5 ms·
Agreed. This article has some good thoughts but the "White" thing is annoying. There are plenty of white people whose life is not golden. In the end it comes do
by maxxxxx 9y ago
Agreed. This article has some good thoughts but the "White" thing is annoying. There are plenty of white people whose life is not golden. In the end it comes down to wealthy vs not wealthy. Race or gender doesn't matter.
- caseydurfee 9y agoFor anyone who didn't read the entire article, this is the part that these comments are complaining about: > Since all new creativity is held hostage in the hands of insensitive investors who promote the development of White business leaders to the exclusion of any other forms of creativity. Seventy five percent of all investment dollars are placed into the hands of White men. In the tech industry, most companies are run by, lead by, and pay the bulk of their company’s value to White men, the primary beneficiaries of such investment effort. 1. This certainly doesn't posit that all white people live perfect lives. 2. This is 74 words out of a 2600 word long essay, for crying out loud. 3. He's not wrong. If you're concerned with "wealthy vs not wealthy" it's entirely relevant that one particular cohort is far more likely to be in the wealthy group rather than other cohorts. I get so tired of people looking to get offended by things like this.
- Chaebixi 9y ago> This certainly doesn't posit that all white people live perfect lives. However, using a loaded term like "White men" is unnecessary and just serves to distract people with polarized culture war stuff.
- Apocryphon 9y agoThe implication is that a key demographic of the elite is enlarging their preexisting wealth. There's something feudal about a traditional noble class entrenching its power, no?
- Chaebixi 9y ago> There's something feudal about a traditional noble class entrenching its power, no? The "traditional noble class" is not "White men." In fact "White men" aren't even a class in that sense.
- Apocryphon 9y agoBut they're the primary demographic that the class was composed of. The article used it as shorthand. In a broad way, sure, something more precise could've been "East Coast old money WASPs"
- Chaebixi 9y agoIt's still very sloppy thinking.
- bllguo 9y agoSeems to me you're all irked by facts? Sure, plenty of white men aren't prospering. Irrelevant. A disproportionate amount of them are succeeding in the "algorithmic economy." I don't see why this is so taboo to point out. If race or gender doesn't matter, why do 75% of investment dollars go to white men? I personally doubt 75% of people in the "algorithmic economy" are white men. But I'd love to be corrected about this.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThat's all fine. Let's say you somehow make more investment go not to white men then wealth will still be concentrated in the hands of a few, maybe less white but still only a few. To me the fact that only a few really profit is the real problem.
- bllguo 9y agoI agree fully actually, and I don't want to distract from that. I just don't think we should shy away from talking about the makeup of this "feudal elite."
- maxxxxx 9y agoI am not offended by the mentioning of white people but I think it's a distraction. If we make the feudal elite more diverse it's still a feudal elite and that's the real problem in my view..
- owebmaster 9y agoThere are 2 scenarios: 1. wealth concentrated in the hands of a few white men 2. wealth concentrated in the hands of a few In the first scenario, it is difficult for white men to join the elite club while virtually impossible for non-White men (and women) to do so. In the second scenario at least one problem is fixed, as it gets equally difficult (not impossible) to everybody join the elite club, which is good enough to start.
- maxxxxx 9y ago