2 ms·
I would say that the approach for Asiana 214 looked bad from the moment it started, as the pilot felt uncomfortable performing a visual approach. Something has
by mikeash 9y ago
I would say that the approach for Asiana 214 looked bad from the moment it started, as the pilot felt uncomfortable performing a visual approach. Something has gone terribly wrong with training standards if a qualified airline pilot feels uncomfortable performing a visual approach in good weather into an airport with no tricky features.
Asiana wasn't a small error of judgment, it was a fundamental failure of training and over-reliance on automation which resulted in a pilot who didn't really know how to land.
- anigbrowl 9y agoThat's the systemic problem that led to the error; I worded it poorly but the 'small error' I'm referring to is how the pilot came in just a little too slow and low. It's easy to think of even worse things a pilot might do when panicking, eg breaking off the approach only to stall and land on the tail, for example. What I'm getting at is that a small error can have big consequences, and that this near-miss last week by the Air Canada plane is not something that should be dismissed as a non-story just because it was spotted and rectified in time. A collision avoided at the last minute is still indicative of a problem. If the Asiana pilot had stuck the landing that day but still felt uncomfortable, their training and operation culture at that firm would still have been problematic, they would just have gotten away with it for a little longer.
- mikeash 9y agoI see what you mean, and I agree. I'm sure the Asiana pilot (and many of his colleagues) had lots of uncomfortable but successful visual approaches before that. This event should definitely be investigated to identify any improvements that could be made. The tone of reporting seems to be going well beyond the severity of what actually happened, but it's not nothing.