6 ms·
> The Seattle City Council on Monday unanimously approved a plan to levy a 2.25 percent tax on the income of residents earning $250,000 or more annually. The Co
by jstanley 9y ago
> The Seattle City Council on Monday unanimously approved a plan to levy a 2.25 percent tax on the income of residents earning $250,000 or more annually. The Council estimates that the tax would bring in an additional $140 million each year.
In other words, they're offering a $140 million incentive for the high-earning residents of Seattle to move out. This is a good way to get "brain drain".
- breadbox 9y agoMore like an "empathy-deficiency drain", and I have no problem with that.
- arjunbanker 9y agonailed it ^^
- chronic6a5 9y agoSoon, there will be even more homeless. I'll take my money (i.e., tax payment) elsewhere, which Seattle just so happens to need. Hopefully someone else will pay for it. Best of luck to the city of Seattle. They will truly need it.
- flukus 9y agoConsidering there are places on earth with much lower taxes than you've been paying, I really doubt you'll move because of this.
- fleshBot 9y agoIf not submitting to having my income expropriated at the barrel of a politician's gun means I lack empathy then you are using a very strange definition for the word "empathy".
- toomuchtodo 9y agoYou earn your income only because the framework of government and society have provided the ability for you to do so.
- jstanley 9y agoHow can one tell when one earns one's money because of government's intervention, and when one earns one's money despite government's intervention?
- breadbox 9y agoYou are supported by the social systems that surround you. They aren't conjured out of thin air. But if you don't want to support them in turn, then you are hardly being forced to. Just move somewhere else. There are a lot of cities in this country.
- stmfreak 9y agoThere are a lot of so-called "needy" who are also supported by these social systems. Where are the calls to get them to pay their "fair" share?
- breadbox 9y agoThere are no "calls" for them to pay their fair share because for the most part they already are, in many cases well more than they can afford. Your comment also implicitly presumes that the wealthy were already paying their fair share, and this is some extra burden arbitrarily heaped upon them by an unkind majority.
- fleshBot 9y agoHow much, exactly, is "society's" fair share of someone else's money? This is the problem. There is this assumption that taxes are used to care for the destitute. Absolutely, some amount of taxes do go to that end. However, I've worked enough government contracts to know that the vast majority of that money goes to providing middle-class incomes for people in government who otherwise would not be making that sort of money because of a distinct lack of intelligence, competence, or diligence.
- conanbatt 9y agoAs I mentioned in other posts, the city government is having half a billion extra cash every year for the past 5 years. The city has a lot of money to support and expand its infrastructure. 8% increase YoY in tax revenue sounds like they are not running into money problems.
- xenadu02 9y agoa) In real life try explaining to your SO/kids that they must abandon their existing life because you want to save 2.25%. b) Assuming there was some flight out of the city good news! We can solve this by increasing state and federal income taxes. We can even tax capital gains and dividends at income tax rates. There is more than enough money to pay for the things we need to pay for. (It is probably wise fiscal policy to exclude the first 1 million in investment income from capital gains as a way of encouraging small investors and those just starting out. If I were King I'd exclude the first 1 million in wages too, with a graduated phase-in and make it up by taxing people with $1 billion or more in assets+income combined).
- imaginenore 9y agoThe ones rich enough can simply move their residence outside, and simply rent wherever.
- mozumder 9y agoOne person's tax is another person's "things and services government can buy for cheaper than I can." They've just given a $140 million incentive for people to move into the city.
- jdonaldson 9y ago$140 million is roughly the cost overruns for the Bertha project. Sometimes you're not getting goods and services, but rather someone's costly mistake.
- stephengillie 9y agoThis will just push more across Lake Washington. Will Amazon start a competitor to the Microsoft Connector (bus service)? Or will they shift some operations over here? Why not both?
- Jach 9y agoJust when I had started to hope Eastside property values were reaching a peak and nearing a correction... My intuition says Issaquah will be the next big hub once Kirkland and Redmond saturate some more, but even the median home price there is $700k already.
- rndmize 9y agoCA has an income tax that's 8% or higher above $40k. If this caused some kind of brain drain, I'd expect to see smart/wealthy people leaving the state. The last 30 years have been the opposite, with the Bay Area and SV growing in size and importance year over year. Further, when discussion of people leaving the state comes up, I hear constantly about cost of living and housing, never about taxes.
- jblow 9y agoI moved out of California because of taxes. Top tax bracket is now 13.3%.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoAnd yet Silicon Valley/SF is still bursting at the seams.
- lj3 9y ago> In fact, in some parts of the Bay Area — including Santa Clara, San Mateo and Marin counties — already more people are leaving than arriving, according to the estimates released Thursday, which cover the period from July 1, 2015, to June 30, 2016. The same would be true in San Francisco if it weren’t for the high number moving in from abroad. source: http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Bay-Area-population-growth-slows-some-counties-11021334.php http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Bay-Area-population-gr...
- toomuchtodo 9y agoHave land values decreased? And I don't mean commercial lease rates, I'm talking actual residential real estate. If not, people still want to live there.
- randyrand 9y agoFor now.
- 9y ago
- conanbatt 9y agoThey do this after so many companies decided to move to seattle. Very greedy.
- petraeus 9y agoRich / Successful people don't leave money on the table lmao