6 ms·
It is a very Silicon Valley thing to assume that everyone else is an idiot and needs to be disrupted, with not a thought given as to why things are the way they
by dmitrygr 9y ago
It is a very Silicon Valley thing to assume that everyone else is an idiot and needs to be disrupted, with not a thought given as to why things are the way they are. Sort of funny to watch it from the side
I assure you that there is a reason AM is used. The reason is that in the case that two stations are transmitting, everyone will be aware of it and the stronger signal may be heard. This is not something that FM can guarantee. And a digital protocol requires a much better signal (where old analog tv gave snowy picture digital TV gives nothing). Not to mention the insane costs that digital radio retofitting would require of every single plane in the sky.
Edit: parent seems to have deleted his post. It previously asked condescendingly why we still use AM for comms in the air.
- wfunction 9y agoOkay, but do military-grade systems use AM like this too? I imagine their needs aren't any less than those of civilians, and I imagine they've gotten their communication systems to work just fine. So what's the issue?
- tuxxy 9y agoAirlines don't need military systems which are used more for confidentiality and OPSEC than other things. In the field, militaries tend to avoid radio communications for various tactical reasons. Submarines are a great example of this.
- ptaipale 9y agoMilitary-grade systems may not be any "less" but their needs and priorities may be different (e.g. secrecy). So different technology may be used, without any contradiction to why the current one is good for civilian air traffic.
- Aloha 9y agoGenerally, yes. There are some digital systems used for aircraft to aircraft communications and for a tactical datalink, but yes its AM for landing.
- wfunction 9y agoWow, did not know. Thank you.
- saurik 9y agoI don't understand what is so wrong with the transmission quality in that MP3. The issues I hear sound like they are simply due to trying to transmit from an extremely noisy environment (the cockpit of an airplane); they are mitigating the pilot's voice being entirely drowned in the background noise by placing the microphone right next to their mouth, but that then causes the sound of their breath to be extremely noticeable. I am not sure how to fix these issues but they don't seem to have anything to do with the usage of AM radio.
- wfunction 9y agoI wasn't complaining about the transmission quality, I was just trying to understand the parent comment. The person who complained about the former was someone else.
- saurik 9y agoSorry; I misunderstood (and to be honest even after my tenth reread am still having a difficult time parsing...) the end of your comment about the "issue" :(.
- wfunction 9y agoOK, I'll clarify. Someone suggested non-AM transmission has problems X/Y/Z; I suggested that I expect non-AM transmission has overcome problems X/Y/Z in the military, and therefore I'm not convinced this is the real issue preventing non-AM communication. I was not discussing whether we or not we need non-AM communication in the first place.
- amenghra 9y agoIn helicopters/tanks, some people wear a sensor around their neck which picks up vocal cord vibrations without pickup any breathing or external sound.
- klodolph 9y ago"Military-grade" systems use complicated techniques like frequency-hopping spread spectrum. They're designed to be encrypted and resistant to jamming. The jamming resistance is not something we care about (if someone is jamming the signal you just make them turn off their radio), and the whole point of encryption is to prevent interoperability when you don't have the right key. So sure, you could pay a bunch of extra money for military features and end up with a product that is even less what you want than AM radio. And then you'd have to retrofit everything with these systems. AM is wonderful. You put a bunch of people on the same channel and it just works.
- wfunction 9y ago> "Military-grade" systems use complicated techniques like frequency-hopping spread spectrum Note that that technology has been around since World War II. And fun fact, while we're on that topic, this page is worth a read: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedy_Lamarr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedy_Lamarr
- tjl 9y agoI love that a technique that's so widely used now was the co-invented by a movie star. It's also used in cell phones.
- Someone 9y ago"The jamming resistance is not something we care about (if someone is jamming the signal you just make them turn off their radio)" Evie might know this, too, so I think you should be concerned about jamming. Luckily, AM provides jamming resistance, since Evie would have to bring a powerful transmitter to be loud enough to drown out the other signals. Nevertheless, I think large airports should have fast response teams who can rapidly fix the position of a jammer and silence it, if needed. If Evie could effectively take out, say, the main airports of LA and SF for a few hours with a few strong AM transmitters, I doubt all will end well.
- klodolph 9y ago
- acchow 9y ago> It is a very Silicon Valley thing to assume that everyone else is an idiot and needs to be disrupted, with not a thought given as to why things are the way they are. This kind of thinking has also lead to a ton of success in Silicon Valley. See Tesla for example.
- coldtea 9y ago>This kind of thinking has also lead to a ton of success in Silicon Valley. See Tesla for example. Well, not exactly a role model for success. 2016 was the first time they made any profit in all those years -- and its uncertain if 2017 will follow. And it might still be beaten up in all its markets (electric cars and eventually self-driving ones), not a sure winner yet.
- justinjlynn 9y agoA broken clock is correct at least once a day.
- adrianN 9y agoDigital only require better signal if you want high data rates. With analog signal the human has to do the error correction, i.e. extract the signal from the snowy picture. Digital signals can use error correcting codes to get the same result. The more bits you have for error correction, the better your recovery can be.
- mikeash 9y agoI hate aircraft radios. I'm sure the guys in big planes have better equipment and don't suffer from this as much, but when I fly small planes, it's a complete mess of wildly different volume levels (it's fun to turn up the volume to hear a quiet person, then get blasted by the next transmission), interference, and irrelevant transmissions from a hundred miles away. Don't get me wrong, they get the job done and any change would have to be very carefully considered, but I'm always happy when I get far enough from the airport that I can turn the damned thing off. I think a digital system could be done much better than what we have. But I'm sure it's not worth the huge effort it would take to design and build.
- dmitrygr 9y agoeven KY-97A from decades ago handles this for you
- Aloha 9y agoThis is a lack of AGC (automatic gain control) - usually even on the (shortwave and Ham) radios I've seen it on, its switchable, otherwise (in certain conditions, like rapid fading) you can end up with gain pumping, which can sound like the audio is surging. What it normally does is reduce gain on high strength signals, and increases it on weak ones to give a constant volume level. I'm honestly surprised the radios in general aviation craft are not so equipped, as its generally a standard part of most AM radios.
- mikeash 9y agoThanks, now I know what to look for next time I go equipment shopping. I'm sure many GA radios have this, but I'm using particularly low-end radios since space and power consumption are more important for what I do. Still won't fix getting an earful about skydivers at an airport a hundred miles away, but it would be an improvement!