning from what happened and preventing it recurring This is very, very wobbly advice if you're dealing with a difficult client. I have had a number of situations where my natural English politeness has led to my offering apologies for situations that are 50% or less my own fault, and clients have leapt on this and translated it into everything being my fault. I very much steer clear of using the words "I'm sorry" or "I apologise" now, and usually opt for fairly bland passive voice phrases like "I appreciate that there has been some degree of frustration", followed by a summary of what both parties can do to improve matters. I also just flat-out disagree regarding liability, though I presume this must refer to a specific legal perspective in this particular context.
- taejo 9y ago> I also just flat-out disagree regarding liability, though I presume this must refer to a specific legal perspective in this particular context. The OP cites the Compensation Act 2006: > 2 Apologies, offers of treatment or other redress > An apology, an offer of treatment or other redress, shall not of itself amount to an admission of negligence or breach of statutory duty.
- jaimex2 9y agoYep, you usually know your clients enough though to know if they are completely toxic ass hats or someone you can build a sincere partnership with. Bureaucracy works wonders for ass hats, give them a vague, inconclusive report with worthless action points instead of an apology.
- bshimmin 9y agoAbsolutely. A decent client who sees you as a key partner in the success of whatever they want doing is absolutely worth apologising to - and they will apologise to you too if they get things wrong. A monster of a client will never apologise to you, and you should never apologise to them. And once whatever it is you're trying to do for them is done, walk away (after having done the usual "Hassle of dealing with this client" vs. "How much of the mortgage it will pay off" dance, of course).
- jjt-yn_t 9y agoSometimes it is necessary to have a strong example of what is wrong to be able to define what right is. Most people on this forum are the type that can learn without touching the hot skillet for themselves, but we still benefit from helping others to not burn themselves. ---- that is by ^^^^ transitionel, not my input. .... Sometimes it has happened that one was within a place were a strong example of wrong was transpiring ... to be able to define what right is. ' unilateral communication device' TV ' fair communication method ' both eyes directed toward another set of eyes' or, as praise was within the workplace: "good eye, jjt-yn_t" who by sheer luck escaped the 1970 on household 'rudeness newly normal' appliance to foster more freely a one on one, where expedient, objective sense of rulebook and next non missteps on the procedures of the day. .......................... -- apologizing in a small way. Here. ...........................
- jankotek 9y agoI disagree. I was in hospital around the time some bad stuff happened. My doctor was busy saying sorry, and neglected his other patiens.
- Spearchucker 9y agoSaying sorry has always been meaningless tokenism to me. We are what we do, and not what we say. However - An apology does indicate that the person saying sorry is able to admit to mistakes. This in turn shows an ability to learn, to try new things, and an open mind. At least more so than one who refuses to apologise under any circumstance.